Tuesday, 2 April 2019
MIT Technology Review/Will Knight: Google employees are lining up to trash Google’s AI ethics council
MIT Technology Review
Google's AI council has proved controversial with some employees.
Getty Images/Leon Neal
Intelligent Machines
Google employees are lining up to trash Google’s AI ethics council
The independent council was meant to help Google’s public image, but the blowback shows just how fraught—and politicized—use of AI is becoming.
by Will Knight April 1, 2019
Almost a thousand Google staff, academic researchers, and other tech industry figures have signed a letter protesting the makeup of an independent council that Google created to guide the ethics of its AI projects.
The search giant announced the creation of the council last week at EmTech Digital, MIT Technology Review’s event in San Francisco. Known as the Advanced Technology External Advisory Council (ATEAC), it has eight members including economists, philosophers, policymakers, and technologists with expertise in issues like algorithmic bias. It is meant to hold four meetings a year, starting this month, and write reports designed to provide feedback on projects at the company that use artificial intelligence.
But two of those members proved controversial. One, Dyan Gibbens, is CEO of Trumbull, a company that develops autonomous systems for the defense industry—a contentious choice given that thousands of Google employees protested the company’s decision to supply the US Air Force with AI for drone imaging. The greatest outrage, though, has come over the inclusion of Kay Coles James, president of the Heritage Foundation, a think tank that opposes regulating carbon emissions, takes a hard line on immigration, and has argued against the protection of LGBTQ rights.
One member of the council, Alessandro Acquisti, a professor at Carnegie Mellon University who specializes in digital privacy issues, announced on March 30th that he wouldn't be taking up the role. “While I'm devoted to research grappling with key ethical issues of fairness, rights & inclusion in AI, I don't believe this is the right forum for me to engage in this important work," he tweeted.
The creation of ATEAC—and the inclusion of Gibbens and James—may in fact have been designed to appease Google’s right-wing critics. At roughly the same time the council was announced, Sundar Pichai, Google’s CEO, was meeting with President Donald Trump. Trump later tweeted: “He stated strongly that he is totally committed to the U.S. Military, not the Chinese Military. [We] also discussed political fairness and various things that Google can do for our Country. Meeting ended very well!”
But one Google employee involved with drafting the protest letter, who spoke on condition of anonymity, said that James is more than just a conservative voice on the council. “She is a reactionary who denies trans people exist, who endorses radically anti-immigrant positions, and endorses anti-climate-change, anti-science positions.”
Some noted AI algorithms can reinforce biases already seen in society; some have been shown to misidentify transgender people, for example. In that context, “the fact that [James] was included is pretty shocking,” the employee said. “These technologies are shaping our social institutions, our lives, and access to resources. When AI fails, it doesn’t fail for rich white men working at tech companies. It fails for exactly the populations that the Heritage Foundation’s policies are already aiming to harm.”
Messages posted to a Google internal communications platform criticized the appointment of James especially. According to one post, earlier reported by the Verge and confirmed by the employee, James “doesn’t deserve a Google-legitimized platform, and certainly doesn’t belong in any conversation about how Google tech should be applied to the world.”
As of 5:30 pm US Eastern time today the public letter, posted to Medium, had been signed by 855 Google employees and 143 other people, including a number of prominent academics. “Not only are James’ views counter to Google’s stated values,” the letter states, “but they are directly counter to the project of ensuring that the development and application of AI prioritizes justice over profit. Such a project should instead place representatives from vulnerable communities at the center of decision-making.”
Correction: An earlier version of this story said only seven Google employees had signed the letter on Medium.
Learn from the humans leading the way in intelligent machines at EmTech Next. Register Today!
June 11-12, 2019
Cambridge, MA
Register now
Share
Tagged
Google, artificial intelligence, ethical tech
Will Knight
Will Knight Senior Editor, AI
Will Knight is MIT Technology Review’s Senior Editor for Artificial Intelligence. He covers the latest advances in AI and related fields, including machine learning, automated driving, and robotics. Will joined MIT Technology Review in… More
Related Video
More videos
Intelligent Machines
Accelerating Discovery with Self-Driving Laboratories 27:00
Intelligent Machines
How to Develop Your Own AI Playbook 27:32
Intelligent Machines
AI Transforming the Developing World 20:56
More from Intelligent Machines
Artificial intelligence and robots are transforming how we work and live.
Deep learning has found two exoplanets that human astronomers missed
It turns out machines have some advantages in the search for planets around other stars.
by Emerging Technology from the arXiv
The Animal-AI Olympics is going to treat AI like it’s a lab rat
The $10,000 competition will test AI with challenges that were originally designed to test animal cognition—to see how close we are to machines that have common sense.
by Oscar Schwartz
If you’re thinking about embracing AI: just jump in
Andrew Ng had some stirring words of advice for any businesses that might be toying with the idea of introducing artificial intelligence into how they work.
by Karen Hao
More from Intelligent Machines
From Our Advertisers
In association with VMware
Digital transformation sparks innovation in networking
In association with Google
For data-savvy marketers, there’s a new keyword: Intent
In association with Google
Machine learning teaches marketers to cultivate a growth mindset
In association with Oracle and Intel
Machine learning - driven analytics: Key to digital transformation
Want more award-winning journalism? Subscribe to All Access Digital.
All Access Digital $35.95/year
The digital magazine, plus unlimited site access, our online archive, and The Download delivered to your email in-box each weekday.
Subscribe
See details+
* Prices are for U.S. residents only
See international prices
The Algorithm Artificial intelligence, demystified
Stay updated on MIT Technology Review initiatives and events?
YesNo
Follow us
Twitter Facebook RSS
MIT Technology Review
The mission of MIT Technology Review is to bring about better-informed and more conscious decisions about technology through authoritative, influential, and trustworthy journalism.
Browse
International
Editions
Company
Your Account
Customer Support
More
Policies
MIT Technology Review © 2019 v.|eiπ|
2/3
You've read two of three free articles this month. Subscribe now for unlimited online access.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment