Deutsche Welle/Jack Flanagan: Initial coin offerings: What are they?

Deutsche Welle
Language

    Business

Business
Initial coin offerings: What are they?

There's a new trend that showcases the way digital currencies can be mobilized as an alternative avenue for funding, in ways that traditional tender cannot. Jack Flanagan takes a closer look at how that works.

Symbolic Bitcoin (Getty Images/D. Kitwood)   

The startling increase in the value of Bitcoin has re-energized speculation of whether or not the currency has a future, or is just a fintech bubble. In either case, digital currencies continue to grow and diversify, offering new opportunities and fertile ground for innovation.

Besides Bitcoin, most prevalent in 2017 was the emergence of the ICO (Initial Coin Offering). This new trend showcases the way digital currencies can be mobilized as an alternative avenue for funding, in ways that traditional tender cannot, and how fruitful that can be.

Read also: Why Bitcoin is valued in Zimbabwe

At this point in time, ICOs have been used in two ways. In the first scenario, a limited number of so-called "altcoins" are traded for legal tender or cryptocurrency, like Bitcoin or Ether. Each time a coin is bought, it further drives up their value. Investors are hoping as many coins are bought as possible and the company thrives, in the hopes of selling the coins later.

In this way, the coins seem to function as regular stock. However, they have an extra advantage, which is that they allow entrepreneurs to cast a much wider net in their search for investment, and not to be limited to traditional financing.

Going beyond crowdfunding

Furthermore, unlike crowdfunding, ownership of these assets especially incentivizes investors to spread the word about the company, in order to increase the value. At the moment, these investors largely come from within the cryptocurrency community.

The exact nature of the coins may vary depending on the company. ICOs may offer a limited number of coins, or make the coins only last over a set period.

The other function, which may be termed "utility tokens" or "coins," are traded specifically on business platforms. Investors may use these tokens to purchase the company's goods or services, or retain the coins, in the hope that they will grow in value. Companies benefit from such an economy: retaining coins increases their value by lowering the number on the market, further driving up their value.

Read also: EU approves cryptocurrency clampdown to fight terrorism financing

Troy Norcross, director of Blockchain Rookies, which offers strategic consulting on this topic, uses a laundromat analogy to give a bit of clarity. Laundromats in the US are often coin-operated. The coins are purchased with US dollars, but only have one function: to be used in the machines.

Theoretically, if you were to buy a lot of coins, the number in circulation would shrink: this would then increase their value. Ideally, for you the investor, the laundromat company would also build more laundromats, further increasing the value of your coins (and your potential for profit).

Tokens for cloud storage space

STORJ, in the US, operates in this way, except, instead of clothes washing, they offer cloud storage space and Storj Tokens with which to rent it. If you offer your own computer hardware for the service to use as data storage, you are paid in these tokens, which accumulate in the value the more it's used.
Kryptowährung Ether (picture-alliance/NurPhoto/J. Arriens)

Ether is a token in a network computing system (Ethereum) which allows the cryptocurrency to actually be used in traded

Finally, it is the blockchain, the technology most often linked to Bitcoin, which attracts startups, hungry for funding. More than half of ICOs have taken place over the Ethereum blockchain, which features smart contracts that execute once certain conditions are met, making it ideal for the exchange of currency in speculative situations.

Each contract is public, and therefore the community is witness to any transaction that takes place. This safety, and the promise of progress and development, is a key motivator for adopters.

These features aside, ICOs are attractive to small businesses because they bypass many of the traditional hurdles to funding: they don't require angel investors or venture capitalists, who typically ask for equity or a place on the board. This appeals to entrepreneurs protective of their idea, and concerned that "too many cooks spoil the broth." However, it is exactly this that has encouraged some other observers to be skeptical.

The explosion of popularity in ICOs has encouraged rumors of a bubble. While there had been some early coin offerings, notably Ethereum in 2014, which raised 3,700 Bitcoin, the second half of 2017 saw a frenzied activity as entrepreneurs and investors latched onto the potential of this idea. For example, in September, instant messaging app developer Kik raised almost $100m (€82.9m) with an ICO. Over that period, more than 400 ICOs have been conducted, and $2.3billion raised. Such a flurry of activity, and vast movements of money in a relatively small community, has observers worried of a sudden collapse.

Criminal energy

There have also been concerns over scams. On the Etherium blockchain, according to Cointelegraph, one in 10 transactions are scams, which they discuss as "phishing, Ponzi schemes," or otherwise. That number, it's worth pointing out, is roughly the same as for Bitcoin, which has a global average of 9.49 percent (Kaspersky, 2017).

Phishing on a blockchain means using standard scams, like phony "lost password" emails, to obtain private keys for the blockchain, which then funnel coins to the hacker's wallet. It can also mean sending a false website, where an investor inputs their crypto details, which are then lost to the scammer. This is avoided by having many different wallets: some for exchanges and payments, and wallets for holding currency.
Bitcoin development

However, if someone on the chain is hacked, they have little recourse. The decentralized and largely unregulated nature of digital currencies, which is a major part of their appeal, leaves victims with few or no ways of responding after an attack. That is part of the regulatory mission now of governmental financial bodies (and, indeed, the digital currencies community). For example, the Securities and Exchange Commission in the US is currently working on guidelines and information to help educated investors.

Read also: Cryptocurrency overcomes roadblocks

Other countries have simply banned ICOs until proper regulation is up and running: China and South Korea, for instance. In other countries like the United Arab Emirates and France, 2017 saw guidelines or placeholder regulations rolled out to make things safer for investors.

In Germany, at the moment, it's unclear whether or not current legislation applies. Some laws there regulate digital currency and the transfer of legal tender or e-money, but neither directly affects an ICO in Germany. However, an ICO may require a prospectus for its tokens, under regulation of financial securities though this depends on the nature of the coin, for instance, if the investor receives dividends.

Despite these problems, the digital currencies community remains confident. Norcross reports that an influx of enthusiastic investors earlier in 2017 showcased the notable flaws in an ICO: lack of guidelines, legal recourse and, perhaps fundamentally, the expertise of angel investors and institutional capital.

Investment in some companies hit a snag where, afterward, it became apparent the idea itself was not grounded in reality, or the team was inexperienced. In which circumstances, the expertise in traditional financial circles would have been more valuable than the no-strings-attached finance of an ICO.

Yet Norcross is optimistic about the future. "In my particular view, there are, in theory, a lot of companies that could do an ICO well. If the technology is legitimate, and the company naturally operates in the blockchain space, they will do absolutely fine. The feeding frenzy of 2017 has let the air out of the bubble and we're starting to see the market stabilize. More regulation will further improve the situation for everybody. The early days, where we could raise 5 million in 30 days without due diligence, are gone."

    Bitcoin (picture-alliance/dpa/J. Kalaene)
    Bitcoin: Where it came from and where it's headed
    Good time to start a currency

    Introduced in 2009, Bitcoin was the world's first decentralized digital currency. It quickly gained traction amid lingering uncertainty in the wake of financial crisis. Designed to be as rare as gold, Bitcoin was created to have a maximum of 21 million "coins." Initially worth just a fraction of a cent, by February 2011 the currency had gained parity with the US dollar, then it really took off.
    Tesla CEO Elon Musk (Reuters/AAP/B. Macmahon)
    Bitcoin: Where it came from and where it's headed
    An anonymous founder

    The name Satoshi Nakamoto is synonymous with Bitcoin. It is said to be the alias for an unknown IT whizz who invented the cryptocurrency. But despite claiming to be a 30-something Japanese national, it is generally thought that several computer science experts created the technology behind the digital coin. One rumor even suggested that Tesla chief Elon Musk is the real Satoshi, which he denied.
    Bitcoin sign (DW/M. Sevcenko)
    Bitcoin: Where it came from and where it's headed
    So no coins then?

    Instead of being printed like dollars and euros, each Bitcoin is created on a global network of computers and verified by the system rather than a bank. There are no transaction fees. The smallest amount you can buy is a "Satoshi" or one-hundred-millionth of a Bitcoin. Purchases can be made anonymously and even at digital currency ATMs. When you buy Bitcoin, it is often stored in a digital wallet.
    Bitcoin Mine (Getty Images/AFP/M. Zmeyev)
    Bitcoin: Where it came from and where it's headed
    Complex puzzles

    To ensure that not too much Bitcoin comes into circulation, a process called mining was created where blocks of transactions could only be processed once a difficult math problem was solved by geeks. The puzzles are becoming so complex that bigger and bigger computers are being utilized to decipher them. That's led to concerns about the amount of electricity used to handle Bitcoin transactions.
    Islamic State fighters in Syria (picture-alliance/Zuma Press/M. Dairieh)
    Bitcoin: Where it came from and where it's headed
    Are Bitcoin fortunes legit?

    Due to its anonymous nature, Bitcoin's success is likely being fueled by organized crime, including money laundering and the purchase of illegal goods. The currency is also being targeted by cybercriminals. A recent hack blamed on North Korea forced a South Korean digital currency exchange into bankruptcy. Reports suggest the "Islamic State" armed group used Bitcoin to receive funds to buy arms.
    Ethereum digital currency (picture-alliance/NurPhoto/J. Arriens)
    Bitcoin: Where it came from and where it's headed
    Bitcoin leads, others follow

    Bitcoin is the largest of all the cryptocurrencies and its incredible rise has spawned many imitators. Other large digital cash creators include Ethereum, Zcash, Bitcoin Cash, Ripple and Litecoin. As of November 2017, their number had swelled to 1,324. Hundreds of others have attempted and failed to launch their own digital coins. The market is now coming under increasing scrutiny by regulators.
    Bitcoin on a motherboard (Reuters/D. Ruvic)
    Bitcoin: Where it came from and where it's headed
    Watch it skyrocket

    2017 was a stratospheric year for Bitcoin. Worth close to $1,000 in January, some twelve months later it had scaled to an all-time high of $19,784. Despite much skepticism, the currency started to see serious interest from institutional investors. Two exchanges began Bitcoin futures trading, allowing speculators to punt on the incredible volatility in the value of the cryptocurrency.
    Joseph E. Stiglitz Professor Columbia University (World Economic Forum/Benedikt von Loebell)
    Bitcoin: Where it came from and where it's headed
    Warnings abound

    From central banks to respected investors, almost the entire financial establishment warned of a massive Bitcoin bubble, which they said can only end in disaster for holders of the digital currency. Among them was Nobel prize-winning economist Joseph Stiglitz who said Bitcoin "ought to be outlawed." Jamie Dimon, the CEO of JPMorgan Chase labeled those who buy the currency "stupid."
    Bitcoin logo (Imago/imagebroker/M. Weber)
    Bitcoin: Where it came from and where it's headed
    The shape of things to come?

    Just before Christmas 2017, Bitcoin saw a dramatic rally, topping out at nearly $20,000 before losing a third of its value in just five days. More intense volatility followed early in the New Year, only to be reversed when it plummeted by almost half. Are we in for an even bigger rollercoaster ride if Wall Street adopts Bitcoin in 2018? Or could another coin usurp the original currency disrupter?

◀
1 / 9
▶
DW recommends
Bitcoin takes flight again after overcoming roadblocks

After surging through the $5,000 level last week for the first time, bitcoin seems to have left behind a summer of uncertainty. But can the virtual currency sustain its record run amid increasing government regulation? (17.10.2017)
Why bitcoin is valued in Zimbabwe

This year has seen cryptocurrency bitcoin shatter all growth expectations, continuing to defy dark predictions. In Zimbabwe, its growth has been particularly striking, all the more so amid recent political turbulence. (20.11.2017)
Bitcoin: EU approves cryptocurrency clampdown to combat terrorism financing

The European Union has agreed to implement stricter rules on exchange platforms that deal with virtual currencies, including bitcoin. The measure is part of an effort to prevent terrorist financing and money laundering. (16.12.2017)
Bitcoin: where it came from and where it's headed

The booming cryptocurrency has a cryptic backstory and a perplexing modus operandi. Following a year of particularly tumultuous growth, DW asks where Bitcoin will go next. Can it sustain its incredible ascent? (22.12.2017)
Audios and videos on the topic
Bitcoin's popularity on the rise

    Date 08.01.2018
    Author Jack Flanagan
    Keywords
    ICO, initial coin offering, Bitcoin, Ether, cryptocurrency
    Share

Related content
Bitcoin takes flight again after overcoming roadblocks 17.10.2017
Bitcoin

After surging through the $5,000 level last week for the first time, bitcoin seems to have left behind a summer of uncertainty. But can the virtual currency sustain its record run amid increasing government regulation?
Bitcoin value falls dramatically in 48 hours 10.11.2017
DW Made in Germany - Bitcoin

Has bitcoin finally hit the ceiling many have predicted it would? Although its price fluctuations are notoriously volatile, a slide in value of $1,000 (€859) in less than 48 hours has raised a few eyebrows.
Digital residency pays off big for Estonia 29.12.2017
Estland elektronische Aufenthaltskarte

Estonia is expected to get a 100-to-one-euro return on investment for its e-Residency program, which lets anybody start a business from afar. It is even planning to launch ‘estcoins,’ its own cryptocurrency.
DW Business – Europe & Africa
04.2015 DW Business Sendungslogo   

Latvian ECB member accused of bribery - Swedish students develop next-gen electric car

The week in review
04.2015 DW Business Sendungslogo   

A quick rundown of business events of the week

The week in review
Self serve checkout: Germany fines man €208,000 for stealing calf liver
A man in the fruit and vegetable section of a grocery store   

A court in Munich has fined a 58-year-old man €208,000 for passing calf liver as fruit at a grocery store. The court said the fine was justified since the man earned tens of thousands of euros a month.
Who are the Russian trolls indicted by the US?
Computer-Tastatur (picture-alliance/dpa/J. Lübke)   

Journalist and whistleblower Lyudmila Savchuk once worked at Russia's notorious St. Petersburg-based troll factory hoping to expose the operation. She spoke to DW about the recent indictments of Russian meddling.
Suspects arrested in theft, slaughter of pregnant Berlin petting zoo goat
Angora goat (picture-alliance/dpa/Arco Images GmbH)   

The brutal killing of a pregnant Angora goat comes weeks after a pregnant sheep was found hacked to death in the bushes. Two men have been arrested.
© 2018 Deutsche Welle Contact | Legal notice | Privacy Policy Desktop version
×
DW
Deutsche WelleFREE - In Google Play
VIEW