Saturday, 12 August 2017

New York Times: Facebook has found a stealthy way to evade China's Great Firewall: a local app that offers no hint it's tied to the social media giant

Technology

In China, Facebook Tests the Waters With a Stealth App

By PAUL MOZURAUG. 11, 2017
Continue reading the main story
Share This Page

Photo
Mark Zuckerberg, Facebook’s chief executive, jogging in Beijing’s Tiananmen Square last year. Credit Facebook, via Agence France-Presse — Getty Images

SHANGHAI — Facebook and many of its apps have been blocked in China for years. To change that, Mark Zuckerberg has made a big point of meeting with Chinese politicians, reading stodgy Communist Party propaganda, studying Mandarin and — perhaps more daunting — speaking it in public.

Now the social network is trying a different way into China: by authorizing the release of a new app there that does not carry the Facebook name.

Facebook approved the May debut of a photo-sharing app, called Colorful Balloons, in China, according to a person with knowledge of the company’s plans, who declined to be named because the information is politically sensitive. The app, which has not previously been reported, shares the look, function and feel of Facebook’s Moments app. It was released through a separate local company and without any hint that the social network is affiliated with it.

The stealthy and anonymous release of an app by a major foreign technology company in China is unprecedented. It shows the desperation — and frustration — of global tech companies as they try to break into the world’s largest online market. It also underscores the lengths they are willing to go, and their increasing acceptance of the idea that standards for operating in China are different from elsewhere.
Photo
The Colorful Balloons app (left) and Moments (right).
Photo
The Colorful Balloons app (left) and Moments (right).

China’s internet censorship — which includes making some news websites inaccessible and passing rules that result in app removals — has left big players like Facebook and Google on the sidelines of a major boom there. The country boasts an audience of more than 700 million internet users who buy $750 billion of stuff online a year, but they are served by local tech companies that have developed their own way of doing business that can seem exotic to Silicon Valley.
Continue reading the main story

Advertisement
Continue reading the main story

Facebook hopes it can learn and potentially assimilate those ways. Yet the social network was banned in China in 2009, followed by its photo-sharing app Instagram in 2014, and its messaging app WhatsApp was partially blocked last month. While the company has more than two billion users around the world, Mr. Zuckerberg, Facebook’s founder and chief executive, has often asked where its next billion users will come from.

Now Colorful Balloons gives the Silicon Valley company a way to see how Chinese users digitally share information with their friends or interact with their favorite social media platforms.

“We have long said that we are interested in China, and are spending time understanding and learning more about the country in different ways,” Facebook said in a statement.

It is unclear whether China’s various internet regulators were aware of the app’s existence. The under-the-table approach could cause Facebook new difficulties with a Chinese government that has maintained strict oversight and control over foreign tech companies.

“It’s not a mere business thing,” said Teng Bingsheng, a professor of strategic management at Cheung Kong Graduate School of Business. “It’s politics.”

The Cyberspace Administration of China did not respond to a faxed request for comment.

Before the release of Colorful Balloons, Facebook had taken an unusually high-profile approach to courting China.
Photo
Mark Zuckerberg meeting President Xi Jinping of China in 2015 with the country’s internet czar, Lu Wei, at the time. Credit Pool photo by Ted S. Warren

Mr. Zuckerberg had paid a series of visits to the country in recent years and become something of a celebrity there. Videos of him speaking Mandarin have gone viral, as did a photo of him jogging on a dangerously smoggy day through Tiananmen Square in Beijing.

Colorful Balloons represents the opposite approach — one that is low profile.

The app was released in China by a company called Youge Internet Technology, according to a post in Apple’s app store. It is registered to an address in eastern Beijing, yet the room number listed in company registration documents could not be found amid a series of shabby, small offices on the building’s fourth floor.
Newsletter Sign Up
Continue reading the main story
Interested in All Things Tech?

The daily Bits newsletter will keep you updated on the latest from Silicon Valley and the technology industry, plus exclusive analysis from our reporters and editors.
You agree to receive occasional updates and special offers for The New York Times's products and services.

    See Sample Manage Email Preferences Privacy Policy Opt out or contact us anytime

According to the documents, Youge’s executive director is a woman named Zhang Jingmei. She appeared in a photo of a recent meeting between Facebook and the Shanghai government, sitting next to Wang-Li Moser, a Facebook executive whose responsibilities include building up the company’s relationship with the Chinese government. Ms. Zhang’s presence at such a high-level meeting indicated she is likely a Facebook adviser or employee.

Facebook declined to comment on Ms. Zhang’s relationship to the company, and Ms. Zhang did not respond to phone calls requesting comment.

Advertisement
Continue reading the main story

If Facebook did little to promote Colorful Balloons in China, it did work to tailor the app to a local audience. In the rest of the world, the company’s Moments app connects users through Facebook. Colorful Balloons instead links users through China’s biggest social network, WeChat.

The app, which is designed to collate photos from a smartphone’s photo albums and then share them, does so in China with the use of a QR code, a sort of bar code that is widely used by WeChat and other apps in the country.

While photos can be shared, Facebook appears to have taken steps to ensure the app could not spread widely. For example, people who post photos from Colorful Balloons on WeChat will see a link that lets other users download Facebook’s Chinese app. But the link does not work, meaning people have to seek out Colorful Balloons in an app store instead of grabbing it from their friends, which may limit its distribution.

The risk Facebook is taking with the new app is high. The company appears to have handed over a fully functioning product to Youge for release, and has done so without indicating in any public way that it is connected to Facebook. Coming just ahead of a key meeting of the Chinese Communist Party this autumn, the secretive release of Colorful Balloons could also undermine trust between the company and the Chinese government.

Such tactics underline the degree to which Facebook is willing to experiment and break precedent to get into China. Last year, The New York Times reported Facebook had also quietly been at work on a censorship tool that could be used on a version of the social network in a place like China, where the government demands control over what is shared. The tool could suppress posts from appearing in people’s news feeds in specific geographic areas.
Photo
China’s former internet czar, Lu Wei, once visited Facebook’s Silicon Valley headquarters. Credit China Network

Yet even if Facebook is able to use Colorful Balloons to keep up with the Chinese market, a recent intense internet crackdown in China suggests the political winds may not soon blow in favor of the company further entering the country.

Mr. Zuckerberg’s attention to China also appears to have waned. And China’s former internet czar, Lu Wei, who had visited Facebook’s offices in 2014, has been removed from his position, making things harder for the company.

“The government’s control and surveillance of media is strict, and it is almost impossible for them to open that door,” said Mr. Teng, the Cheung Kong professor. “Although Mark Zuckerberg has visited China many times and practiced his Chinese very hard, I don’t foresee any major breakthroughs for Facebook.”

Carolyn Zhang contributed research from Shanghai. Zhang Tiantian contributed research from Beijing.

Follow Paul Mozur on Twitter @paulmozur.

A version of this article appears in print on August 12, 2017, on Page A1 of the New York edition with the headline: Facebook Uses A Stealth App To Enter China. Order Reprints| Today's Paper|Subscribe
Continue reading the main story
Related Coverage

    China Disrupts WhatsApp Service in Online Clampdown JULY 18, 2017
    Facebook Said to Create Censorship Tool to Get Back Into China NOV. 22, 2016
    Chinese Tech Firms Forced to Choose Market: Home or Everywhere Else AUG. 9, 2016

Trending

    How U.S. Military Actions Could Play Out in North Korea
    White Nationalists March on University of Virginia
    Op-Ed Columnist: Sundar Pichai Should Resign as Google’s C.E.O.
    ‘We’ve Had Enough’: Conservatives Relish the ‘Fury’ in Trump’s Talk
    Trump Says Military Is ‘Locked and Loaded’ and North Korea Will ‘Regret’ Threats
    Vows: She’s 98. He’s 94. They Met at the Gym.
    Uproar Over Omarosa Manigault-Newman at Black Journalists Convention
    Scott Pruitt Is Carrying Out His E.P.A. Agenda in Secret, Critics Say
    News Analysis: Combative Trump Pulls His Punches for One Man: Putin
    Op-Ed Columnist: Trump Tweets Tough

View More Trending Stories »
What's Next
Loading...

Go to Home Page »
Site Index The New York Times
Site Index Navigation
News

    World
    U.S.
    Politics
    N.Y.
    Business
    Tech
    Science
    Health
    Sports
    Education
    Obituaries
    Today's Paper
    Corrections

Opinion

    Today's Opinion
    Op-Ed Columnists
    Editorials
    Contributing Writers
    Op-Ed Contributors
    Opinionator
    Letters
    Sunday Review
    Taking Note
    Room for Debate
    Video: Opinion

Arts

    Today's Arts
    Art & Design
    Books
    Dance
    Movies
    Music
    N.Y.C. Events Guide
    Television
    Theater
    Video: Arts

Living

    Automobiles
    Crossword
    Food
    Education
    Fashion & Style
    Health
    Jobs
    Magazine
    N.Y.C. Events Guide
    Real Estate
    T Magazine
    Travel
    Weddings & Celebrations

Listings & More

    Reader Center
    Classifieds
    Tools & Services
    Times Topics
    N.Y.C. Events Guide
    Blogs
    Multimedia
    Photography
    Video
    NYT Store
    Times Journeys
    Subscribe
    Manage My Account
    NYTCo

    Subscribe Home Delivery Digital Subscriptions Crossword

    Email Newsletters Alerts Gift Subscriptions Corporate Subscriptions Education Rate

    Mobile Applications Replica Edition

Site Information Navigation

    © 2017 The New York Times Company
    Home
    Search
    Accessibility concerns? Email us at accessibility@nytimes.com. We would love to hear from you.
    Contact Us
    Work With Us
    Advertise
    Your Ad Choices
    Privacy
    Terms of Service
    Terms of Sale

Site Information Navigation

    Site Map
    Help
    Site Feedback
    Subscriptions

Post a Comment