TechCrunch/Romain Dillet: Libra currently looks more like a fiat currency than a cryptocurrency

TechCrunch

Libra currently looks more like a fiat currency than a cryptocurrency

Romain Dillet@romaindillet / 6 hours ago
Image (1) dollarss.jpg for post 174265

Facebook unveiled a cryptocurrency called Libra yesterday, as well as the Libra Association, a not-for-profit that will oversee all things Libra. While Libra’s white paper draws a lot of inspiration from other cryptocurrencies, the current governance model and blockchain implementation remind me of banks more than bitcoin.

Permissioned blockchain

The Libra Blockchain is designed like a true blockchain, with a Byzantine Fault Tolerance approach, the use of Merkle trees to guarantee the integrity and a network of nodes.

And yet, unlike popular blockchains, such as the bitcoin blockchain or the Ethereum blockchain, you won’t be able to run a node in your backyard. Only founding members of the Libra Association will be able to run a node. There are currently 28 members, such as Vodafone, Mastercard, Visa, Stripe, Uber and Spotify.

In other words, it looks like a blockchain, but it’s not a real blockchain. It’s not truly decentralized. It’s not truly open, as the ledger of transactions will be accessible to Libra Association founding members exclusively — unless Facebook or another founding member builds a public-facing API of some sort.

Facebook is well aware of that, as the company says it plans to let anyone run a node at some point over the next five years:

    To ensure that Libra is truly open and always operates in the best interest of its users, our ambition is for the Libra network to become permissionless. The challenge is that as of today we do not believe that there is a proven solution that can deliver the scale, stability, and security needed to support billions of people and transactions across the globe through a permissionless network. One of the association’s directives will be to work with the community to research and implement this transition, which will begin within five years of the public launch of the Libra Blockchain and ecosystem.

Authorized resellers

The Libra cryptocurrency is a stablecoin, as it is tied to a basket of fiat currencies and securities. So it requires a lot of oversight to make sure that every time the Libra Association mints a Libra, they buy and store the equivalent in fiat currencies and securities in a bank account.

Similarly, every time someone converts Libra into, say, USD, the Libra Association has to issue a selling order on the equivalent in fiat currencies and securities.

That’s why the Libra Association will work with a list of authorized resellers. It creates a barrier to entry and transforms the Libra Association into a regulatory body for the Libra ecosystem.

Once again, this works against decentralization as only trustworthy partners will get a license to operate as an authorized reseller. Small financial institutions will have no choice but to work with an authorized reseller if their clients want to get paid back in Libra, for instance. All the founding members become a sort of Visa or Mastercard for the 21st century.

Other stablecoins, such as USDC, work in a similar fashion. If you want to support USDC on your exchange or payment service, you have to become a member of the CENTRE Consortium.

But anybody can look at the USDC ledger, as USDC is an ERC-20 token built on top of the Ethereum blockchain. If you run an Ethereum node, you indirectly contribute to USDC transactions. And there are a ton of partner exchanges that open up a lot of opportunities.
Shadow bank

There’s a reason why French Finance Minister Bruno Le Maire told Europe 1 that Libra can’t “become a sovereign currency.” In some countries with high inflation rates, Libra could become an instant hit and power many of the peer-to-peer and even business-to-customer transactions.

But central banks that issue currencies and conduct monetary policies are members of the International Monetary Funds. They also have different objectives compared to private entities.

Given the current nature of the Libra Association, there’s a chance that Libra becomes a quasi-sovereign currency in Venezuela, Argentina, Turkey or South Africa — but it would be controlled by private companies that don’t care about monetary policies.

There’s a reason why the European Union is moving toward a single market but can’t agree at all on budget, tax harmonization and debt. Similarly, China cracked down on the shadow banking system because it caused systemic risks.

Governments will want strict oversight on the Libra Association because the association could change its goals overnight. What if they remove a fiat currency from the basket of fiat currencies and securities? What if they start issuing credit?

Essentially, the Libra Association is now in charge of a quasi-fiat currency and will face a ton of challenges on the regulatory front. It comes down from its governance structure and technical implementation.
Disrupt SF 2019
Prices increase this Friday 6/21

San Francisco Oct 2 - 4
Get Passes Now
Sign up for Newsletters

See all newsletters(opens in a new window)
The Daily Crunch
The Weekly Roundup
Crunchbase Daily
Email
(opens in a new window)
(opens in a new window)
(opens in a new window)
(opens in a new window)
Copy
Tags

    Cryptocurrency
    TC
    Facebook(opens in a new window)
    Libra
    Libra Association(opens in a new window)
    stablecoin

Libra currently looks more like a fiat currency than a cryptocurrency
6 hours agoRomain Dillet
Calibra wallet won’t launch in Facebook’s biggest market
23 mins agoManish Singh
Netflix signs landmark deal with writer-director Janet Mock
29 mins agoAnthony Ha
Google launches Chromebook App Hub for educators plus other classroom tools
30 mins agoSarah Perez
Google to face shareholders on censored ‘Dragonfly’ search in China
42 mins agoZack Whittaker
Launch your startup onstage at TechCrunch Disrupt SF 2019
43 mins agoNeesha A. Tambe
Fluent acquires AdParlor, a social ad specialist previously owned by Adknowledge, for $10M
1 hour agoIngrid Lunden
Jeffrey Katzenberg’s streaming service Quibi books $100M in ad sales ahead of launch
1 hour agoSarah Perez
Humanising Autonomy pulls in $5M to help self-driving cars keep an eye on pedestrians
2 hours agoDevin Coldewey
Only 72 hours left to save big on passes to Disrupt SF 2019
2 hours agoEmma Comeau
CMU researchers use computer vision to see around corners
2 hours agoDarrell Etherington
Text IQ, a machine learning platform for parsing sensitive corporate data, raises $12.6M
2 hours agoJordan Crook
textiq
Extra Crunch
Risks and rewards of digital therapeutics in treating mental disorders
3 hours ago
Apple expands authorized repairs to ~1,000 Best Buy stores
3 hours agoBrian Heater
broken iphone
Geely is turning to Zenuity as its self-driving software supplier
3 hours agoKirsten Korosec
Geely-CHINA-AUTO
China to lose top spot to U.S. in 2019 gaming market
3 hours agoRita Liao
Extra Crunch
Tally’s Jason Brown on fintech’s first debt roboadvisor and an automated financial future
4 hours agoGregg Schoenberg
Whitebox raises $5M for its e-commerce logistics platform
4 hours agoAnthony Ha
Whitebox team
Amazon adds color adjustable lighting to its best Kindle
4 hours agoBrian Heater
Netflix reveals the top TVs it thinks you should use to binge watch in 2019
4 hours agoDarrell Etherington
Echo, the medication management app, has been acquired by LloydsPharmacy-owner McKesson
4 hours agoSteve O'Hear

    TechCrunchPrivacy PolicyAbout Our AdsCode of ConductTerms of Service

© 2013-2019 Verizon Media. All rights reserved. Powered by WordPress VIP(opens in a new window). Fonts by TypeKit(opens in a new window).






Sent from Samsung tablet.