Inside Climate News/Sabrina Shankman: Kids Challenge Alaska’s Climate Paradox: The State Promotes Oil as Global Warming Wreaks Havoc

Inside Climate News
Home

Kids Challenge Alaska’s Climate Paradox: The State Promotes Oil as Global Warming Wreaks Havoc

The dangers of climate change are immediate and extreme here, yet most of Alaska's revenue comes from the expanding oil and gas industry.
Sabrina Shankman
By Sabrina Shankman
May 5, 2018

In coastal Alaska, communities count on winter sea ice to buffer the shore from damaging waves. The ice is disappearing and erosion is getting worse as the Arctic warms twice as fast the global average. Credit: Sabrina Shankman

In coastal Alaska, communities count on winter sea ice to buffer the shore from damaging waves, but the ice is disappearing and erosion is getting worse as the Arctic warms twice as fast as the global average. Credit: Sabrina Shankman

When Tasha Elizarde was a young girl, she would climb up a mountain a few miles outside her home in Juneau, Alaska, to a scenic overlook, where she could gaze at the Mendenhall Glacier.

But over the course of her childhood, the glacier began to vanish. From the time she was 8 until she turned 16, it receded about 1,800 feet. Now, standing at the same overlook, "we can't even see it anymore," she said.

Now 19 years old, Elizarde has joined 15 other young Alaskans who are suing the state of Alaska for causing climate change and failing to protect the climate for future generations. They are asking for a science-based energy policy—one that will shift to renewable energy sources and bring greenhouse gas emissions to zero by 2050.

These kids live in places where dangerous waves are eating away at the shorelines as the sea ice vanishes; where thawing permafrost is undermining roads; and where the ocean is acidifying and hurting the local seafood industry.

Sign up for InsideClimate News Weekly

Our stories. Your inbox. Every weekend.

The young plaintiffs in the case are being represented by the nonprofit Our Children's Trust, which is supporting similar cases in other states, as well as a federal case that will head to trial in October.

While the Alaska case mirrors the other lawsuits, it also represents a unique paradox: In Alaska, not only are the impacts of warming both immediate and extreme, but the state is also contributing to climate change through its continued production of oil and gas.

"When we're looking at the health of the state and the people of this state, it's important to recognize that what we're doing is not the right course," Elizarde said.
Alaska's Reliance on Oil Runs Deep

Oil represents the lifeblood of Alaska's economy. Revenue from oil and gas accounts for the lion's share of Alaska's budget, and since dividend payments for Alaska residents began in 1982, a family of four living there would have received $133,461.

As President Donald Trump has sought to increase fossil fuel exploration and production, Alaska Sen. Lisa Murkowski has pushed to successfully open the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge to oil drilling for the first time, and a oil leasing sale of record-breaking proportions was held in the National Petroleum Reserve-Alaska in late 2017.

Murkowski, like Alaska Gov. Bill Walker, embodies the Alaskan paradox: She accepts climate science and the role that fossil fuels play in exacerbating global warming. Yet she is pushing the state on a no-holds-barred pursuit of fossil fuel development.

Mendenhall Glacier time-lapse, 2007-2015. Credit: Extreme Ice Survey.

Earlier this week, the youth case went before Alaska Superior Court Judge Gregory Miller as the state sought to dismiss the lawsuit. One of the final arguments from the state's assistant attorney general was that "Alaska is not destroying the environment. Alaska is not causing climate change."

Andrew Welle, co-counsel for the young plaintiffs, begs to differ. "Alaska is by no means a small contributor to climate change," he said. As one of the largest oil and gas producing states in the country, it also has outsized greenhouse gas contributions.
Arctic Drilling Pollution Affects Warming Now

The impact that oil and gas production has on climate change has a lot to do with geography, and Alaska's Arctic location ups the ante. At the same time that carbon dioxide emissions are locking in future warming, the emissions of short-lived climate pollutants—especially black carbon—are exacerbating warming now.

When black carbon is emitted through gas flaring or the use of diesel generators or the burning of fuel for transportation, its impact is felt locally.

Black carbon—dark particulate matter—"always has its greatest impact closest to the source, and with all the snow and ice in and around Alaska, the black carbon impact is greatly magnified when it darkens that snow and ice, causing more to melt," said Pam Pearson, the director of the International Cryosphere Climate Initiative, a network of senior policy experts and researchers working to preserve the world's frozen places.

As the sea ice rapidly melts, the impacts are being felt around the world.
State Leaders: 'We Must Do Both'

In late March, Walker and Lt. Gov. Byron Mallott published an article in the Juneau Empire that acknowledged the difficulty of reconciling climate change's impact and an economy dependent on fossil fuel development.

"The question in front of us is not whether we can remain an oil and gas producing state or strengthen our commitment to addressing climate change — we must do both," they wrote. "The state will continue to be an energy producer for as long as there is a market for fossil fuels, and the revenue that comes from our resources will continue to spur economic growth and support essential public services."

Welle, the lawyer in the Our Children's Trust case, believes that their acknowledgment of the role that climate change plays and their seeming unwillingness to take aggressive action to deal with it helps his case.

"The dissonance that their statements reflects is more than adequate to show their knowledge of the dangers of climate change and their simultaneous commitment to promoting fossil fuel regardless of the consequences to these young plaintiffs," he said.
Freedom from Government Actions that Harm?

Welle and his co-counsel are arguing that the de-facto energy policy in Alaska is unfettered development of oil and gas resources, no matter the impact on the climate. They're arguing that this violates the state's constitution, which "recognizes and preserve the fundamental right of citizens to be free from government actions that harm life, liberty, and property without due process of law," according to court documents.

The case is now in the hands of the judge, who has six months to rule on whether to dismiss the case or allow it to continue to trial. A similar case in Washington state has been given a trial date, as has the federal case.

Elizarde, who will head to college in the fall, hopes the case raises awareness about how her state is being affected by climate change.

"We're talking about climate change and we're seeing all these impacts, but at the same time we're continuing to pursue activities that create climate change," she said. "I hope that this pushes the Walker administration and future administrations to look at this case and understand what a big problem climate change can be."
Published Under:
Arctic
Activism
Children's Climate Lawsuit
Short-Lived Climate Pollutants

    Email this page

    Printer-friendly version

About the Author
Sabrina Shankman
Sabrina Shankman

Sabrina Shankman is a reporter for InsideClimate News focusing on the Arctic. She joined ICN in the fall of 2013, after helping produce documentaries and interactives for the PBS show "Frontline" since 2010 with 2over10 Media. She is the author of the ICN book "Meltdown: Terror at the Top of the World," and was named a finalist for the Livingston Awards for Young Journalists for that work. Shankman has a Masters in Journalism from UC Berkeley's Graduate School of Journalism.
Our stories. Your inbox. Every weekend.
Most Popular
A new study based on EPA documents and interviews found industry influence over the EPA today is stronger than it was during the early Reagan years. Credit: Justin Sullivan/Getty Images
Pruitt's EPA Is on the Verge of 'Regulatory Capture', Study Says

By Neela Banerjee
Cleanup of the Enbridge pipeline Kalamazoo River oil spill in 2010. Credit: State of Michigan
Enbridge Fined for Failing to Fully Inspect Pipelines After Kalamazoo Oil Spill

By David Hasemyer
Pacifica California, in San Mateo County, by air. Credit: Philar/CC-BY-SA-2.0
In Cities v. Fossil Fuels, Exxon’s Allies Want the Accusers Investigated

By David Hasemyer
Storm-driven waves wash over man-made barriers on Roi-Namur island in 2014, showing the risk as sea level rises. Credit: U.S. Geological Survey
Climate Change Will Leave Many Pacific Islands Uninhabitable by Mid-Century, Study Says

By Nicholas Kusnetz
New York City plans to take its buses electric. Credit: Chris Hondros/Getty Images
New York City Aims for All-Electric Bus Fleet by 2040

By Phil McKenna
Chicago traffic. Credit: Rick Seidel/CC-BY-2.0
17 States Sue EPA Over Auto Emissions Standards Rollback

By Nicholas Kusnetz
UN climate negotiations in Bonn, May 2018. Credit: UN Climate Change
In Shadow of Trump's New Foreign Policy Team, U.S. Climate Negotiators Walk a Fine Line

By Marianne Lavelle
A herder purchases a portable solar power kit in Mongolia. Credit: Stephan Bachenheimer
World Is Not on Track to Meet UN’s 2030 Sustainable Energy Goals

By Georgina Gustin
Poultry industry chicken houses can hold tens of thousands of birds. Credit: U.S. Department of Agriculture
Giant Chicken Houses Overrun Delmarva, and Neighbors Fear It's Making Them Sick

By Georgina Gustin
Kansas farms and wind farms. Credit: Kansas State University Research and Extension
4 States Get Over 30 Percent of Power from Wind — and All Lean Republican

By Nicholas Kusnetz

Learn more about ICN's environmental journalism institute

Our Sponsors
View all sponsors
Follow

    facebook.com/insideclimatenews
    twitter.com/insideclimate

Related
Waves batter Little Diomede Island, where coastal communities are normally protected by ice through the winter. This year, the ice buffer melted early. Credit: Frances OzennaWaves batter Little Diomede Island, where the coastal community is normally prote
A Heat Wave Left Arctic Sea Ice Near a Record Winter Low. This Town Is Paying the Price.

By Sabrina Shankman
A UCLA research team takes measurements in Greenland, where soot has darkened the ice in some areas, contributing to melting. Credit: Mia Bennett/CryopoliticsSoot has darkened the ice in areas of the Greenland ice sheet, contributing to melting. Credit: M
These Climate Pollutants Don't Last Long, But They’re Wreaking Havoc on the Arctic

By Sabrina Shankman
Ringed seal. Credit: Kazuhiro Nogi/AFP/Getty Images
Court Sides with Arctic Seals Losing Their Sea Ice Habitat to Climate Change

By Sabrina Shankman
These eroding coastal bluffs in Alaska are thick with permafrost. Credit: U.S. Geological Survey
Thawing Arctic Permafrost Hides a Toxic Risk: Mercury, in Massive Amounts

By Sabrina Shankman
In Alaska's Thawing Permafrost, Humanity's 'Library Is on Fire'

By Sabrina Shankman

Subscribe to Clean Economy Weekly

Want More Stories Like This One?
Contribute To Our Staff
Donate Now
More Arctic
Scientists conduct studies on the Greenland Ice Sheet. Credit: Joe Raedle/Getty Images
What's Eating Away at the Greenland Ice Sheet?

By Bob Berwyn
Ships enter Russia's port of Sabetta on the Yamal Peninsula. Credit: Kirill Kudyavtsev/AFP/Getty Images
Shipping’s Heavy Fuel Oil Puts the Arctic at Risk. Could It Be Banned?

By Sabrina Shankman
The U.S.S. Connecticut breaks through the ice on the Beaufort Sea during a submarine exercise in March 2018. Credit: Mass Communication 2nd Class Micheal H. Lee/U.S. Navy
Arctic Drilling Lease Sale Proposed for 2019 in Beaufort Sea, Once Off-Limits

By Sabrina Shankman
More on Arctic
Subscribe to InsideClimate News Email Newsletters

    Articles & Investigations
    Today's Climate
    Clean Economy
    Week in Review

Subscribe
More From The Author
In coastal Alaska, communities count on winter sea ice to buffer the shore from damaging waves. The ice is disappearing and erosion is getting worse as the Arctic warms twice as fast the global average. Credit: Sabrina Shankman
Kids Challenge Alaska’s Climate Paradox: The State Promotes Oil as Global Warming Wreaks Havoc

By Sabrina Shankman
Tar sands production at Fort McMurray in Alberta. Credit: Mark Ralston/Getty Images
Canada Sets Methane Reduction Targets for Oil and Gas, but Alberta Has Its Own Plans

By Sabrina Shankman
Scott Pruitt, EPA administrator under President Trump, visits a coal mine. Credit: Justin Merriman/Getty Images
Pruitt Announces 'Secret Science' Rule Blocking Use of Crucial Health Research

By Sabrina Shankman
More by Sabrina Shankman

    Whistleblowers Jobs & Freelance Policies & Legal Our E-Books

Keep Environmental Journalism Alive
Donate Now

    News Investigations Topics Today's Climate Clean Economy Middle Ground Infographics