Inside Climate News/Georgina Gustin: Toxic Algae Blooms Occurring More Often, May Be Caught in Climate Change Feedback Loop

Inside Climate News


Toxic Algae Blooms Occurring More Often, May Be Caught in Climate Change Feedback Loop

The blooms, primarily fed by farm runoff but exacerbated by warming, release methane and CO2. Lake Erie is a 'poster child' for the challenge.
Georgina Gustin

By Georgina Gustin
May 15, 2018
A satellite image captures algae blooms in Lake Erie in 2011. Toledo, Ohio, is at the southwestern tip of the lake. Credit: European Space Agency

A satellite image captures algae blooms in Lake Erie in 2011. Toledo, Ohio, is at the southwestern tip of the lake. Credit: European Space Agency

Blooms of harmful algae in the nation's waters appear to be occurring much more frequently than in the past, increasing suspicions that the warming climate may be exacerbating the problem.

The Environmental Working Group (EWG) published newly collected data on Tuesday reporting nearly 300 large blooms since 2010. Last year alone, 169 were reported. While NOAA issues forecasts for harmful algal blooms in certain areas, the advocacy group called its report the first attempt to track the blooms on a nationwide scale.

The study comes as scientists have predicted proliferation of these blooms as the climate changes, and amid increasing attention by the news media and local politicians to the worst cases.

Just as troubling, these blooms could not only worsen with climate change, but also contribute significantly to greenhouse gas emissions.

EWG based its study on news reports and before-and-after satellite images that show the expansion of the blooms. Though the rapid increase in the annual numbers might reflect more thorough observations and reporting in recent years, Craig Cox, who focuses on agriculture for EWG, said the numbers may still be on the low side.

In 2014, the news was especially urgent in Toledo, where a toxic algal bloom in Lake Erie forced health officials to declare the water unsafe for drinking and bathing. Harmful algae blooms had been common in the western part of Lake Erie from the 1960s through the 1980s, but they had diminished with better pollution controls—until about a decade ago, according to NOAA. 

Now the blooms—thick undulating mats of green—have become an annual occurrence there.
Farm Runoff and the Pushback on Solutions

The root cause of the problem lies mainly in agricultural runoff that contains phosphorus, which encourages algal growth.

At a recent conference, the mayor of Toledo pointed the blame for the continuing problem squarely at the Ohio Farm Bureau Federation, saying that lawmakers in the state were too intimidated by the group to support legislation to deal with the problem. "It's probably the most powerful interest group in Ohio," Mayor Wade Kapszukiewicz said in an interview.

Kapszukiewicz noted that the city spent billions of dollars upgrading its water treatment facility more than a decade ago and that there have been no sewage overflows into the lake since then, and yet the blooms are getting worse. "Toledoans are paying for a problem we didn't create," he said.

"Nutrient runoff" comes from sewage and other sources, but mostly from fertilizer and manure, which are especially high in phosphorus.
Algae blooms about 12 miles east of Toledo. Credit: NASA Glenn Research Center

Agricultural runoff and algae blooms in Lake Erie near a river outlet, about 12 miles east of Toledo. Credit: NASA Glenn Research Center

The agricultural industry in Ohio and elsewhere has long been aware of the problem. Joe Cornely, a spokesman for the Ohio Farm Bureau, said the bureau had been looking into it for years. But when it came to legislative and regulatory measures, Cornely said: "You've heard the old saying, 'You can have it fast or right.' We want it to be right."

Critics see that as foot-dragging from the industry. In March, after the administration of Ohio Gov. John Kasich proposed labeling fertilizer an agricultural pollutant, the Farm Bureau balked.

The proposal came after the Ohio Environmental Protection Agency declared, in a draft report that has not yet been finalized, that the open waters of western Lake Erie were impaired, a designation long sought by environmental groups. The impairment designation, the groups hope, will lead to a threshold—a "total maximum daily load," or TMDL—that sets a cap on overall phosphorus loading into the lake.

"We can use it to hold EPA's feet to the fire," said Madeline Fleisher, a senior attorney with the Environmental Law and Policy Center.
'Shooting Methane and CO2 into the Atmosphere'

Meanwhile, researchers have found evidence that algal blooms are not just consequences of climate change, but are also sources of climate-warming emissions.

In a study released in March, researchers affiliated with the University of Minnesota, Minnesota Sea Grant and the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency found that, globally, lakes and manmade "impoundments" like reservoirs emit about one-fifth the amount of greenhouse gases emitted by the burning of fossil fuels. The majority of that atmospheric effect comes from methane, an especially potent short-lived climate pollutant.

"We found that, as the lakes go greener, more eutrophic, the atmospheric effect of the lakes skyrockets," said John Downing, the paper's lead researcher and director of the Minnesota Sea Grant. "That's because plants are decomposing and shooting methane and CO2 into the atmosphere."

Downing and his colleagues also found that even small increases in harmful algal blooms could impact the atmosphere. "Basically a little increase [in algal blooms] could cause the greenhouse effect of lakes to increase 5 to 40 percent," Downing said.

Since the study was published, Downing and his colleagues have continued looking into changes in Lake Erie, which Downing called "one of the poster children for algal blooms." 

"The atmospheric impact of those gases coming out of Lake Erie right now is probably 18 times the atmospheric effects of all the cars in the city of Detroit," Downing said. 

"If we take Lake Erie and change it, and make it as green as the part around Toledo, then the carbon emissions from the lake increases two-and-a-half more times and the atmospheric impact is equivalent to adding another seven million cars on the road," he said.

"People are concerned that [algal blooms] stink and they hurt their pets," Downing said. "But there's another reason to not have your lakes ruined: They can change the climate in a significant way."
Published Under:
Agriculture
Climate Change

    Email this page

    Printer-friendly version

About the Author
Georgina Gustin

Georgina Gustin is a Washington-based reporter who has covered food policy, farming and the environment for more than a decade. She started her journalism career at The Day in New London, Conn., then moved to the St. Louis Post-Dispatch, where she launched the "food beat," covering agriculture, biotech giant Monsanto and the growing "good food" movement.  At CQ Roll Call, she covered food, farm and drug policy and the intersections between federal regulatory agencies and Congress.  Her work has also appeared in The New York Times, Washington Post and National Geographic's The Plate, among others.

Your donation powers our nonprofit newsroom.

Our stories. Your inbox. Every weekend.
Most Popular
A map of average temperatures in degrees Celsius on May 8, 2018, show a warm spot near freezing over the Arctic. Credit: Climate Reanalyzer/University of Maine
Arctic Heat Surges Again, and Studies Are Finding Climate Change Connections

By Sabrina Shankman
Key currents of the Atlantic ocean's overturning circulation. Credit: NASA
Scientists Say Ocean Circulation Is Slowing. Here’s Why You Should Care.

By Bob Berwyn
A layer of smog sits over Salt Lake City. Credit: Eltiempo10/CC-BY-SA-4.0
Scott Pruitt Plans to Radically Alter How Clean Air Standards Are Set

By Nicholas Kusnetz
Five of California's largest fire years have been since 2006. Credit: David McNew/Getty Images
In California, Climate Change Is an ‘Immediate and Escalating’ Threat

By Phil McKenna
Installers add solar panels to a home in San Rafael, California. Credit: Justin Sullivan/Getty Images
In a First, California Requires Solar Panels for New Homes. Will Other States Follow?

By Dan Gearino
Eric Schneiderman, shown here during a January press conference, announced his resignation as New York's attorney general on May 7 after allegations that he physically assaulted four women during relationships with them. Credit: Spencer Platt/Getty Images
What Does Eric Schneiderman's Resignation Mean for N.Y.'s Exxon Probe and Environment Lawsuits?

By David Hasemyer
A new study based on EPA documents and interviews found industry influence over the EPA today is stronger than it was during the early Reagan years. Credit: Justin Sullivan/Getty Images
Pruitt's EPA Is on the Verge of 'Regulatory Capture', Study Says

By Neela Banerjee
Rising Seas Are Flooding Virginia’s Naval Base, and There’s No Plan to Fix It

By Nicholas Kusnetz
Sea Surface Temperatures. Credit: NOAA
The Most Powerful Evidence Climate Scientists Have of Global Warming

By Sabrina Shankman and Paul Horn
Crescent Dunes Solar Energy Project. Credit: SolarReserve
24-Hour Solar Energy: Molten Salt Makes It Possible, and Prices Are Falling Fast

By Robert Dieterich

Learn more about ICN's environmental journalism institute

Our Sponsors
The North Face
View all sponsors
Follow

    facebook.com/insideclimatenews
    twitter.com/insideclimate

Related
Algae blooms in a canal during hot weather. Credit: Robert Ashworth/CC-BY-2.0
How Climate Change Will Worsen Algae and Dead Zones

By Bob Berwyn
Toxic algae blooms on the California coast have killed many animals.
Toxic Algae May Thrive as Climate and Oceans Warm, Study Says

By Bob Berwyn
Climate Change Drives Lakes Toward Ecological Tipping Points

By Bob Berwyn
Scientists conduct studies on the Greenland Ice Sheet. Credit: Joe Raedle/Getty Images
What's Eating Away at the Greenland Ice Sheet?

By Bob Berwyn

Subscribe to Clean Economy Weekly

Want More Stories Like This One?
Contribute To Our Staff
Donate Now
More Agriculture
Poultry industry chicken houses can hold tens of thousands of birds. Credit: U.S. Department of Agriculture
Giant Chicken Houses Overrun Delmarva, and Neighbors Fear It's Making Them Sick

By Georgina Gustin
A new study matched what people reported eating with the carbon footprint of those foods and then ranked them. Beef was a big part of the difference. Credit: Jeff Swensen/Getty Images
America’s Biggest Beef Eaters Responsible for Large Chunk of Climate Emissions

By Georgina Gustin
Volcanic plains tend to be fertile farmland. Credit: SounderBruce/CC-BY-SA-2.0
How Crushed Volcanic Rock in Farm Soil Could Help Slow Global Warming — and Boost Crops

By Georgina Gustin
More on Agriculture
Subscribe to InsideClimate News Email Newsletters

    Articles & Investigations
    Today's Climate
    Clean Economy
    Week in Review

Subscribe
More From The Author
A satellite image captures algae blooms in Lake Erie in 2011. Toledo, Ohio, is at the southwestern tip of the lake. Credit: European Space Agency
Toxic Algae Blooms Occurring More Often, May Be Caught in Climate Change Feedback Loop

By Georgina Gustin
A herder purchases a portable solar power kit in Mongolia. Credit: Stephan Bachenheimer
World Is Not on Track to Meet UN’s 2030 Sustainable Energy Goals

By Georgina Gustin
In 2008, a coal ash containment area broke at the TVA's Kingston Fossil Plant, and 5.4 million cubic yards of coal ash washed downstream toward the Emory River. Credit: Brian Stansberry/CC-BY-3.0
Don't Gut Coal Ash Rules, Communities Beg EPA at Hearing

By Georgina Gustin
More by Georgina Gustin

    Whistleblowers Jobs & Freelance Policies & Legal Our E-Books

Keep Environmental Journalism Alive
Donate Now

    News Investigations Topics Today's Climate Clean Economy Middle Ground Infographics