National Review/Jack Crowe: Hawley to Introduce Bill Making It Easier to Sue Big Tech Firms Over Political Bias

National Review

Jun. 19, 2019
News
Politics & Policy   
Hawley to Introduce Bill Making It Easier to Sue Big Tech Firms Over Political Bias
By Jack Crowe   

June 19, 2019 9:01 AM

Senator Josh Hawley (R, Mo.) on Capitol Hill in Washington, D.C. January 3, 2019 (Aaron P. Bernstein/Reuters)

Senator Josh Hawley (R., Mo.) plans to introduce legislation that would make it easier for consumers to sue big tech companies that display overt political bias, his office announced Wednesday.

The bill would make firms like Facebook, Youtube, and Google legally liable for user-generated content, unless and until they can demonstrate that their content moderation processes are unaffected by political bias.

“This legislation simply states that if the tech giants want to keep their government-granted immunity, they must bring transparency and accountability to their editorial processes and prove that they don’t discriminate,” Hawley said in a news release.

Under Section 230 of the Communications Decency Act, tech platforms are currently immune from legal action related to the user-generated content they host.
Stay Updated with NR Daily

NR's afternoon roundup of the day's best commentary & must-read analysis.

Hawley, who has emerged as the foremost Republican critic of big tech in his first months in office, plans to strip companies of that protection in order to counter the anti-conservative bias he believes is rife within Silicon Valley firms. In doing so, he is channeling the longstanding Republican charge that social media platforms profit from a double standard in which they curate user content according to their political biases, in much the same way a publisher would, while continuing to benefit from the legal protections afforded to neutral platforms.

The proposed legislation would only apply to sites that have more than 30 million active users in the U.S., 50 million active users worldwide or more than $500 million in annual revenue. Companies that exceed those benchmarks would be required to demonstrate every two years “by clear and convincing evidence” that they do not “negatively affect a political party, political candidate, or political viewpoint” through their content curation.

The bill currently has no co-sponsors and will likely face stiff opposition from Democrats, who disbelieve the charge of anti-conservative bias, and business-friendly Republicans averse to exposing tech firms to seemingly endless litigation.

Jack Crowe is a news writer at National Review Online. @JackRCrowe
More in Politics & Policy   
The Wrong Bogeymen
Could a Revenue-Neutral Carbon Tax Be the First Step to Fight Climate Change?
National Popular Vote Movement Tries to Win Over Skeptical Conservatives
A Sensible Middle Ground on Data Privacy
Recommended Articles
Most Popular
Politics & Policy   
FBI Lovebirds Is D.C. Satire at Its Best
By John Fund
Education   
Harvard Demonstrates Once Again That Post-Christian America Is Post-Forgiveness America
By David French
Video
Culture with Kat Timpf: 16-Year-Old Girl Shouldn’t Face Child-Porn Charges
Politics & Policy   
Parkland Shooting Survivor Has Harvard Admission Rescinded over Old Comments
By Alexandra DeSanctis
Law & the Courts   
SCOTUS Sends Gay-Wedding-Cake Case Back to State Court
By Jack Crowe
Politics & Policy   
Since When Are Liberals against Investigating the CIA and FBI?
By Jonathan S. Tobin
Film & TV   
In Toy Story 4, the Franchise Shows Its Age
By Kyle Smith
Science & Tech   
We Survived the Net-Neutrality Apocalypse
By Christopher Tremoglie
Law & the Courts   
Democrats’ Hypocrisy on ‘Foreign Interference’
By Andrew C. McCarthy
World   
Why Transgender Activist, Munroe Bergdorf, Should Not Work with Children
By Madeleine Kearns

    ...

    Donate
    Subscribe

    Sections
        The Corner
        Bench Memos
        The Morning Jolt
        The G-File
        News
        Books, Arts & Manners
        All Articles
        All Authors
        Podcasts
        Photos
        Games
        Videos

    Topics
        Politics & Policy
        Culture
        White House
        Film & TV
        PC Culture
        U.S.
        World
        Immigration
        Economy & Business
        Elections

    Magazine
        Latest Issue
        Archive
        Subscribe
        Gve NR as a Gift
        Customer Care
        NRPLUS
        Magazine FAQ
        NRPLUS FAQ

    About
        Frequently Asked Questions
        The Masthead
        Contact Us
        Careers
        Privacy Policy
        Terms of Service
        NR Institute

    More
        Advertise
        Donate
        Search
        E-mails & Alerts

Newsletters
Morning Jolt (M-F)
NR Daily (M-Sa)
Breaking News (M-Su)

© 2019 National Review