Wednesday, 25 July 2018

Instead Of Focusing On Mrs. Jean Mensa's Person, Why Does The NDC Not Expend Its Considerable Energies Building An Electoral Command Centre That Will Make Future Elections Impossible To Rig?

Sometimes it is pretty hard to fathom what drives those who currently dominate Ghana's largest opposition party, the National Democratic Congress (NDC). Why must they always be so negative in reacting to controversial actions taken by the ruling New Patriotic Party (NPP) - when the most sensible response is to offer smarter alternative-nation-building-ideas that will resonate with  even school-going children: and win the admiration of their parents too? Haaba.

Take the issue of Mrs. Charlotte Osei's dismissal from her position as chairperson of the Electoral Commission - by a president acting lawfully in accordance with constitutional provisions. Why fight a running propaganda battle over her dismissal, when that much-abused and unfairly treated lady, herself, has accepted her fate, and is living with it stoically? Ebeeii.

And, why focus on Mrs. Jean Mensa's person, and her alleged friendship with President Akufo-Addo (something to which after all Mrs. Charlotte Osei too admitted at a point in time when she came under a barrage of criticism by extremist NPP politicians - after her nomination by President Mahama as the next Electoral Commissioner following Dr. Afari-Djan's retirement - when she pointed out that between President John Mahama and then presidential candidate Nana Akufo-Addo, it was the latter who was her friend)?

The question to ponder over that is: Is the most sensible national-interest  consideration,  for politicians who truly care about Mother Ghana, not to rather urge leaders of all the political parties in Ghana to help create an Electoral Commission that is truly fit-for-purpose, going forward? One knows that it is virtually impossible to get through to most members of our nation's hard-of-hearing  political class, but those who now dominate the NDC ought to  expend  their considerable energies focusing on the task of building a cutting-edge electoral Command Centre, underpinned by blockchain technology, which will make the rigging of future elections in Ghana an impossibility. Haaba. Hmmm, Oman Ghana - eyeasem o: asem kesie ebeba debi ankasa.


The New York Times/Natan Sharansky: The Essay That Helped Bring Down The Soviet Union

The New York Times
nytimes.com
Opinion | The Essay That Helped Bring Down the Soviet Union
6-8 minutes

It championed an idea at grave risk today: that those of us lucky enough to live in open societies should fight for the freedom of those born into closed ones.

By Natan Sharansky

Mr. Sharansky, the author of “The Case for Democracy,” is a former spokesman for Andrei Sakharov. He spent nine years in Soviet prisons and the gulag.

    July 20, 2018

Andrei Sakharov in Moscow in 1973.CreditAssociated Press

Fifty years ago this Sunday, this paper devoted three broadsheet pages to an essay that had been circulating secretly in the Soviet Union for weeks. The manifesto, written by Andrei Sakharov, championed an essential idea at grave risk today: that those of us lucky enough to live in open societies should fight for the freedom of those born into closed ones. This radical argument changed the course of history.

Sakharov’s essay carried a mild title — “Thoughts on Progress, Peaceful Coexistence and Intellectual Freedom” — but it was explosive. “Freedom of thought is the only guarantee against an infection of mankind by mass myths, which, in the hands of treacherous hypocrites and demagogues, can be transformed into bloody dictatorships,” he wrote. Suddenly the Soviet Union’s most decorated physicist became its most prominent dissident.
3 pages, 1.84 MB

For this work and other “thought crimes” the Soviet authorities stripped Sakharov of his honors, imprisoned many of his associates and, eventually, exiled him to Gorky.

In 1968, when this work was published, I was a 20-year-old mathematician studying at the Moscow equivalent of M.I.T. Although we dared not discuss it, my peers and I lived a life of double-think: toeing the Communist Party line in public, thinking independently in private. Like so many others, I read Sakharov’s essay in samizdat — a typewritten copy duplicated secretly, spread informally and read hungrily.

Its message was unsettling and liberating: You cannot be a good scientist or a free person while living a double life. Knowing the truth while collaborating in the regime’s lies only produces bad science and broken souls.

Sakharov’s essay, which coincided with the Prague Spring, helped energize democratic dissident movements that were just budding in a post-Stalinist world. The largest of these was one I would soon join: the so-called refusenik movement to allow the Soviet Union’s long-oppressed Jews the freedom to emigrate.

Some Russian dissidents mistrusted the Zionist movement as particularistic and unpatriotic, fearing it would distract from their broader human rights agenda. Not Sakharov. He supported the refuseniks because he recognized the right to emigrate as a gateway to democratic entitlement that opens everyone to embracing freedom in a closed society.

By the mid-1970s I was serving as Sakharov’s spokesman, and I remember after yet another friend of ours had been sentenced to prison, he told me: “They want us to believe there’s no chance of success. But whether or not there’s hope for change is not the question. If you want to be a free person, you don’t stand up for human rights because it will work, but because it is right. We must continue living as decent people.”

Sakharov’s decency made him a moral compass orienting not just the East, but also the West. He insisted that international relations should be contingent on a country’s domestic behavior — and that such a seemingly idealistic stance was ultimately pragmatic. “A country that does not respect the rights of its own people will not respect the rights of its neighbors,” he often explained.

As Sakharov and his fellow dissidents in the 1970s and ’80s challenged a détente disconnected from human rights, Democrats and Republicans of conscience followed suit. Jimmy Carter and Ronald Reagan disagreed about many specific policies, but both presidents linked human rights and foreign policy. President Carter treated Soviet dissidents not as distractions but as respected partners in a united struggle for freedom. President Reagan went further, tying the fate of specific dissidents to America’s relations with what he called the “evil empire.”

Approaching the fight to win the Cold War as a human rights crusade as well as a national security priority energized Americans. It reminded them that, regardless of the guilt and defeatism of the Vietnam War or the shame and cynicism of Watergate, the country remained a beacon of liberty.

This anniversary of Andrei Sakharov’s heroic essay comes during similarly dark days for the United States.

Despite the dramatic discontinuities between Donald Trump and Barack Obama, in divorcing human rights from foreign policy President Trump is following President Obama’s lead.

Mr. Obama repeatedly prioritized engaging dictatorial regimes rather than challenging their human rights records. His eagerness to strike a nuclear deal with Iran muffled his moral voice during Iran’s Green Revolution of 2009. And he refused to make diplomatic progress conditional on demands that Iran stop supporting terror globally or executing its own people at home.

Mr. Trump has taken America’s human-rights-free foreign policy to absurd new heights. His assertion that North Koreans support Kim Jong-un with “great fervor” undermined America’s moral standing, sabotaged North Korean dissidents and legitimized an evil dictator. His shocking refusal to confront President Vladimir Putin of Russia over his country’s blatant interference in the 2016 United States presidential election highlights his unwillingness to protect Americans’ democratic rights, let alone Russians’ human rights.

The wisdom of Sakharov’s essay may not be in fashion these days, but the truth it contains is eternal. People all over the world are waiting for an American leader to recover it.

Natan Sharansky, the author of “The Case for Democracy,” is a former spokesman for Andrei Sakharov. He spent nine years in Soviet prisons and the gulag. This essay was written with Gil Troy, a historian at McGill University and the author of “The Zionist Ideas.”

A version of this article appears in print on
July 21, 2018

, on Page

A

21

of the New York edition

with the headline:

The Manifesto That Crippled the Soviets
. Order Reprints | Today’s Paper | Subscribe

The Daily Beast/Bethany Allen-Ebrahimian: China Built an Army of Influence Agents in the U.S.

The Daily Beast

RISING TIDE
China Built an Army of Influence Agents in the U.S.
The Russians may be getting all the attention for influencing American opinion and pocdlicy. But Beijing has been at it for decades.
Bethany Allen-Ebrahimian
Bethany Allen-Ebrahimian
07.18.18 4:49 AM ET
exclusive
Photo Illustration by Elizabeth Brockway/The Daily Beast

In May, a classified Australian government report revealed that the Chinese Communist Party had spent the last decade attempting to influence every level of that nation’s government and politics.

“Unlike Russia, which seems to be as much for a good time rather than a long time, the Chinese are strategic, patient, and they set down foundations of organizations and very consistent narratives over a long period of time,” said the author of the report in March.

“They put an enormous amount of effort into making sure we don’t talk about what it’s doing.”

Commissioned by Australian Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull in the wake of a series of Chinese influence scandals that rocked Australian politics last year, the report, compiled under the auspices of an intelligence agency, examined Chinese attempts to influence politicians, political donations, media, and academia.

But such a report could easily be written about the United States—and may soon be. U.S. intelligence agencies have long tracked Beijing’s clandestine attempts at political influence inside the United States.

And they don’t like what they see. One former CIA analyst put it bluntly: Beijing’s agents in this country aim “to turn Americans against their own government’s interests and their society’s interests.”

Unlike Australia, however, American society has yet to engage in a broad public debate about the issue. Most Americans have never even heard of the main conduit of such influence, an obscure but sprawling Chinese Communist Party agency known as the United Front.

The organization has been around in one form or another since the World War II era. Mao famously referred to the United Front as one of the Communist Party’s “magic weapons.” These days, United Front operations sometimes resemble the CIA’s soft attempts to buy off, co-opt, or coerce influential community leaders. Sometimes it functions like a booster club for pro-party locals, or like an advocacy group trying to sway public opinion. Sometimes it works in concert with China’s traditional intelligence agencies, such as the Ministry of State Security, to gather information or apply pressure. And United Front networks may sometimes play a role in facilitating intellectual property theft and soft intelligence collection, though that role isn’t always clear.

What is clear is that the United Front is active in dozens of U.S. cities and has been for years, with almost no one the wiser.

Standing in front of a ruby-red backdrop, a Chinese diplomat’s hand resting lighting on her lower back, He Xiaohui looked radiant. The Chinese-American woman, a local activist in Maryland politics, had just been appointed president of the National Association for China’s Peaceful Unification in Washington, D.C., which describes itself as a non-profit for Chinese-Americans dedicated to the eventual unification of China with Taiwan.

He Xiaohui posed for a photo with the previous president, who was symbolically handing over an object to her. Presiding over the January 13 handover was Li Kexin, a high-profile minister at the Chinese embassy in Washington. Li stood between two, a hand on each of their backs.

“No matter the time, no matter the situation, the Chinese government and 1.4 billion Chinese people will always have your back,” said Li in his remarks. “I believe that this new cohort of leadership will continue… to unite the power of overseas Chinese, and hold high the banners of anti-independence and peaceful unification.”

On paper, peaceful reunification associations, such as the Washington, D.C. branch, are independent from both the Chinese government and, largely, each other. But functionally, these associations are the United Front’s most ubiquitous outposts in the United States. And as the leader of one of the oldest such associations in the world, He, who also goes by Helen, serves as a top point of contact between the Chinese Communist Party in Beijing and the Chinese-American community in greater Washington, D.C.

“Peaceful reunification associations”—the term refers to Beijing’s intent to obtain sovereignty over Taiwan—have a close relationship with the United Front Work Department, in some cases functioning almost as an extension of its Overseas Chinese Affairs Office, the government agency that focuses on outreach to the Chinese diaspora. (Sun Chunlan, who until 2017 directed the United Front Work Department, simultaneously served as the executive vice president of the China Council for the Promotion of Peaceful Unification in Beijing.)

The peaceful reunification association has established chapters in over 70 countries, according to the organization’s website. In the United States, there are more than 30 chapters in cities across the country, including San Francisco, Chicago, Houston, New York, and Washington, D.C. And while “peaceful reunification” was one of the original aims of United Front work, the associations in different countries may engage on many issues, including territorial integrity flashpoints such Tibet, Hong Kong, and maritime claims in the East and South China Seas.

Peaceful reunification associations serve as one of the CCP’s main connection points with Chinese-American communities. They function as welcome centers for visiting government officials, as platforms for the dissemination of party propaganda, as hubs that allow Beijing to identify and potentially co-opt prominent community members, and as centers for local community organizing, such as hosting cultural events.

The Washington branch is particularly illustrious. Founded in 1973, it was one of the earliest such organizations, and Beijing has praised its accomplishments. The organization sent a delegation to Beijing in 2015, where they met Tan Tianxing, the deputy director of the Overseas Chinese Affairs Office. Tan praised the organization, saying that since its founding in 1973, the Washington branch has “done a lot of useful work” to “fight Taiwanese independence and promote unification.”
“After the Tiananmen Square massacre, the party launched a decades-long expansion of United Front activity abroad. The aim was to build party-linked networks in overseas Chinese communities, keep them connected to Beijing, and quash any anti-party organizing.”
Get The Beast In Your Inbox!
Daily Digest

Start and finish your day with the top stories from The Daily Beast.
Cheat Sheet

A speedy, smart summary of all the news you need to know (and nothing you don't).
By clicking “Subscribe,” you agree to have read the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy
Thank You!
You are now subscribed to the Daily Digest and Cheat Sheet. We will not share your email with anyone for any reason.

At its heart, United Front strategy involves amplifying friendly voices and suppressing critical ones. After the Tiananmen Square massacre in 1989, the CCP realized that it had a major global image problem, and it feared that the pro-democracy movement would flourish in overseas Chinese communities and then seep back in China. So the party launched what would become a decades-long expansion of United Front activity abroad, particularly among diaspora communities. The aim was to build party-linked networks in overseas Chinese communities, keep them connected to Beijing, and quash any anti-party organizing.

These overseas efforts have targeted independent Chinese-language media outlets, Chinese student and community groups, Chinese businesses and organizations, and increasingly, prominent non-Chinese individuals and organizations, including campaign donors and politicians, with the goal of convincing them to promote Beijing’s policies and interests in their host countries.

Anne-Marie Brady, a fellow at the Wilson Center who researches the United Front’s activities in New Zealand, describes the goal of United Front work among overseas Chinese communities as “[getting] the community to proactively and even better, spontaneously, engage in activities which enhance China’s foreign policy agenda.”

Peter Mattis, a former CIA China analyst and a research fellow in China studies at the Victims of Communism Memorial Foundation, takes it a step further.

“The purpose of this department is to turn Americans against their own government’s interests and their society’s interests,” he told The Daily Beast. “It’s undermining the integrity of our democracy and it’s getting Americans to do it themselves.”

And by targeting Chinese-Americans, “it foments discord and encourages racial divisions. And what’s worse is, I think the party knows it.”

“They’re essentially taunting foreign governments like the United States to turn on their Chinese populations,” Mattis added.

United Front activity creates discord within the Chinese-American community as well. It actively creates pro-Beijing groups and pits them against Taiwanese and Tibetan groups, dissidents, and Falun Gong practitioners. As one Taiwanese-American told The Daily Beast, “It’s like everyone is in a faction and they’re trying to gauge what faction you’re in.”

In Australia, a major scandal unfolded last year after it was revealed that Huang Xiangmo, a top political donor and president of the country’s peaceful reunification association, had attempted to use his donations to sway Australia’s position on the South China Sea, a hotly contested region that China claims as its own. In New Zealand, the peaceful reunification association organizes Chinese community members to fundraise and block-vote for China-friendly politicians.

Less public scrutiny has been applied to peaceful reunification associations in the United States, so less is known about their activities. But according to former Western intelligence officials, the United Front and its U.S-based proxies actively cultivate ties to campaign donors in America. And the United Front has made it clear that it wants overseas Chinese to get involved in their respective countries’ politics to sway things in China’s favor.

And that’s exactly what He Xiaohui, the newly appointed head of Washington’s peaceful reunification association, has said Chinese-Americans ought to do.

“Helen” He came to the United States in 1988. In the 2000s, she became politically active in Maryland, lobbying the state government to make Chinese lunar new year an official holiday, founding an umbrella group for Chinese hometown associations called the Coordination Council of Chinese American Associations, and organizing voter drives in the Chinese community. In 2010, she was awarded the Governor’s Volunteer Service Award. She has also donated to the campaigns of local and state-level politicians.

Or at least, that’s what her English-language online footprint says. Chinese-language sources paint a different picture.

In 2005, He said in an interview with official party mouthpiece People’s Daily that Chinese people in America should get involved in civic spaces to oppose Taiwan independence and to “fight for the support of American people for China to achieve unification.” Unification with Taiwan, which has ruled itself since 1949, is one of the party’s top core interests.

In April, in an interview with the pro-Beijing newspaper Qiao Bao, for example, He criticized the recently-passed Taiwan Travel Act, which makes it easier for government officials from the U.S. and Taiwan to visit each other, and the 2018 National Defense Authorization act, saying they “interfered in China’s internal affairs” and “seriously violated the One-China Principle.”

Statements such as these are a window into He’s views, but also demonstrate a specific United Front strategy. When the United States adopts a policy that Beijing doesn’t like, official news outlets and website can approach people like He for comment, then tout those statements as evidence that Chinese-Americans don’t approve of Washington’s latest move. One intended audiences for this evidence is Chinese people in China -- it serves to bolster the party’s image as receiving support from Chinese around the world, not just at home.

He has worked for years in local-level community and political organizing in Maryland, and has become known among Maryland politicians for her ability to reach the Chinese community. Lily Qi, a current Democratic nominee for Maryland state delegate, described He as “one of those great connectors to pay attention to local level.” If you need to reach out to the local Chinese community, Qi told The Daily Beast, “she would always step up, more than most people, and follow through.” (Helen He did not respond to a request for comment).

That level of influence is just what United Front officials look for as they scout out potential recruits.

In 2009, while serving as president of the Chinese hometown associations group, He was invited to Beijing to serve as an overseas delegate to the Chinese People’s Political Consultative Conference (CPPCC), one of China’s two rubber-stamp legislatures and another important United Front body that identifies influential overseas Chinese and aims to incorporate them into the party’s overseas goals.

Being chosen as a CPPCC delegate means that “these people are recognized by the [Chinese] party-state,” said Gerry Groot, who researched the United Front and serves as head of the department of Asian studies at the University of Adelaide in Australia. “The United Front department has seen these people as being influential and important in their communities, and is seeking to increase or deepen their ties to China, as the ancestral land.”

“In rewarding them, those people get status in their communities back home,” continued Groot, “and in many cases it increases their influence back home. And that means that these people go back much more committed to supporting the party than they were.”

A common thread runs through much of the United Front’s related activities in the United States and other Western democracies. It uses the freedoms guaranteed in liberal democracies to promote Beijing’s own ends. At times it resembles the tools that democracies such as the United States use to promote their own interests—funding friendly media outlets, recruiting sympathetic locals—but Chinese influence operations often employ elements of secrecy, coercion, and repression that the United States usually does not. 

It also means that any response to the United Front must be carefully calibrated to preserve the rights and freedoms of Chinese-Americans.

“It is tempting to frame all party-state encroachment as a national security issue,” wrote Mattis and Samantha Hoffman, a research fellow at the Mercator Institute for China Studies in Berlin, in May. But “bringing national security tools to bear risks what makes America exceptional. As the CCP tightens its grip, the United States should extend an open hand. It means ensuring Chinese students, scholars, and perhaps future Americans do not have their right to liberty impeded on American soil.”

“Rising to China’s challenge, however, is as much about being a better America as it is finding the appropriate strategic response.”

Whenever Chinese President Xi Jinping makes high-profile visits to cities abroad— whether Washington, Prague, or Auckland—he is almost invariably greeted by crowds of enthusiastic Chinese students wearing red t-shirts and carrying signs proclaiming their support. They line the streets outside of the meeting venue, sometimes for days, and local media outlets tend to be impressed with the level of committed patriotism that Chinese students display for their country’s leader, who has overseen a sweeping ideological crackdown on Chinese society and higher education.

But such demonstrations are often organized by Chinese consular officials, who work through the Chinese Student and Scholar Associations, or CSSAs, that exist on the campuses of universities around the United States and many other countries. CSSAs are another good example of United Front strategy at work in the United States. There are between 100 and 150 CSSAs at universities around the United States, and many of them are quite large and influential on campus. These are not the only Chinese student groups in the U.S., but unlike other groups, CSSAs typically consider themselves to be under the “official guidance” of the consulate—language they often include on their websites in Chinese but not in English. Many or most CSSAs receive funding from the Chinese embassy.

In return for their assistance and funding, Chinese consular officials make occasional political “asks” of CSSAs. These asks include quiet political mobilization campaigns. Any time a top Chinese leader visits a U.S. city, consular officials will direct student groups to wear red t-shirts, carry Chinese flags, hold enthusiastic signs, and fan out onto the streets to welcome the visiting leader. Sometimes the consulates offer cash compensation to students, up to $60 per day in some cases. They often provide the t-shirts and flags, may pay for transportation, and may provide food and snacks.
“At times they resemble the tools that democracies like the United States use to promote their own interests. But Chinese influence operations often employ elements of secrecy, coercion, and repression that the United States usually does not.”

Chinese students are joined by delegations from other Chinese community organizations such as hometown associations who have received similar directives from the consulates, creating sizable crowds that easily drown out small groups of Chinese dissidents or other protesters. The resulting reports in both Western and Chinese language media typically portray these activities as “patriotic” demonstrations by “supporters of Beijing.”

There’s another reason the party wants to organize such large crowds. As participants have told The Daily Beast, one goal is to take up as much space as possible in prime locations in front of meeting venues so that would-be dissidents simply have no room to lodge their protests against the CCP.

This isn’t organic patriotism, though certainly many Chinese are patriotic. But it is intended to look like it. And the scale and scope of this covert political mobilization is striking. Embassies have been able to organize large pro-Beijing demonstrations in major cities all over the world for at least 15 years, and mainstream media coverage almost without exception portrays such events as evidence of organic grassroots support for Beijing—precisely the goal of United Front work.

A United Front policy which has become increasingly prominent in the past two decades is to encourage “huaren canzheng,” or Chinese participation in the politics of the countries they live in. Qiu Yuanping, the current director of the Overseas Chinese Affairs Office, which is under the direct oversight of the United Front Department, regularly encourages Chinese living in the United States and elsewhere to get involved in politics and to vote.

It’s a policy that by nature is tricky to discuss. In the United States, Chinese communities have traditionally been politically marginalized, and efforts to get more Chinese-Americans to vote and run for office are sorely needed. “Of course it is completely normal and to be encouraged that the ethnic Chinese communities in each country seek political representation,” the New Zealand scholar Brady writes in her report.

But the United Front efforts to encourage overseas Chinese to participate in politics are not “spontaneous and natural development,” writes Brady.

“This policy encourages overseas Chinese who are acceptable to the PRC government to become involved in politics in their host countries as candidates who, if elected, will be able to act to promote China’s interests abroad,” says Brady, “and encourages China’s allies to build relations with non-Chinese pro-CCP government foreign political figures, to offer donations to foreign political parties, and to mobilize public opinion via Chinese language social media; so as to promote the PRC's economic and political agenda abroad.”

Here’s an example of what that can look like. Yang Chunlai, a Chinese engineer, came to the United States in 1990. He later became the president of the Association of Chinese Scientists and Engineers, a U.S.-based group founded in 1992. In his role as ACSE president, Yang traveled to China in 2007 to participate in a conference for overseas Chinese organizations hosted by the Overseas Chinese Affairs Office.

At a speech he gave at the conference, Yang said that Beijing views overseas Chinese political participation in host countries as a means to serve China.

“China has gone through three stages regarding its approach to overseas Chinese making contributions to China,” said Yang. “The earliest stage was emphasizing that overseas scholars should return home to serve China. Later, we realized that serving China doesn’t necessarily require returning to China. Now, China is placing an emphasis on our development in foreign countries, paying close attention to whether or not we can enter local mainstream society and play an active role in the politics and debate of our host countries.”

Yang added, “Next year is a big election year in America; voting is hard logic. ACSE hopes to take advantage of this opportunity to further expand our influence on American mainstream society.”

Perhaps Yang’s name rings a bell. That’s because he was arrested in 2011, accused of stealing trade secrets in a scheme to set up an exchange in China. He pleaded guilty, was convicted in 2015, and sentenced to four years probation. In the reporting on his arrest, trial, and conviction, his participation in United Front-related activities in China was not mentioned.

    Bethany Allen-Ebrahimian
    @BethanyAllenEbrBethany.Allen@thedailybeast.com

Got a tip? Send it to The Daily Beast here.

    Politics
    Entertainment
    World News
    Half Full
    Arts and Culture
    U.S. News
    Tech
    Hunt for the Cure
    Science
    Scouted
    Travel

    About
    Contact
    Tips
    Jobs
    Help
    Privacy
    Code of Ethics & Standards
    Terms & Conditions
    Copyright & Trademark
    Sitemap

© 2018 The Daily Beast Company LLC
Advertise With Us

Tuesday, 24 July 2018

OZY/Lina Zeldovich: Robots to the Rescue: Racing Through Our Blood to Cure Diseasee

OZY

Robots to the Rescue: Racing Through Our Blood to Cure Disease
Robots to the Rescue: Racing Through Our Blood to Cure Disease
 
Heart
SourceGetty
Fast Forward
Why you should care

The future of medicine? Miniature robots communicating with doctors from inside our bodies.

By Lina Zeldovich

The Daily DoseJUL 24 20

David Zarrouk carefully places the tiny robot into a cleaned-up pig intestine on his table, and flips on the switch. About the size of a thumb, the miniature robot comes to life and starts worming through the intestine, all the way through the other end. The researcher at Ben-Gurion University in Israel draws his inspiration from the 1960s movie Fantastic Voyage. There, a shrunken submarine swims through a scientist’s bloodstream to repair his brain. Zarrouk hopes to turn what he saw on the screen into reality. “You can call it a gut bot,” he says. He isn’t alone.

Since the turn of the century, scientists have eyed implantable medical devices or particles, sometimes as tiny as ingestible pills, as a long-awaited solution that could allow them to monitor body functions from the outside while avoiding painful, and at times costly, surgeries. But now, researchers are leapfrogging those implants, instead developing minuscule robots that are emerging as the next frontier in medical science.

Until this decade, there were about 10 labs globally that were trying to develop such robots. Today, most of those efforts have advanced to a stage where they’re no longer science fiction, and the field is taking off as a major industry of the future. More than two dozen labs — from China to Canada and Israel to Italy, and at other research institutions across the U.S. and Europe — have now published research on their nanobot projects. And a June 2018 report by Market Research Future estimates that the medical nanobots industry will grow annually at 21 percent to reach $100 billion — the size of Morocco’s entire economy — by 2023.

Unlike implantable devices that stay where they are placed, these robots are mobile and can be directed by outside human operators or even move around with some autonomy. This mobility lets them carry out diagnostics, organ repair and even perform surgeries from the inside, reducing the extent to which tissues need to be cut.

    They can be delivering drugs to organs, continuously gather information or do localized treatments …

    Hod Lipson, roboticist, Columbia University’s Creative Machines Lab

Scientists at the University of California, San Diego have built nanobots that are able to swim in the blood and fight superbugs like MRSA — methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus — that attack both red blood cells and platelets. At Northwestern University, materials science and engineering professor John Rogers and his team are taking that next step: thinking about the future of robots after they’re done with their work. They’re building electronics that can safely dissolve within the human body once they complete their mission, similar to how sutures work.

And at Ben-Gurion University, Zarrouk is refining his gut bot to one day replace costly and uncomfortable intestinal diagnostic procedures in which doctors push a camera-equipped tube down a patient’s throat and into the stomach — to look for ulcers, polyps or tumors.

“These advancements can really create a lot of impact,” says roboticist Hod Lipson, who directs Columbia University’s Creative Machines Lab. “They can be delivering drugs to organs, continuously gather information or do localized treatments where you need to open up a particular artery inside.”

These emerging breakthroughs need to pass multiple trials and regulations before they become available in the medical market — they’re all at the laboratory stage at the moment. And even in the laboratory, the step up from stationary, implanted electronics to robots that swim through body fluids and blood isn’t straightforward. To make his bot fully functional, Zarrouk needs to shrink its current size by half, so it can fit inside a small capsule. Patients could then consume it, and doctors holding joysticks could direct its movement within the body. The gut bot would traverse the intestines, transmit the information from the inside and finally leave the body in “a natural way,” with excreta.

But researchers are convinced these swimming bots are the future of ingested medical electronics. The enemy for the researchers at UCSD, for instance, is a tricky customer, and it needs cutting-edge solutions like the one they’re developing to truly beat it, say scientists.

MRSA mounts a double attack on the human body: The bacteria attach to and destroy blood platelets, the cells that prevent bleeding, and simultaneously release toxins that punch holes in red blood cells, damaging their ability to fight pathogens. So researchers built their nanobots as decoys. The team covered tiny gold nanowires with a biological coating that looks like the outer membranes of platelets and red blood cells. Then the team used ultrasound waves to propel the bots, each 25 times smaller than the width of a human hair, through blood samples. As the nanobots floated around posing as MRSA’s targets, they essentially “fished out” the invaders and disarmed them. After five minutes, blood samples treated with mobile nanobots had three times less bacteria and toxins than samples with no treatment.

“The ability to move within the bloodstream was a key factor,” says the study’s co-author, Berta Esteban-Fernández de Ávila, highlighting why stationary implants couldn’t have done the job. “When robots are moving through the blood sample, they are increasing the contacts with bacteria and toxins, so they work faster, and achieve a higher detoxification efficiency.” The team is now moving onto testing this process in mice.

At Northwestern University, Rogers and his team are trying to turn what electronics engineers have tried to do for decades on its head. “The goal of the electronics industry has always been to build durable devices that last forever,” Rogers says — but you can also do the opposite. With the right choice of materials, electronics can be made biodegradable and compatible with the human body.

Rogers noticed that when silicon, commonly found in electronics, is used in very thin sheets, it can dissolve in water. Once that silicon “wrapper” is gone, the electronic parts inside it can decompose too. Moreover, these parts can be made from metals that the human body uses naturally and actually needs — such as magnesium, zinc or iron. They can be absorbed without harm. Working with physicians, Rogers’ team has built several variations of such “transient electronics,” including a temporary pacemaker and a device that electrically stimulates bone growth. And by using silicon sheets of different thicknesses, these devices can be programmed to last a specific period of time. Rogers’ transient electronics are already being tested in mice.

“We are learning how to make and control these kinds of microscale machines,” says Lipson. “It’s exciting.” Transformative too. When a young Zarrouk watched the film that would half a century later lead him to design his gut bot, it was pure science fiction. “Now it’s no longer fiction. It’s just science,” says Zarrouk. And it’s the future.

    Lina Zeldovich, OZY Author
    Contact Lina Zeldovich

    Facebook
    Twitter
    10Shares
    Copied
    Copy link
    Email

Most Popular on OZY

    Jemele Hill Plans to Leave ESPN, Won't Kiss Political Ass
    Provocateurs
    Jemele Hill Plans to Leave ESPN, Won't Kiss Political Ass

    The former SportsCenter host’s outspoken political views have come under fire. She’s eager to tell bigger stories than sports.
    When My Neighbors Called the Cops on Me
    True Story
    When My Neighbors Called the Cops on Me

    With a raft of Black folks having the cops called on them for threadbare reasons, it’s all an abstraction until they’re called on the Black folk writing this.
    I Moved to Costa Rica to Escape Trump
    True Story
    I Moved to Costa Rica to Escape Trump

    While 23 percent of Americans said they’d consider leaving America for political reasons, how many have? We found two.
    This Maya Village Was Frozen in Time by a Volcano
    Good Sh*t
    This Maya Village Was Frozen in Time by a Volcano

    A visit to this frozen-in-time farming village shows what daily life was like for Maya commoners in Mesoamerica.

OZYFast Forward

New trends and breakthrough thinking in politics, science, technology, business and culture. It’s futurism at its best.

    Colombia's Path to Peace Passes Through Museums
    Fast Forward
    Colombia's Path to Peace Passes Through Museums

    Communities across Colombia are using museums to highlight the pitfalls of slipping back into conflict, as the future of the country’s peace deal hangs in the balance.
    Why More People Are Choosing Unique Children's Names
    Fast Forward
    Why More People Are Choosing Unique Children's Names

    It’s not just celebrities. Americans from all backgrounds are increasingly selecting unique names for their kids.
    Damascus Says Bon Appétit Amid Brutal War
    Fast Forward
    Damascus Says Bon Appétit Amid Brutal War

    An urban prison, the Syrian capital is seeing an explosion of restaurants and cafés — as outlets for war-weary residents.
    Beijing's Bid to Woo Tech Titans Back to Mainland China Falters
    Fast Forward
    Beijing's Bid to Woo Tech Titans Back to Mainland China Falters

    Alibaba, Baidu and JD.com have postponed share deals as the mainland stock market turns bearish.
    Where's the Beef With Blockchain? Wyoming
    Fast Forward
    Where's the Beef With Blockchain? Wyoming

    Ranch owners are using blockchain to prove the quality of their cattle as the state passes laws to attract cryptocurrency startups.

More from Fast Forward
get caught up
with the presidential daily brief
Trump Considers Revoking Critics’ Security Clearances
Payback
Trump Considers Revoking Critics’ Security Clearances
R. Kelly Releases Track Addressing Allegations
Off Track
R. Kelly Releases Track Addressing Allegations
vault ahead
with the daily dose
Which Country Loves to Snap More Than Saudi Arabia? None
Acumen
Which Country Loves to Snap More Than Saudi Arabia? None
Robots to the Rescue: Racing Through Our Blood to Cure Disease
Fast Forward
Robots to the Rescue: Racing Through Our Blood to Cure Disease
SEE BEYOND

40M People and growing
   Facebook
   Twitter
   Apple
   Youtube
   Instagram

    The Week On OZYAbout OZYMeet The TeamJobs @ OZYAdvertise On OZYPrivacy Policy

© OZY 2018 Terms & Conditions

National Review/Jack Crowe: White House to Extend $12 Billion in Aid to Farmers Hurt by Trade War

National Review

Jul. 24, 2018

   
Politics & Policy    
White House to Extend $12 Billion in Aid to Farmers Hurt by Trade War
By Jack Crowe

July 24, 2018 11:36 AM

President Trump speaks during a news conference following his summit with Russian President Putin in Helsinki, Finland, July 16, 2018. (Grigory Dukor/Reuters)

The White House is expected to announce a plan to provide $12 billion in government aid to farmers harmed by the administration’s multi-front trade war, the Washington Post first reported Tuesday morning.

Under the plan, which could be announced as soon as Tuesday, farmers whose livelihoods have been harmed by the retaliatory tariffs resulting from President Trump’s trade war with China, NAFTA and the E.U. will be provided access to three distinct forms of aid: direct assistance, a food-purchase program and a trade-promotion program.

The announcement is expected to come as President Trump continues to escalate his protectionist rhetoric on U.S. trade with China.

The administration has already implemented tariffs on $34 billion in Chinese exports and Beijing has retaliated in kind, down to the dollar. In recent weeks, Trump has repeatedly threatened to implement tariffs on the entirety of China’s more than $5 billion export market, placing Beijing at a distinct disadvantage, given that it only has roughly $120 billion in U.S. exports available to hit with tariffs.
Stay Updated with NR Daily

NR's afternoon roundup of the day's best commentary & must-read analysis.

Soybean farmers have been hit particularly hard by the trade war as prices have plummeted. The president has repeatedly vowed to help soften the blow as Midwestern farmers, a key part of his base, have increasingly turned against his protectionism.

The aid proposal, which relies in part on a depression-era Department of Agriculture program designed to bail out farmers, is the product of a months-long research effort intended to help the administration see its trade war through by warding off domestic opposition in the farming community.

The depression-era program, known as the Commodity Credit Corporation, is empowered to borrow $30 billion from the Treasury Department absent Congressional approval.

A coalition of Republican lawmakers, such as Sen. Bob Corker of Tennessee and Ben Sasse of Nebraska, have been outspoken in their criticism of Trump’s protectionist tendencies while leadership has remained relatively muted in their opposition.

“This trade war is cutting the legs out from under farmers and White House’s ‘plan’ is to spend $12 billion on gold crutches. America’s farmers don’t want to be paid to lose – they want to win by feeding the world. This administration’s tariffs and bailouts aren’t going to make America great again, they’re just going to make it 1929 again,” Sasse said in a statement released following reports of the aid package.

Jack Crowe — Jack Crowe is a news writer at National Review Online.
More in Politics & Policy  
The Greatest Hysteria in American History
Democrats in Four States File a Misguided Lawsuit against the Tax-Reform Law
Russianism
The Middle East Is Capitalism’s Next Frontier
Recommended Articles
Most Popular
PC Culture  
The Sliming of Ben Shapiro
By David French
Law & the Courts  
Democratic Desperation on Kavanaugh Is Showing
By Dan McLaughlin
Elections  
Will New Jersey Send a Republican to the Senate?
By George Will
Politics & Policy  
The First Nationalist
By Kevin D. Williamson
National Security & Defense  
A New World Disorder
By Jonah Goldberg

    Login

© 2018 National Review

    Donate
    Subscribe

    Sections
        The Corner
        Bench Memos
        The Morning Jolt
        The G-File
        News
        All Articles
        All Authors
        Podcasts
        Photos
        Videos

    Topics
        Politics & Policy
        Culture
        White House
        Film & TV
        PC Culture
        U.S.
        World
        Immigration
        Economy & Business
        Elections

    Magazine
        Latest Issue
        Archive
        Subscribe
        Customer Care
        NRPLUS
        Magazine FAQ

    About
        Frequently Asked Questions
        The Masthead
        Contact Us
        Privacy Policy
        Terms of Service
        NR Institute

    More
        Advertise
        Donate
        Search
        E-mails & Alerts

Newsletters
Morning Jolt (M-F)
NR Daily (M-Sa)
The G-File (F)
Breaking News (M-Su)

© 2018 National Review
:)

Forbes/Brian Anderson: A Leader's Cautionary Tale: Town Halls

Forbes CommunityVoice Connecting expert communities to the Forbes audience. What is This?
A Leader's Cautionary Tale: Town Halls
Forbes Communications Council
Brian Anderson CommunityVoice
Forbes Communications Council

Jul 18, 2018, 09:00am #LikeABoss

Post written by

Brian Anderson

CMO of POPin, with over 30 years of global marketing experience in technology, business-to-business and business-to-consumer markets.

Shutterstock

Leaders beware: This is a cautionary tale of two leaders and their approaches to being more approachable and thus more successful as leaders. Today we traverse the fine line between success and failure for the ubiquitous town hall/all-hands meeting.

Town hall meetings harken back to colonial times when political leaders incited the American Revolution by bringing together citizens to discuss issues of taxation without representation. Business leaders have long since cooped the concept in order to periodically address the entire organization for issues ranging from general business updates to dealing with massive (usually negative) change.

A recent article in the Harvard Business Review notes that a leader’s time is exceedingly limited, and the scope of their work is vast. This includes agendas, organizational levels and external issues. In this modern business reality, it is critical for leaders to ensure that their messages are effectively communicated, heard and understood by all of their constituents.

Today’s tale starts with an observation of two leaders, alike in almost every aspect. Fred and Barney are both CEOs of large companies with similar education and business backgrounds. Both face a highly competitive market fraught with regulatory requirements, a workforce changing with the influx of millennials and the daily challenge of staying ahead of consumer preferences. Both have read the management books that pontificate visibility and approachability as a way to promote higher productivity and, in turn, profitability.

The Vocal Minority

Fred is very proud of his monthly town hall meetings with the entire company. He personally crafts the agenda and spends a solid 45 minutes updating everyone on all corporate metrics with a 42-slide presentation. Fred closes every meeting by opening up the microphone to anyone who has any questions on everything he just presented. Invariably, the only people coming forward with questions seem to be about inconsequential things that are easily addressed. Month after month, it's the same people spouting the same personal agendas, but Fred gives them the opportunity to speak to show how approachable he is as a leader.

At the end of every meeting, his direct reports praise his performance, assuring him that everything went great, which furthers Fred’s opinion of his success. Unfortunately, there always seem to be fire drills between town hall meetings that require restating and resetting expectations down through the ranks of the organization.

Fred also sends out a survey at the end of every town hall to quantify feedback. It usually takes a week to get enough people to complete the 10-question survey in order to make it meaningful, and then another three to four weeks to compile and analyze the data. The feedback from the organization is that it feels like they are being tested and never know the outcome, while Fred feels like he is being graded and usually discounts what he sees in the summary.

The Silent Majority

Barney’s approach is dramatically different. He always has three or four topics that he knows must be addressed, but he understands that in an organization as large as his, there are items of importance to different organizational levels that may not be on his radar.

Three days before every town hall meeting, he invites the entire organization to collaborate in an anonymous crowdsourcing tool with the question, “What questions or topics do you want us to address at our next all-hands meeting?” [Full disclosure: My company offers an anonymous crowdsourcing platform.] The entire organization can then safely add their ideas as well as vote and comment on other ideas to create a consensus on what is truly important for everyone. Barney even adds his own ideas anonymously to see how the organization rates what he feels is mission critical to success.

During the town hall, Barney starts by bringing up the crowdsourcing session and addresses the issues voted to the top, even when they may be difficult topics, because he knows it is better to address everything head on than to let them fester and negatively impact productivity. His town halls always feel more like a true company conversation because everyone has had some say through their votes and comments, and he can ensure that mission-critical issues are also addressed.

Immediately after the meeting he launches another session to ask, “How effective were the topics covered in today’s all-hands meeting, and where do you need more clarity?” In this way, he can see where more information is needed to succeed and where potential hot spots may flare in the future. Barney comes away with a clear understanding of critical success factors and the organization comes to trust him even more because of his actions.

An Invitation To Excel

In short, I’d invite you to be a Barney. The world already has too many leaders who are more interested in their own opinions and that of their direct reports than that of the entire team they manage. I’m not suggesting management by mob rule, but more often than not, while leaders know what needs to be done, employees know why and how best it can be done.

Recognizing and tapping into this can be the difference between success and failure, or at least the difference between getting something done quickly and smoothly versus constantly battling confusion and resetting expectations.

Bottom line: Whether the ideas and strategies implemented were in fact your idea to start with, you will find that when your entire organization feels like it was their idea, they will feel emotionally invested in the outcome. You will gain not only their trust but their ongoing buy-in for success and, ultimately, your organization’s market dominance.
Forbes Communications Council is an invitation-only community for executives in successful public relations, media strategy, creative and advertising agencies. Do I qualify?

    Website Feedback
    News Tip
    Report Corrections
    Reprints & Permissions
    Terms
    Privacy

The Washington Post/Elizabeth Dwoskin and Emily Rauhala: Facebook opens subsidiary in China after being locked out of the country for years

The Washington Post
Democracy Dies in Darkness

    Try 1 month for $1
    Sign In
        Newsletters & Alerts
        Gift Subscriptions
        Contact Us
        Help Desk

    Accessibility for screenreader

Business
Facebook opens subsidiary in China after being locked out of the country for years

REUTERS/Eric Gaillard (Eric Gaillard/Reuters)
by Elizabeth Dwoskin and Emily Rauhala July 24 at 12:08 PM Email the author

SAN FRANCISCO -- Facebook has obtained a license to set up an office in China – a first for the company, which has been shut of China’s lucrative market for years despite many attempts to break in.

The $30 million subsidiary, which will open in the southern city of Hangzhou, would be set up as a startup incubator, making minor investments and advising small businesses, according to a person familiar with the company’s thinking and a Chinese business filing.

Facebook is currently blocked in China. Chief executive Mark Zuckerberg made personal appeals to the Chinese Communist Party’s top brass, including learning Mandarin and taking a “smog jog” through Tiananmen Square — braving toxic air pollution for a photo op in 2016.

“We are interested in setting up an innovation hub in Zhejiang to support Chinese developers, innovators and start-ups,” the company said in a statement. “We have done this in several parts of the world -- France, Brazil, India, Korea — and our efforts would be focused on training and workshops that help these developers and entrepreneurs to innovate and grow.”

A notice published on China’s National Enterprise Credit Information Publicity System listed the company as Facebook Technology (Hangzhou) Co., Ltd and noted that it is wholly owned by Facebook Hong Kong Limited. It has registered capital of $30 million.

The filing, which is no longer accessible, provided few details about what the subsidiary will—or won’t—do. It stated the “business scope” included technology development, technical services and investment consulting, among long list of other things.

Facebook had quietly launched a photo-sharing app called “Colorful Balloons” for the Chinese market last year. It was released by a company called Youge Internet Technology.

Youge’s executive director is a woman named Zhang Jingmei, who has been pictured visiting Shanghai officials with the woman who was then Facebook’s top representative in China, Wang-Li Moser. Zhang is listed as the “legal person” for Facebook’s subsidiary in China.

Facebook has a sales office in Hong Kong, and for years has sought to open an office in mainland China. But China has a robust economy of social media companies, and the government has favored local competitors.

Facebook’s efforts have been marked by fits and starts. The company scouted for space in Shanghai last year and obtained a permit to open an office in Beijing in 2015. Neither materialized.

Oculus, Facebook’s virtual reality company, has a Shanghai office, and the company is interested in China for its growing hardware ambitions.

— Amber Wang and Luna Lin contributed from Beijing
Elizabeth Dwoskin
Elizabeth Dwoskin has been reporting from Silicon Valley since 2013. She was the Wall Street Journal's first full-time beat reporter covering big data and artificial intelligence. In 2016, she joined The Washington Post as Silicon Valley correspondent, becoming the paper's eyes and ears in the region and in the wider world of tech. Follow
Emily Rauhala
Emily Rauhala is China correspondent for The Washington Post. She was previously a Beijing-based correspondent for Time and an editor at the magazine's Hong Kong office. In 2017, she shared an Overseas Press Club award for a series about the Internet in China. Follow
subscribe
The story must be told.
Your subscription supports journalism that matters.
Try 1 month for $1
Market Watch
Dow 25,267.89
Today 0.89%
S&P 2,824.75
Today 0.63%
NASDAQ 7,865.56
Today 0.3%
Last Updated:12:19 PM 07/24/2018

Huffington Post/Zach Carter: Trump's Tariff War Is The Final Act Of A Broken System

Huffington Post
POLITICS
07/22/2018 08:01 am ET Updated 14 hours ago
Trump’s Tariff War Is The Final Act Of A Broken System
The myth of free trade is coming apart.
By Zach Carter
Trump is not the destroyer of order and harmony, but the product of a corrupt and broken system.
Barcroft Media via Getty Images
Trump is not the destroyer of order and harmony, but the product of a corrupt and broken system.

President Donald Trump’s trade agenda is a corrupt, chaotic mess.

He made trade concessions to China after its government agreed to invest hundreds of millions of dollars in a Trump-branded resort. He announced a modest trade enforcement action on steel and aluminum and declared it a “trade war” ― something both “good” and “easy to win.” He then shifted his sights in this combat from China to Canada without any apparent rationale. The president has even threatened Ecuador’s economy with crippling sanctions if its government offered public support for breastfeeding.

As with so many Trump debacles, his bluster creates an appearance of radicalism — a dramatic break with a stable and happy consensus. Washington Post columnist Catherine Rampell has lamented that he is discarding more than 300 years of settled economic knowledge. Nobel laureate economist Paul Krugman has been more modest, accusing Trump of jeopardizing a free trade system that dates back to former President Franklin Delano Roosevelt.

It’s easy to forget that just before Trump’s election, elite Washington was rethinking the approach to free trade and globalization that the United States had taken since the 1990s. Centrist think tanks held major conferences calling to restructure the U.S. relationship with China. Hillary Clinton, Elizabeth Warren and even libertarian experts at the Cato Institute agreed there were serious problems with the way trade agreements were enforced.

Part of the trouble is that Trump is not pursuing a coherent and consistent trade strategy. On some matters, he’s hard to distinguish from Bill Clinton or Barack Obama, while on others, he does break with the recent past. But even here Trump is not the destroyer of order and harmony, but the product of a corrupt and broken system.

To understand what’s going on and where it went wrong we need to start at the beginning. What economists are accustomed to describing as “free trade” or “globalization” has another, less flattering name: colonialism.
Comparative Advantage And Exploitation

Human beings have been trading across political borders for as long as human beings have recorded their activity. But free trade in the modern sense was the conceptual innovation of David Ricardo, a brilliant 19th-century British economist. In his 1817 magnum opus ”On The Principles Of Political Economy And Taxation,” Ricardo laid out the theory of comparative advantage: If every country focused on producing what it made best, and then traded with other countries that did the same, everybody everywhere would get to enjoy the best of everything. In the process, Ricardo argued, every country would become richer this way than it would if it tried to produce everything at home by itself.

To illustrate the point, Ricardo presented a thought experiment in which two countries, Britain and Portugal, produced just two commodities ― wine and cloth. In the 19th century, Portugal was famous for its wine, while European nobility coveted fine British textiles. Imports of good Portuguese wine were tough on British winemakers, and if the British government wanted to protect its domestic wineries, it could put up tariffs against Portuguese wine, making the foreign stuff more expensive in British stores. And that could be just fine for winemakers.

But there are only so many workers. Someone who spends the day smashing grapes can’t devote that same time to running a loom. Tariffs couldn’t change the root problems with the British wine business ― the soil and climate on a rocky semi-arctic island just weren’t good for grapes. As a result, propping up the inefficient British wine industry would sap resources from its much more productive textile operations. This waste would register as lower overall production of both wine and cloth. And perhaps worst of all, it would mean British drinkers would have to settle for their own lousy wine.

The obvious solution was for politicians to keep out of the way and let people do what they would naturally do absent government meddling ― trade freely.

“Under a system of perfectly free commerce, each country naturally devotes its capital and labour to such employments as are most beneficial to each,” Ricardo wrote. “This pursuit of individual advantage is admirably connected with the universal good of the whole.”

Ricardo was onto something. But he took an awful lot for granted to make his point. He didn’t have much to say, for instance, about how the British textile business actually operated. In the real world, England’s spinning and weaving factories relied on cotton from India and the United States. This cotton was cheap ― and the British factories, by extension, so wonderfully efficient ― because plantation owners relied on slave labor and violent exploitation to keep down costs.

By focusing on Ricardo’s abstract trade model, economists and policymakers could be lulled into understanding these acts of violent subjugation as components of an impartial, balanced system. Ricardo converted a vast array of political choices ― including the very existence of the British Empire and American slavery ― into what looked like a simple, mathematical truth: More trade equals greater prosperity. But the 19th-century mantra of “free trade!” was, among other things, a euphemism for enriching slaveowners.

    Free trade rhetoric almost always serves a magical function: It erases ugly, violent political realities and replaces them with clean, natural progress.

Free trade rhetoric almost always serves a magical function: It erases ugly, violent political realities and replaces them with clean, natural progress. To its evangelists, free trade isn’t just a way to maximize profits and production. It offers a path to the elimination of human evil. New Deal luminary Cordell Hull believed free trade offered a cooperative foundation for the prevention of war, while libertarian high priest Milton Friedman believed it cleared the way for political rights like freedom of speech and religion.

Krugman describes “liberalized trade” as the key to an “international alliance” against “authoritarian politics,” while House Speaker Paul Ryan (R-Wis.) champions it as a way to advance “rule of law,” “women’s rights” and “democracy.”

And yet history shows no clear pattern between tariff levels and freedom, war, democracy or autocracy. Ryan’s enthusiasm, for instance, was issued in support of a 2004 U.S. free trade agreement with the Kingdom of Bahrain. In 2017, according to the nonprofit group Human Rights Watch, the government of Bahrain shut down the country’s only independent newspaper and held its most prominent human rights activist in prison.

In the 19th century, “free trade” was a doctrine that called for limiting trade barriers between European imperial powers as they plundered the rest of the world. When this system collapsed in World War I, the ensuing destruction on the European continent created a profound sense of nostalgia for the prewar order and the Ricardian ideals it had fostered. Over the following decade, heads of state and diplomats made herculean efforts to re-establish the collapsed trading regime. But they were frustrated by outbursts of violence, like the French invasion of the Ruhr, Germany, in 1923; political instability, like the collapse of the Weimar Republic; and speculative financial implosion, like the stock market crash of 1929.

Tariffs were largely incidental to this story, entering late in the game as a decade of dysfunction descended into the Great Depression. The United States passed the Smoot-Hawley Tariff Act in 1930, raising tariffs on roughly 20,000 goods. In 1931, the British government raised a tariff of its own and devalued the pound. Tit-for-tat reprisals followed among other nations. These prevented the re-establishment of the lost Golden Age at the Twilight of European Empire, but they did not cause the Great Depression. The system had already come undone.

It was time for new thinking. And eventually, an economist entered the world stage with the intellectual firepower to overthrew Ricardo.
U.S. President Donald Trump, surrounded by business leaders and administration officials, prepares to sign a memorandum on in
Jonathan Ernst / Reuters
U.S. President Donald Trump, surrounded by business leaders and administration officials, prepares to sign a memorandum on intellectual property tariffs on high-tech goods from China, at the White House in Washington, U.S. March 22, 2018.

John Maynard Keynes grew up an ardent free trader, viewing the unimpeded movement of goods “almost as a part of the moral law.” But the war and the Depression changed his mind. Though he still cherished the free international exchange of “ideas, knowledge, art, hospitality, [and] travel,” technological advances seemed to have left many of Ricardo’s observations obsolete. True, climate and culture played some role ― the British were never going to be great winemakers. But such products were tangential to an industrial order dominated by heavy manufacturing. You could make a car anywhere. The advantages of national specialization were fading.

“Most modern mass-production processes can be performed in most countries and climates with almost equal efficiency,” Keynes noted in a 1933 essay. There would be costs for any nation that wished to make the lion’s share of its economy a domestic concern. But innovation had dramatically reduced the cost of abandoning free trade. National self-sufficiency, he wrote, was fast “becoming a luxury which we can afford if we happen to want it.”

And Keynes believed there might very well be reasons to want it. “It does not now seem obvious,” he wrote in 1933, “that the penetration of a country’s economic structure by the resources and the influence of foreign capitalists, that a close dependence of our own economic life on the fluctuating economic policies of foreign countries, are safeguards and assurances of international peace.”

“At any rate,” he continued, “the age of economic internationalism was not particularly successful in avoiding war.”

Keynes elaborated on these ideas in his most famous book, The General Theory of Employment, Interest and Money, which he believed offered national governments the tools they needed to take care of their domestic economies without preying on their neighbors. He urged readers to think of his work as a kind of handbook for alternatives to the economic strategies of imperialism. If countries effectively managed their internal demand, they would not need to pillage resources, exploit foreign workers or undercut overseas markets to improve domestic prosperity.

Many of Keynes’ economic tactics were becoming commonplace by the late 1930s, as governments resorted to deficit spending to bring countries out of the Depression and financial regulation to mitigate the cataclysmic boom-and-bust cycles of Wall Street and London. For domestic policymakers around the world, Keynes was king.

Efforts to integrate these domestic policy innovations into a global trading system, however, were quickly subsumed by the Cold War. In the rivalry between the United States and the Soviet Union, tariffs, subsidies and currency maneuvers became tactical methods used to win allies and punish enemies.

But the language of “free trade” and its supposed liberationist potential persisted as the new great powers of the 20th century grappled with the rights and demands of newly formed nations emerging from colonial rule. By the late 1970s, the apartheid government in South Africa had become a focal point for an intellectual and political dispute with global implications.
Free Market Support For Apartheid

South Africa was both a U.S. ally against the Soviet Union and a tremendous profit center for more than 160 American corporations, including General Electric, IBM and Hewlett-Packard. Profit margins were incredible ― more than double what U.S. firms could earn on a typical international investment.

The key to all this was cheap labor. The nation’s black population could not form labor unions, engage in collective bargaining, go on strike, move or vote. Apartheid officials had administered an estimated 850,000 whippings against the black population between 1954 and 1964 alone to keep demands for better treatment in check, according to Africa Today, an academic journal published by Indiana University. Colonialism had shed its 19th-century European military uniform for a modern American business suit.

The appalling conditions for the South African people led American anti-apartheid activists to call for corporations and investors to pull money and resources out of South Africa until the apartheid government had been replaced by a democratic order. As the divestment movement gained momentum on college campuses, a group of neoliberal lawyers and economists began advancing arguments explicitly attacking the prospect of democracy in South Africa on the grounds that democratic politics would be incompatible with free markets and free trade.

Wellesley College historian Quinn Slobodian details this project in Globalists: The End Of Empire And The Birth Of Neoliberalism. The most prominent anti-democracy advocate of the era was Milton Friedman, who argued that universal suffrage in South Africa would be “a system of highly-weighted voting in which special interests have far greater roles to play than does the general interest.” It was critical not to let the “political market” interfere with the economic market. As with Ricardo, the abuses on the ground evaporated into airy economic theory.

By the 1980s these arguments were too gauche to win much favor in American politics. And so President Ronald Reagan and a crop of future Republican power brokers including Grover Norquist, Jack Abramoff and Jeff Flake advanced a modified version: The best way to reform the apartheid government was not to cut off its money but through the magic of free trade.

    By eliminating tariff barriers with nations that had poor labor standards and a record of human rights abuses, these trade pacts encouraged U.S. companies to shift domestic jobs to countries where labor was cheap.

Many U.S. companies had agreed to a set of corporate responsibility principles outlined by Philadelphia pastor and General Motors Director Leon Sullivan that called for equal treatment of black and white workers. Additional U.S. investment, these voices argued, would bring American values and freedoms to South African workers and lead to political reform.

“The American companies pulling out who have abided by the Sullivan Principles, did much good for the black population there,” Flake told the Utah State Senate in 1987, while working as a lobbyist for a Namibian mining company with substantial South African operations. “Since 1977 they have contributed more than $140 million to black education, to social programs, to housing, and when our corporations pull out and these sanctions are opposed, it leaves these South African subsidiaries to take up ownership who are not obliged to follow the Sullivan Principles, and who would just as soon make a profit.”

By the time Flake was testifying, however, the free traders had essentially lost the battle on apartheid. The Comprehensive Anti-Apartheid Act of 1986, passed into law over Reagan’s veto, imposed economic sanctions against the country that weren’t lifted until the apartheid government had put in place a series of reforms, including Nelson Mandela’s release from prison.

The experience of American corporations in South Africa wasn’t far from the minds of leading neoliberal intellectuals as the Cold War drew to a close, and international negotiators began developing the treaties that would create The World Trade Organization. As Slobodian notes, these agreements were intended to control emerging democracies and prevent them from Keynesian economic policies that would privilege the rights of their citizens over the interests of American and European capital.

By eliminating tariff barriers with nations that had poor labor standards and a record of human rights abuses, these trade pacts encouraged U.S. companies to shift domestic jobs to countries where labor was cheap. While most of the agreements paid lip service to labor rights, these provisions were only rarely enforced in practice. In countries like Guatemala and Colombia where the U.S. eventually brought North American Free Trade Agreement-style agreements, dozens of union leaders were murdered every year after free trade agreements were signed, most of them unpunished. If new factory jobs in the developing world were designed to lift people out of extreme poverty, there were limits to the new system’s generosity, as demonstrated by the deaths of 1,100 workers in a Bangladesh factory making garments for U.S. retailers in 2013.

But though WTO architects continued to use the language of “free trade,” they had left Ricardo’s idea of free trade behind. They weren’t just talking about tariffs anymore. They wanted to reach across national borders and into the domestic political life of post-colonial nations to block potential labor, environmental and consumer protection rules before they were written while guaranteeing broad rights to international investors. The same was true for a new slate of trade pacts former President Bill Clinton began signing into law beginning with NAFTA. These rules had little or nothing to do with Ricardo’s ideas about comparative advantage. They weren’t based on natural differences in climate, culture or expertise. They were an attempt to construct an international law that favored a particular brand of inegalitarian politics.

The spirit of this new era of globalization was most obvious in the realm of intellectual property ― an arcane, technical arena with life and death implications for millions of people. Once again, South Africa became the epicenter of a global economic conflict.
The WTO And The AIDS Crisis

When Nelson Mandela’s government was elected in 1994, the HIV rate in South Africa was spiraling out of control, with roughly 10 percent of the country’s 39 million citizens already infected. American pharmaceutical companies had developed powerful and effective new drugs to treat HIV, with the capacity to extend lives by years, even decades. But the treatments came at a price. AIDS and HIV medication cost roughly $12,000 per patient, per year in a country with an average annual income of about $2,600.

This was obviously unaffordable for both individual South Africans and the new democratic government. South Africa’s entire economy generated roughly $140 billion a year. Treating every AIDS and HIV patient would have required shipping one-third of the nation’s annual wealth to American pharmaceutical companies every year. In the United States today, it would be comparable to spending almost $6.6 trillion ― 65 percent more than the entire annual federal budget ― on AIDS and HIV alone. There was simply no way to establish a functional national economic program with such costs.

The Clinton administration argued that WTO treaties on intellectual property gave pharmaceutical firms clear rights to charge what they wanted. WTO agreements included 20-year patent rights that guaranteed monopolies on new drugs and prohibited generic competition or government price controls. These terms, of course, had nothing to do with Ricardo’s ideas about comparative advantage. But they were still defended with the language of “free trade.”

Mandela had a deadly pandemic on his hands. In 1997, he signed a law authorizing his administration to shop around the world for cheaper drug prices. The United States, citing a WTO treaty, threatened to retaliate with trade sanctions on the grounds that the new law would “abrogate patent rights.” Mandela put the implementation of the new law on hold, even as the AIDS crisis spread to terrifying new proportions. By 2000, more than 22 percent of the country would be infected.

A new Indian pharmaceutical firm began producing HIV medication for the “humanitarian” price of $1 a day, portending a revolution in public health strategy, but the Clinton administration took pride in holding the line against South Africa on its “international commitments.” Clinton only relented when protesters descended on Vice President Al Gore’s presidential campaign announcement rally in Tennessee, unveiling a banner for the cameras reading “Gore’s Greed Kills: AIDS Drugs For Africa.”

Obama would prove to be nearly as aggressive. Higher global drug prices were a primary goal of his Trans-Pacific Partnership trade pact, and everyone from his deputy director of the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office to Secretary of State John Kerry leaned on India to curb the production of generic drugs, which were lowering treatment costs around the world. In 2016, the Obama administration and Senate Finance Committee Chairman Orrin Hatch (R-Utah) even threatened to spike a peace deal between the Colombian government and Marxist rebel group Revolutionary Armed Forces of Colombia, known as FARC, over pricing for a leukemia drug (they only backed down after the private threat leaked to the press, prompting an international outcry).

Clinton had set a grisly diplomatic precedent. In front of the cameras, however, he presented his trade agenda as a grandiose humanitarian project. When he finalized a new trade pact with China in 2000, Clinton boasted the deal was ”likely to have a profound impact on human rights and political liberty,” creating pressure for China to “choose political reform.” The argument was essentially a refurbished version Flake’s case for free trade with apartheid South Africa.

“The process of economic change will force China to confront that choice sooner, and it will make the imperative for the right choice stronger,” Clinton said.
U.S. President Donald Trump takes part in a welcoming ceremony with China's President Xi Jinping.
Damir Sagolj / Reuters
U.S. President Donald Trump takes part in a welcoming ceremony with China’s President Xi Jinping.
Breaking From Dependence

Today, Trump refers to Chinese President Xi Jinping as “the king of China” with admiration, while Chinese democracy advocates die in prison. But the global economy has indeed changed as a result of the choices made in the 1990s. Under the WTO, the American corporate colonialism of the apartheid era turned in on itself, cannibalizing the U.S. social order in the quest for higher returns on capital. “The China Shock,” as it became known, probably eliminated about 2.4 million American jobs ― many of them concentrated in communities that have never really recovered.

Part of Trump’s appeal in 2016 was based on his promise to overthrow this order. In the Republican primary, he won 89 of the 100 U.S. counties hurt most by trade with China. In the general election, he swept the Rust Belt, taking conventional Democratic Party strongholds in Wisconsin, Michigan and Pennsylvania. Millions of people who voted for Obama voted for Trump based in part on his promise to save manufacturing jobs.

He has instead offered belligerent, xenophobic chaos. But there is plenty of important work a thoughtful reformer could do. What we call free trade today is not a stable system reflecting several decades of consistent economic thinking. “Free trade” is a label that political leaders have applied to a variety of different colonial systems. It has changed before, and it can change again.

Old trade deals can and should be reopened to establish stronger international rights for workers and communities. And it makes good national security sense to establish some degree of American economic independence from a rising authoritarian superpower. Nearly every supply chain for things Americans buy runs through China at some point. That’s a dangerous amount of political leverage for one country, and limiting it will require a few tariffs.

These changes would take time, and cost money. But it is a matter of managing the transition. We do not face a choice between reason and the abyss.

CORRECTION: A previous version of this article stated that Quinn Slobodian teaches at Wesleyan College. He teaches at Wellesley.
headshot
Zach Carter
Senior Political Economy Reporter, HuffPost
Suggest a correction
MORE:
Donald Trump Politics And Government South Africa Free Trade John Maynard Keynes
Trump’s Tariff War Is The Final Act Of A Broken System

Dr. Mercola: Ben & Jerry's Sued for Misleading Customers


Ben & Jerry’s Sued for Misleading Customers

    July 24, 2018 • 11,377 views

Story at-a-glance

    Ben & Jerry’s, loved by so many because of its environmentally friendly image, is being sued by Organic Consumers Association (OCA), which alleges its do-good reputation and marketing campaigns are all “smoke and mirrors”
    In the lawsuit, OCA takes issue with statements that the ice cream is made using milk from “happy cows” raised in “Caring Dairies,” which leads consumers to believe it comes from sustainable, humane farms
    In reality, Ben & Jerry’s sources its milk and cream from a co-op in St. Albans City, Vermont, which gets milk from hundreds of farms, fewer than 25 percent of which adhere to Ben & Jerry’s “Caring Dairy” standards
    Despite their claims of environmental stewardship and sustainability, Ben & Jerry’s makes its ice cream with CAFO milk and refuses to switch over to 100 percent organic, grass fed dairy

By Dr. Mercola

Ben & Jerry's, loved by so many because of its environmentally friendly image, is being sued by Organic Consumers Association (OCA), which alleges its do-good reputation and marketing campaigns are all "smoke and mirrors."1 In the lawsuit against Ben & Jerry's and their parent company, Unilever, filed in July 2018, OCA takes issue with statements that the ice cream is made using milk from "happy cows" raised in "Caring Dairies."2

They promote their Caring Dairy program as involving "family operated" farms working toward sustainable dairy farming, and state that farmers must meet the program's basic requirements to be included. This, the lawsuit claims, leads "consumers to believe that the products are produced using animal-raising practices that are more humane than those used on regular factory-style, mass production dairy operations."

Even the peaceful cows on their ice cream pints, silhouetted by green pastures and blue skies, give the impression that ice cream, or at least its milk, is a wholesome product you can feel good about buying. You, and many others, would probably be surprised to learn that this is very much a carefully crafted illusion.
Ben & Jerry's Uses CAFO Milk

Ben & Jerry's has set itself apart from other ice cream makers in the frozen dairy aisle, largely because of their claims of "values-led sourcing" and "Caring Dairy" promises, which built a loyal fan base. "Due to concerns about health, sustainability and animal welfare, consumers are increasingly considering how their food is produced and the effects of that production on animals and the environment," OCA's lawsuit states.

"As a result, consumers seek out products that are produced with farming and grazing practices that lead to humanely-raised animals, clean water, healthy soil and a toxin-free environment, such as practices associated with regenerative agriculture."3 The company is so popular that it was the second-largest ice cream brand in 2017, bringing in $801 million in sales.4

But if you look closely, there are some key terms missing from the ice cream labels that signal perhaps they're not as environmentally friendly as they'd like you to believe — terms like "organic" and "grass fed," for starters. They'd certainly get a different reaction from consumers if their labels touted what's really inside, like milk from concentrated animal feeding operations (CAFOs).

"In contrast to Unilever's representations, the products include milk that comes from cows raised in regular factory-style, mass-production dairy operations, also known as 'Concentrated Animal Feeding Operations' or 'Large Farm Operations' — not in the special 'Caring Dairies' emphasized in Unilever's marketing," OCA states.5

The nonprofit advocacy group Regeneration Vermont, which, along with OCA, has been invested in trying to get Ben & Jerry's to clean up their act, revealed that Ben & Jerry's sources their milk and cream from a co-op in St. Albans City, Vermont.

About 360 farms contribute milk to the co-op, but fewer than 25 percent adhere to Ben & Jerry's "Caring Dairy" standards. Yet, when the milk is delivered, it's all mixed together, so there's no way to tell whether the milk you're getting came from a Caring Dairy farm or a CAFO. "So even if some of the milk comes from a farm that actually meets those standards, Ben & Jerry's can't truthfully claim that all of their milk and cream come from dairies that meet the company's 'Caring Dairy' standards," OCA points out.6

Brent Johnson, a class-action defense lawyer who is not involved with the case, told Bloomberg, "If it's true that St. Albans' mixes milk production, and some don't qualify as a Caring Dairy under the standards articulated by Ben & Jerry's, that's to me the plaintiffs' best case."7
Ben & Jerry's Tainted by Glyphosate Herbicide

Another one of the lawsuit's complaints centers on Ben & Jerry's claims that their products help reduce environmental impact, an ironic marketing claim for a product tainted by chemical pesticides.

In July 2017, OCA reported that 10 of 11 samples of Ben & Jerry's ice cream they tested came back positive for glyphosate, the active ingredient in Monsanto's Roundup herbicide, and/or its main metabolite AMPA.8 The fan favorites Phish Food, Half Baked and Americone Dream are just a few examples found to contain glyphosate or its metabolites.

In 2017, OCA called on Ben & Jerry's to immediately transition to using only organic ingredients, including milk, "or face a national and international consumer boycott." Ben & Jerry's responded by stating their products are safe to eat and contain only trace levels below those allowed by regulatory standards. However, daily exposure to even ultra-low levels of glyphosate for two years led to nonalcoholic fatty liver disease (NAFLD) in rats in one study.9

Ben & Jerry's also subsequently released a "vision of sustainable agriculture," with claims that they would stop using ingredients made with crops chemically dried using glyphosate by 2020. In northern, colder regions farmers of wheat and barley must wait for their crops to dry out prior to harvest. Rather than wait an additional two weeks or so for this to happen naturally, Monsanto urged farmers to spray the plants with glyphosate, killing the crop and accelerating their drying (a process known as desiccating).

It's a step in the right direction for Ben & Jerry's to not use ingredients from desiccated crops, but as OCA noted, this only applies to their nondairy ingredients. Organic dairy is another animal entirely, but to this Ben & Jerry's responded that they would come out with a new product line in 2018 that will include organic dairy in the base mix.

They anticipate the new organic line is only going to represent up to 6 percent of total U.S. sales,10 which means they have no intention of sourcing the bulk of their dairy from organic sources in the near future.
Ben & Jerry's Supports Vermont's Biggest Polluter: The Dairy Industry

Big Dairy is a major source of pollution in Vermont, a state overrun with CAFO dairies feeding their cows heavily pesticide-sprayed genetically engineered corn. According to Regeneration Vermont, in a report titled, "A Failure to Regulate: Big Dairy & Water Pollution in Vermont":11

    "[C]ontamination from the mega-dairies that supply Vermont's big brands, like Ben & Jerry's and Cabot Cheese, is nothing new to Vermonters,12 especially when it comes to the contamination of our waterways. For decades, these iconic brands have garnered enormous profits — each hovering around the $1 billion-a-year level — while pushing a kind of confinement, non-grazing dairy production, resulting in a toxic farm runoff that is literally choking our lakes and streams.

    Even the beloved Lake Champlain is one of more than 100 other bodies of water in Vermont that are classified as 'impaired.' And, in many cases, 'impaired' means filled with the green slime that is cyanobacteria, smelling so badly that summer camps have become uninhabitable, and beaches are posted with signs that warn, 'no swimming.'"

Lake Carmi is another Vermont lake plagued by cyanobacteria or blue-green algae. It's of particular importance to Ben & Jerry's, or should be, because it sits in Franklin County, a region with 36,000 CAFO cows that supply dairy for Ben & Jerry's ice cream.13 Regeneration Vermont and members of the Franklin Watershed Committee even took Ben & Jerry's executives on a tour of Lake Carmi and the surrounding watershed to see the damage firsthand.

In a commentary by Jostein Solheim, Ben & Jerry's CEO, it's noted, "Ben & Jerry's recognizes that we are connected to the farms in the Lake Carmi watershed. Our Caring Dairy farm program, which we implement through the St. Albans Cooperative, has members in the Lake Carmi watershed … The condition of the lake, the hardship it's forced upon local residents and businesses is, well, heartbreaking."14

Apparently, it wasn't heartbreaking enough to prompt the company to ask their farmers to switch to organic farming methods, however. As Michael Colby, former editor of Food & Water Journal and cofounder of Regeneration Vermont, stated, they have no reason to switch to organic or grass fed farming because "the marketing is working just fine."

"'People think we're organic,' is what we were told time and time again in private meetings," Colby says, "while asking them to actually go organic. If fooling people allows for maximizing profits, why stop fooling them?"15
OCA Hopes Lawsuit Will Prompt Ben & Jerry's to Clean Up Its Ice Cream

The purpose of OCA's lawsuit is to bring attention and awareness to the fact that one of the biggest "environmentally friendly" ice cream makers in the U.S. is actually supporting an industry that harms animals, the environment and public health. Meanwhile, Unilever has a nearly $9 billion annual advertising budget, which means they can afford to support real, positive changes in the industry.

"Ben & Jerry's is on a mission to spin a false and misleading story about a company that has a lousy track record when it comes to sourcing ingredients from socially and environmentally responsible producers," OCA noted. "We think the company should spend less on misleading product claims, and invest more in helping Vermont dairy farmers transition to organic and regenerative practices that actually support those claims."16

Still, the fact remains that as long as consumers continue to buy Ben & Jerry's products as-is, they have little incentive to change, unless their Powers That Be suddenly dial in to a more altruistic tune. What would make them take notice? Backlash from their customers over their environmentally irresponsible and inhumane dairy sourcing.

OCA added, "Consumers who care about their health, the environment and animal welfare would do better to buy organic brands from companies that don't source glyphosate-sprayed ingredients and that do source from dairies that meet organic standards."17

It remains to be seen how OCA's lawsuit will pan out, but you can take a stand now by choosing only organic ice cream in lieu of Ben & Jerry's. You can also send Ben & Jerry's a message using the online contact form at the bottom of their contact page letting them know why you've chosen to no longer purchase their products. Better yet, call Ben & Jerry's directly (802-846-1500) and ask the company to fulfill their mission statement and go organic.

OCA has also created a petition18 to encourage Ben & Jerry's to convert to organic and stop hoodwinking customers into thinking they're organic by claiming to be all-natural and environmentally responsible. By filing a lawsuit, OCA stated, they hope Ben & Jerry's will ultimately "do the right thing" by helping Vermont dairy farmers transition to organic or, at the very least, stop misleading consumers with their misleading marketing.19
+ Sources and References
Most Popular

    Uses of Spikenard
    Chamomile Tea
    Raspberry Ketones
    Healthy Recipes

Post your comment
Show Comments (12)
Previous Article
Next Article
Subscribe to Dr. Mercola's Natural Health Newsletter

Thank you! Your purchases help us support these charities and organizations.

    Inside Mercola.com
    About Dr. Mercola
    Contact Us
    Employment Opportunities
    En Espanol
    Health Articles
    Health Videos
    Media Inquiries
    Mercola Community FAQ
    Mercola Social Responsibility
    Press Room
    Special Reports
    Terms & Conditions
    Updated Privacy Policy

    Special Info Sites
    Aspartame
    Cancer
    Fitness
    Fluoride
    Fructose/Sugar
    GMO
    Mercury
    Nutritional Typing
    Pets
    Vaccines
    Vitamin D

    Shopping
    Autoship Program
    California Supply Chains Act
    FAQs
    GMO-Free Products
    Healthy Rewards Program
    Low Price Guarantee
    Online Product Guide
    Online Shopping

   
    Our Service Commitment
    Premium Products
    Product Badge Glossary
    Return Policy
    Shipping Policy (Domestic)
    Shipping Policy (International)
    Store Locator
    Wholesale Program

Disclaimer: The entire contents of this website are based upon the opinions of Dr. Mercola, unless otherwise noted. Individual articles are based upon the opinions of the respective author, who retains copyright as marked. The information on this website is not intended to replace a one-on-one relationship with a qualified health care professional and is not intended as medical advice. It is intended as a sharing of knowledge and information from the research and experience of Dr. Mercola and his community. Dr. Mercola encourages you to make your own health care decisions based upon your research and in partnership with a qualified health care professional. If you are pregnant, nursing, taking medication, or have a medical condition, consult your health care professional before using products based on this content.

If you want to use an article on your site please click here. This content may be copied in full, with copyright, contact, creation and information intact, without specific permission, when used only in a not-for-profit format. If any other use is desired, permission in writing from Dr. Mercola is required.

Terms & Conditions | Updated Privacy Policy | Sitemap

© Copyright 1997-2018 Dr. Joseph Mercola. All Rights Reserved.

    Mercola Health Resources, LLC BBB Business Review
    McAfee SECURE sites help keep you safe from identity theft, credit card fraud, spyware, spam, viruses and online scams
    TRUSTe online privacy certification
    Click to Verify - This site has chosen a GeoTrust SSL Certificate to improve Web site security
    Privacy Policy

Mercola.com

Call Toll Free: 877-985-2695

    4Save
    Email
    Copy Link

Read Previous
Read Next