National Review
Feb. 21, 2019
White House
The FBI Is Not a Separate Branch of Government
By Rich Lowry
February 20, 2019 6:30 AM
FBI Trump Russia Investigation
Acting FBI Director Andrew McCabe testifies before a Senate Intelligence Committee hearing, June 7, 2017. (Aaron P. Bernstein/Reuters)
Whatever you do, never fire the FBI director.
It’s too early to take away any clear lessons from the Trump era, except one: Whatever you do, never fire the FBI director.
Yes, as president, it is fully within your power to cashier inferior executive-branch officers. But if the aftermath of the James Comey firing is any indication, it risks backlash from FBI and Justice Department officials who will take umbrage — and extraordinary steps in response.
This is the upshot of the 60 Minutes interview of former Deputy Director Andrew McCabe. The Comey firing was ham-fisted and unsettling given the ongoing investigation of Russian interference into the 2016 election. But what ensued was an embarrassing freakout by law-enforcement officials entrusted with awesome powers.
According to McCabe, Deputy Attorney General Rod Rosenstein brought up invoking the 25th Amendment.
It’s worth considering how this Rube Goldberg amendment is supposed to work: The vice president takes power if he and a majority of the Cabinet declare in writing to the Senate and the House that the president is “unable to discharge the powers and duties of his office.”
NOW WATCH: 'Bernie Sanders Is Running in 2020'
Then the president can contest the declaration, also in writing, to the Senate and the House. If the vice president and a majority of the Cabinet still say he can’t serve, Congress has 21 days to vote on the question. If two-thirds of both houses says he can’t, the vice president remains acting president.
Anyone who believes that this was a remotely plausible or appropriate means to depose Donald Trump should have his own ability to discharge his duties examined.
First of all, Trump obviously was perfectly capable of discharging his duties; he just discharged them in a way alarming to McCabe and Rosenstein. His response to an effort by his Cabinet to join such an exercise would have been to fire anyone involved, which he could have done because, again, he wasn’t incapacitated.
McCabe also says that Rosenstein twice discussed wearing a wire to record the president and wasn’t joking. (A source told the New York Times when it originally broke the story that Rosenstein meant it sarcastically; his own denials have been carefully worded.)
The FBI didn’t go this far, but it did open, per McCabe, two probes into the president to determine if he was a Russian agent or had obstructed justice.
Consider the lunacy of this: By providing Trump with a memo justifying Comey’s firing, Rosenstein participated in the scheme that the FBI considered a possible crime, or the culmination of a Russian plot. Then Rosenstein turned around and appointed a special counsel, whom he oversaw, to investigate the possible crime to which he was a party.
It’s also absurd that the FBI officials considered the firing of Comey to be potential obstruction of the investigation that they were continuing, and indeed making more serious by making the president an explicit target.
The comments that Trump made about Russia that McCabe and Co. found so disturbing were hardly damning. In his cover letter over Rosenstein’s memo, Trump mentioned that Comey had told him three times that he wasn’t under investigation. This was true, and Trump was frustrated that Comey wouldn’t make it public. That doesn’t make him a Russian agent.
In his notorious Lester Holt interview, Trump said he fired Comey because there wasn’t anything to him and Russia. He didn’t say he wanted to shut down the probe; indeed, he said he understood it would now probably go on longer.
Perhaps Trump’s comments in his ill-considered meeting with the Russian foreign minister and ambassador in the immediate aftermath of the Comey firing were worse, but it’s hard to say absent a transcript.
187
What McCabe’s version strongly suggests is that the FBI took upon itself to be a check on the president of the United States. This is not its appointed role in our system. If the president abuses his powers, that’s a matter for Congress to take up, not for executive-branch officials whose panic eclipsed their judgment.
© 2019 by King Features Syndicate
187
Rich Lowry — Rich Lowry is the editor of National Review. He can be reached via email: comments.lowry@nationalreview.com. @richlowry
More in White House
Congress Is Complicit in Trump’s Power Grab
Trump’s National-Emergency Declaration Is an Act of Weakness
When Bureaucrats Veto the President
Collusion: The Criminalization of Policy Disputes
Recommended Articles
Adam Schiff Remarks McCabe Firing ‘May Be Justified’
Mairead McArdle
Trump Should Keep Calm and Sic His Surrogates on Comey
Deroy Murdock
McCabe Claims Officials Discussed Invoking 25th Amendment to Remove Trump
Jack Crowe
When Did It Become the FBI’s Job to Act as a Check and Balance to the President?
Rich Lowry
SPONSORED CONTENT
Military Smartwatch Everybody in Ghana is Talking About Military… techdiscountfinder.com
Big tech knows more than you think, says DuckDuckGo Founder. Big… Quora
This Military Smartwatch Is The Best Gift Idea for Men In Ghana This… techdiscountfinder.com
25 Insanely Cool Products You Didn't Know You Needed 25… Top25.nexttech.com
This Cheap Drone Is The Most Amazing Invention In Ghana This… hyperstech.com
Military Watch Everybody in Ghana is Talking About Military… en.nexttech.com
With Nourishing Meals, One Man Overcomes Leprosy in Burkina Faso With… Rise Against Hunger
Dirty Glasses? This is going wild in $[country]$ Dirty… en.nexttech.com
Recommended by
PROMOTED POSTS
Chris Wallace Gets Schooled When He Tries To Browbeat Rush
bizpacreview.com
Oscar Predictions: What Will Win, What Should Win
factswanted.com
Trump Campaign Fundraising On Bernie Sanders' $6M Haul
thehill.com
Jussie Smollett Officially A Suspect In Alleged Chicago Attack
thehill.com
Most Popular
World
Ilhan Omar’s Big Lie
By Rich Lowry
U.S.
Questions for Those Who Believed Jussie Smollett
By Kyle Smith
Video
New Poll Shows Dems Have Reasons to Fear Schultz
PC Culture
Fake Newspeople
By Ben Shapiro
U.S.
White Progressives Are Polarizing America
By David French
Law & the Courts
Stephen Miller’s Own Words Show the Weakness of the Trump Legal Argument on the Wall
By David French
Law & the Courts
McCabe and 60 Minutes Avoid Discussing Why Russia Factored in Comey’s Firing
By Andrew C. McCarthy
Law & the Courts
#BelieveWomen Is in a State of Legal Collapse
By David French
Login
© 2019 National Review
Donate
Subscribe
Sections
The Corner
Bench Memos
The Morning Jolt
The G-File
News
Books, Arts & Manners
All Articles
All Authors
Podcasts
Photos
Games
Videos
Topics
Politics & Policy
Culture
White House
Film & TV
PC Culture
U.S.
World
Immigration
Economy & Business
Elections
Magazine
Latest Issue
Archive
Subscribe
Gve NR as a Gift
Customer Care
NRPLUS
Magazine FAQ
NRPLUS FAQ
About
Frequently Asked Questions
The Masthead
Contact Us
Careers
Privacy Policy
Terms of Service
NR Institute
More
Advertise
Donate
Search
E-mails & Alerts
Newsletters
Morning Jolt (M-F)
NR Daily (M-Sa)
The G-File (F)
Breaking News (M-Su)
© 2019 National Review
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment