MIT Technology Review/James Ball:

MIT Technology Review

Ms. Tech; Logos: Facebook, twitter, google, youtube, snapchat, instagram

Connectivity
The UK’s online laws could be the future of the internet—and that’s got people worried
While they’re a welcome warning to big tech, some fear that if the implementation is botched they could easily lead to censorship.

    By James Ball April 8, 2019

Technology giants will be forced to have a “duty of care” for their users, if a proposal announced by the government on Monday becomes law.

The proposal—a “white paper,” in UK legal parlance, which is one of the first stages of a formal government policy—is, on the surface at least, sweeping in scope and is a serious shot across the bows for big tech companies. But it has also raised some serious concerns about how it will be implemented and the possible consequences it might have on citizens' free speech.

Aiming to tackle well-defined harms such as hate crime, stalking, and terrorist activity alongside issues such as trolling and disinformation, the UK government proposes combining work done across eight or more separate regulators into one.
Sign up for The Download
Your daily dose of what's up in emerging technology
Stay updated on MIT Technology Review initiatives and events?

    YesNo

This new "super-regulator" could have powers to fine technology companies according to their revenue, or even to block them. It could also be able to prosecute individual executives. The proposed body could be funded either by an industry levy or from the proceeds of any enforcement fines it imposed.

The proposals have raised interest among academics and observers, and alarm among privacy campaigners. The former note that while the document is scant on details despite being tens of thousands of words long, it sets out a clear direction in a way few countries have been willing to do.

But the latter fear that the way it is implemented could easily lead to censorship for users of social networks rather than curbing the excesses of the networks themselves. Such impressions were not helped when Home Secretary Sajid Javid endorsed the concept, at least, of pre-moderating content before it was published. “The government’s proposals would create state regulation of the speech of millions of British citizens,” says Jim Killock, executive director of digital privacy advocates, Open Rights Group.

According to Eric Kind, a surveillance consultant and lecturer, the UK proposals affirm a duty of care to users as “the central idea and rallying call under which a variety of policy options are sitting.” This would represent something significantly new for the technology companies.

The plans also shift the government view away from any idea that the technology industry is somehow stateless or ungovernable—judging instead, likely rightly, that the UK market is large and wealthy enough to give the industry a powerful interest in complying even with legislation they loathed.

Where the plans run aground, though, is in implementation. All the complexities are punted—either to later legislative stages, to the regulator, or to the technology giants themselves. There is little to no attempt to define “harms,” or to work out precise sanctions. Where the report attempts to be moderate—for example, saying a new regulator would have to be mindful of “innovation”—it doesn’t set out what that means.

For some, that vagueness is alarming. The UK already has some of the strongest laws in the world—via the Investigatory Powers Act—on accessing and surveilling internet users and gaining their data from suppliers.

Given the weakness of the UK government and Prime Minister Theresa May’s (likely) impending resignation, this white paper in its present form is unlikely to become law. But it could serve as a lodestone to regulators in the UK and elsewhere. The course it represents is likely to be embraced by whichever government succeeds this one.

For good or for ill, this could represent a new direction for the internet, at least in Europe. For the US, with its First Amendment, we can expect the story to go very differently.

Learn from the humans leading the way in Connectivity at EmTech Next. Register Today!
June 11-12, 2019
Cambridge, MA
Register now
Share

James Ball
Related Video

More videos

Connectivity
10 Breakthrough Technologies of 2019, curated by Bill Gates 17:18

Connectivity
Technology, Work, and Urban Ecosystems: How Should Cities and Regions Respond? 31:37

Connectivity
The Next Generation of 3-D Printing 20:25
More from Connectivity

What it means to be constantly connected with each other and vast sources of information.

    Online dating sites give us an intriguing look at how we meet people now

    More than 300 million people use online dating sites. We’re now beginning to get a look at how these complex networks work.

    by Emerging Technology from the arXiv
    This is the first ever photo of a black hole

    The scientists behind it spent a decade using a virtual telescope the size of Earth to create this historic image.

    by Erin Winick
    Crowdsourced reports could save lives when the next earthquake hits

    Combining app check-ins and tweets with traditional detection data could give rescue teams and residents a vital head start.

    by Charlotte Jee

More from Connectivity
From Our Advertisers

    In association with VMware
    Digital transformation sparks innovation in networking

    In association with Google
    For data-savvy marketers, there’s a new keyword: Intent

    In association with Google
    Machine learning teaches marketers to cultivate a growth mindset

    In association with Oracle and Intel
    Machine learning - driven analytics: Key to digital transformation

Want more award-winning journalism? Subscribe to Print + All Access Digital.

    Print + All Access Digital $79.95/year*

    The best of MIT Technology Review in print and online, plus unlimited access to our online archive, an ad-free web experience, discounts to MIT Technology Review events, and The Download delivered to your email in-box each weekday.
    Subscribe

       
    See details+

* Prices are for U.S. residents only

See international prices
The Download What's important in technology and innovation, delivered to you every day
Stay updated on MIT Technology Review initiatives and events?

    YesNo

Follow us
Twitter Facebook RSS
MIT Technology Review

The mission of MIT Technology Review is to bring about better-informed and more conscious decisions about technology through authoritative, influential, and trustworthy journalism.

Browse
International
Editions

    Company
    Your Account
    Customer Support
    More
    Policies

MIT Technology Review © 2019 v.|eiπ|
3/3
This is your last free article this month. Subscribe now for unlimited online access.