Social Europe
Politics, Economy and Employment & Labour
Home ・ Employment and Labour ・ It’s time to talk about democracy at work
It’s time to talk about democracy at work
By Stan De Spiegelaere on 22nd May 2019
TwitterFacebookLinkedinE-mail
Democracy at work has many benefits but above all it is a matter of human dignity.
democracy at work
Stan De Spiegelaere
My normal bike commute to work was interrupted by red flags. No revolution (yet) but industrial action blocked access to an energy company (and my bike path). Asked about their complaints, one of the strikers said: ‘Management ignores the rules and our agreements. And, worst of all, for a month now they refuse even to talk to us to find a solution.’
While ‘not following the rules’ is costing the employee money, the fact that the management refuses even to have a discussion is an affront to the worker’s dignity. The only answer he could find was joining the strike and blockading the offices.
Many of the institutions we have in companies, such as trade unions and works councils, are there to ensure basic human rights. Employees are not machines. They are human beings and citizens, with rights and liberties. And in a democracy that means they have (or should have) the right to be heard, to be involved in decision making—be that in politics or in the workplace.
Join our almost 30.000 subscribers!
"Social Europe publishes thought-provoking articles on the big political and economic issues of our time analysed from a European viewpoint. Indispensable reading!"
Polly Toynbee
Columnist for The Guardian
Powered by ConvertKit
Democracy at work
Recent research has looked at those (European) countries and employees enjoying a high degree of ‘democracy at work’—whether through representation or direct involvement in decision making—and compared the outcomes with those where such a voice is not heard. This shows that democracy at work brings many advantages, to the employee, the society at large and companies themselves.
First of all, workers who have a strong voice at work are more likely to be democratically engaged citizens, as they show more interest and vote more. Labour isn’t only at the origin of many democratic transformations—it also sustains the system by stimulating interest in politics and letting workers experience democratic processes in their workplace or union.
But there is much more. Countries with strong democracy at work have more productive economies and higher employment rates and are more innovative. The argument that giving employees a voice will stifle the economy seems unfounded.
More importantly, countries with strong democracy at work are also more equal. And inequality has been recognised to be an important threat to democracy.
Listen to the latest episode of Social Europe Podcast
Social Europe Podcast
#42: Colin Mayer: The Future of the Corporation - Why Businesses need to rediscover their historic purpose
What’s more, employees who enjoy a strong voice at work are, on average, considerably more satisfied with life than their colleagues who have a very weak voice. The example of the worker who complained about his management not talking to him perfectly illustrates how lack of voice can eat away at a worker’s dignity and therefore her/his life satisfaction.
’Shareholder value’
Companies are (currently) established with one priority: increase profits and thus the returns to the owners, the shareholders. For this, they need the co-operation of their employees and, depending on how much co-operation is required, companies will go a short or long way to address employee needs. But they remain focused on their target.
Democracy at work instils a minimum of accountability on the part of the management—a minimum of oversight over how (and why) certain decisions are taken—and provides a push towards equal treatment. As a result, companies will be more likely to take into account salary ratios as well as environmental, social and other concerns.
All in all, democracy at work thus stimulates companies to take a broader perspective. In the process, employees are emancipated, which is beneficial for their belief and participation in political democracy. If one can keep one’s boss accountable, one can do the same with one’s mayor or minister.
Radical change
A political agenda for more democracy at work would however entail a radical change of direction in most European countries and the EU. Current policies are mostly directed at reducing employee voice and trade-union power, rather than promoting and strengthening it, in Europe and in the US. The reason is that, just as with democratising politics, instilling accountability, oversight and involvement means reducing the absolute power of the shareholder and the boss over companies. And, just as in politics, sharing power is never easy.
We need to enforce and strengthen existing structures of information and consultation in companies, we need to stimulate trade-union organising and we need to find effective avenues for democracy at work in large multinationals as well as in small companies. In all of these, we need to strengthen the power of ordinary workers to keep the company owners accountable for their actions, to increase democratic oversight of them and, in the end, to reduce the absolute freedom they currently enjoy.
In doing so, we just might all become a little more satisfied with our lives, as management will at least have the guts to talk to workers about their concerns. For democracy at work, when it comes to it, is indeed a matter of human dignity.
TwitterFacebookLinkedinE-mail
About Stan De Spiegelaere
Stan De Spiegelaere is a researcher at the European Trade Union Institute (ETUI).
Partner Ads
Our Most Recent Posts
industrial policy
Industrial policy: is there a paradigm shift in Germany and what does this imply for Europe?
Peter Bofinger
feminism
It’s time for feminism at the European elections
Carmen Calvo, Helena Dalli and Franziska Giffey
attractive utppia
The free market is not the answer
Jochen Steinhilber
‘Gendering’ the EU budget
Firat Cengiz
democracy at work
It’s time to talk about democracy at work
Stan De Spiegelaere
Most Popular Posts
output gap
Output gap nonsense
Adam Tooze
populists
Populism and the embrace of complexity
Sheri Berman
income tax
Why top rates of income tax should be much higher
Simon Wren-Lewis
Joseph Stiglitz - Beyond GDP
Beyond GDP
Joseph Stiglitz
external instability
Migration Into Europe: A Long-Term Solution?
Branko Milanovic
Other Social Europe Publications
Austerity: 12 Myths Exposed
The Crisis of Globalisation
The Legitimacy of the Brexit Referendum and What We Can Learn from It
Still time to save the euro
Brexit Generation Game: How Conflict Between Old and Young Masks Welfare Challenges
S&D Group Advertisement
A New Analytical Approach Towards Sustainable Development
Co-sponsored by the S&D through its Progressive Society Initiative, the Independent Annual Sustainable Economy Survey is an alternative vision of the Commission's Annual Growth Survey. In addition to its usual in-depth analyses of economic and social developments in Europe, the new iASES broadens its scope and addresses environmental sustainability. To this end, it provides the first ever evaluation of Europe's ‘climate debt’, i.e. a computation of the investments needed for EU Member States to achieve the climate targets set out in the COP 21 agreement.
FREE DOWNLOAD
ETUI Advertisement
‘Algorithm breakers’ are not a different ‘species’: attitudes towards trade unions of Deliveroo riders in Belgium
This working paper investigates a rare case of platform work performed in the realm of regulated employment and explores the attitudes of platform workers towards collective representation. Using a case study of Deliveroo, a food delivery platform, the paper argues that platform workers are not essentially different to their peers in their attitudes towards trade unions. The paper finds that the riders do not generally hold negative views towards unions, and do not consider unions incompatible with platform work. Instead, there has been a lack of union activity in reaching out to riders as a reason for their non-membership.
FREE DOWNLOAD
Eurofound Advertisement
Webinar: Flexible working in the digital age - Is everyone a winner?
On 13 June 2019 from 15.00 – 16.30 CET, Eurofound will host a webinar about its latest research findings on the growing number of ICT-based mobile workers, or workers who are not tied to a particular work location as they use a tablet, laptop or phone to connect the company network via Information and Communication Technologies (ICTs). By registering for this webinar, attendees will be able to take part in the live Q&A session and send in questions and reactions via the live chat.
CLICK FOR MORE INFO
Hans-Böckler-Stiftung Advertisement
Time for substantial minimum wage rises and a European minimum wage policy
Minimum wages in most European Union (EU) countries were increased at the start of 2019, with an median increase of 4.8 % compared with the previous year, continuing the recent trends towards faster minimum wage growth. Much of this is accounted for by substantial increases in Eastern Europe together with efforts to undertake permanent and structural increases in minimum wage levels in countries such as Spain. There is also a growing debate over the role of minimum wages for the concept of Social Europe, which is expected to play a significant role in the 2019 European Parliament elections. In this context, the German government has indicated that one of its priorities during its EU Council Presidency in the second half of 2020 will be elaborating a framework for a European minimum wage policy.
FREE DOWNLOAD
Social Europe Edition Book
Is an unconditional basic income without means-test or work-test compatible with social justice and individual self-worth? Does it open up the space for an end to demeaning labour and a resurgence of voluntary work and cultural life? Is it affordable? This collection of short but compelling essays, all previously published in Social Europe, allows both proponents and opponents to make their case and is designed to extend this vital discussion to a wider audience.
MORE INFO
Social Europe Edition Book
Zygmunt Bauman was a towering intellectual who saw and analysed – right up to his death in early 2017 – the great socio-political changes, often convulsive, in modern western society long before his peers. Here we highlight his prescient insights into what he dubbed ‘liquid modernity’ with 24 chapters on topics ranging from online loneliness via precarity/poverty/inequality to migration, fear of the ‘Other’ and the decline of the nation state. Chronicle of Crisis, 2011-16, written by one of the great chroniclers of our times, will be read and re-read for decades and more to come.
MORE INFO
About Social Europe
Mission Statement & Editorial Team
Article Submission
Social Europe ISSN 2628-7641
Legal & Privacy
Legal Disclosure
Privacy Policy
Copyright
Thought Leadership
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment