Deutsche Welle/Matthias von Hein: Climate change: A catalyst for conflict

Deutsche Welle
TOP STORIES / World

World
Climate change: A catalyst for conflict

African ranchers seeking new pastures after traditional grazing lands have dried up are coming into conflict with farmers. In some areas, lands previously herded are being planted by farmers.
Niger Dürre Symbolbild (Getty Images/AFP/I. Sanogo)

In mid-October, people in the central Nigerian village of Nkyie Doghwro desperately sought shelter in a schoolhouse. Yet they did so in vain. Ultimately, 29 of them lost their lives; the victims of an ongoing conflict between ranchers and farmers in the region. Over the last 15 years more than 60,000 people have died in this forgotten conflict – almost four times as many as have been killed by the terror group Boko Haram.

Conflict between ranchers and farmers is a classic motif in Hollywood westerns. But conflict is also very much part of everyday life in many African nations – and the reality of it is far more brutal than that which is portrayed on the silver screen. Such conflict becomes unavoidable when ranchers seek new pastures after traditional grazing lands dry up, just as it does when climate change forces farmers to plant in areas where cattle had previously been herded. Such conflicts feature in this year's edition of the Stockholm International Peace Research Institute's (SIPRI) annual report.

Read more: Climate change burden unfairly borne by world's poorest countries
A dry landscape with a herd of cattle and a farmer walking in front of them.

Farmers in Nigeria are having increasing difficulty finding enough land to graze cattle

In an interview with DW, SIPRI director Dan Smith stressed the link between climate change and security: "The effects of climate change, alongside other social, economic and political components, contribute to the violence with which conflicts are resolved." 

In 2012, several agencies within the United States' intelligence community prepared a report that predicted: "Many countries that are of strategic importance to the USA will suffer water shortages or flooding over the next 10 years." The report added that such situations would increase the risk of instability or even lead to failed state status as well as contributing to regional conflict.

Climate change as a threat magnifier

That said, one cannot draw a direct connection between climate change and violent conflict, as the causes that lead to bloody conflict are often too complex to allow such mapping. Therefore, it is perhaps more helpful to think of climate change as a threat amplifier. That is how Rob van Riet of the World Future Council describes the relationship between climate and conflict. Van Riet expanded on that thought when speaking with DW: "Existing threats – like resource shortages, poverty, famine, terrorism or extreme ideology – are only amplified by climate change."

Read more: 'Climate change allows terrorists to thrive'
A Syrian neighborhood of flat-roofed houses that have been heavily bombed.

Water scarcity and food expense in Syria added to social chaos and fulled the conflict

SIPRI's Dan Smith also warns that the effects of climate change – from droughts to floods – are not simply local phenomena. He points out that extreme weather situations affect global food prices, and that those rising prices also fuel conflict. "Whenever global food prices go up we see demonstrations, rioting and ultimately lasting social and political instability in 30 or 40 countries at the same time," the SIPRI director observed.

When asked which regions most clearly illustrated that relationship, Smith pointed to North Africa and the Middle East: "Climate change can be clearly recognized within the complex mosaic of causes of conflict in Syria, Egypt and Yemen." Rob van Riet also sees Syria as a prime example of climate change as a driver of conflict. In the mid-2000s, large numbers of farmers were forced to give up their livelihood and move to already hopelessly overpopulated cities as a result of the worst droughts the country had ever seen. "Water became scarce and food expensive. The resulting suffering and social chaos added to ongoing conflicts that eventually spun out of control and ultimately led to the conflict that we are witnessing today," says the World Future Council climate expert.
A street scene in the Pakistan capital, Karachi, showing flooding and cars driving through water.

Flooding in Karachi, Pakistan

Rob van Riet is also gravely concerned about how nuclear powers like Pakistan will deal with the effects of climate change. He says that Pakistan is especially vulnerable, which can be seen in the massive flooding that takes place there annually. "Beyond the fact that such floods immediately deprive people of their livelihoods, they also have a direct influence on nuclear security," emphasized van Riet in a DW interview.

Fleeing from a changing environment
An aerial view of the Dadaab refugee camp on what looks like never-ending desert.

The Dadaab refugee camp in Kenya houses almost 250,000 people

It is clear that the economic effects of climate change are dramatic, and that social effects are as well. The Berlin-based Mercator Research Institute on Climate Change (MCC) is currently analyzing the scope of economic damages caused by climate change. Matthias Kalkuhl, who heads MCC's working group on economic growth and human change, is closely studying 1,400 regions around the world, and told DW: "On average, about 10 percent of a region's economic output – and up to 20 percent in tropical counties – is lost to sinking agricultural and labor productivity caused by climate change – those are substantial numbers!" And Kalkuhl did not factor damages from extreme weather catastrophes such as hurricanes or long-term issues such as rising sea levels into the equation.

Read more: Conflict as Lake Chad vanishes

When entire regions become impoverished it can lead to mass migration, which can, in turn, lead to increased tensions within a country or even beyond its borders. Speaking with DW, Kalkuhl points back to the discussions that accompanied the refugee debate in Germany, "roughly a million people arrived here within a relatively short period of time, throwing the political system into chaos. Therefore, it is very hard to predict how societies will cope with mass population movements."
A group of German right-wing extremists wearing black hoodies

Right-wing extremism in Germany has risen since the influx of refugees in 2015

So what can be done in light of the fact that in a best case scenario it will be decades before the effects of intelligent climate policy can be assessed – provided such measures are even enacted? SIPRI director Dan Smith thinks that an institution serving under the aegis of the United Nations is what is needed. The institution, he says, would be tasked with assessing security risks. It would then pass its findings on to other UN organizations such as the Security Council, the Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs or the World Food Program. "In one way or another, these organizations will all be affected by climate change related security risks over the next several years," says Smith.    
Watch video 00:52
Lobbying behind the scenes at UN climate talks?
DW recommends
Climate change burden unfairly borne by world's poorest countries

A flood of climate refugees could be imminent unless the richer nations do more to help poorer ones combat global warming, argues an IMF report. (28.09.2017) 
'Climate change allows terrorists to thrive'

A report commissioned by the German foreign office shows how in scenarios of instability and conflict, climate change can contribute to the emergence and growth of terrorist groups such as Boko Haram or "Islamic State." (20.04.2017) 
Conflict as Lake Chad vanishes

Experts say Lake Chad could disappear this century. With water and vegetation retreating fast, communities around the lake are coming under pressure – and into conflict. (23.12.2016) 
Audios and videos on the topic
Lobbying behind the scenes at UN climate talks? 

    Date 06.11.2017
    Author Matthias von Hein
    Related Subjects Climate Change, Drought, COP23
    Keywords Climate Change, conflict, floods, drought, upheaval
    Share Send Facebook Twitter Google+ More
    Feedback: Send us your feedback.
    Print Print this page
    Permalink http://p.dw.com/p/2n3wr

Related content
Erde Planet Mission NASA   
Climate change is happening — but it's not game-over yet 01.11.2017

Global warming isn't just an environmental problem — it will affect every aspect of human life. Our response has to be just a wide-reaching — and experts say people power can still save the planet.
Extreme weather – strength and frequency on the rise 06.11.2017

2017 has been a year marked by severe hurricanes, storms and drought. The extreme weather events have affected North America, South Asia, East Africa and also Europe. Scientists are warning that some of them are linked to climate change.
Äthiopien Norwegian Refugee Coucil NRC Dorf Asubuli   
Is the world prepared for climate refugees? 03.11.2017

Senior US military experts say the effects of climate change could cause a migration wave of 20 million climate refugees over the next 20 years. But climate risk insurance schemes could prevent it.

    Date 06.11.2017
    Author Matthias von Hein
    Related Subjects Climate Change, Drought, COP23
    Keywords Climate Change, conflict, floods, drought, upheaval
    Share Send Facebook Twitter Google+ More
    Send us your feedback.
    Print Print this page
    Permalink http://p.dw.com/p/2n3wr

Top stories in 90 seconds

DW News presents the most important news — in brief, quickly and up-to-date.

    TOP STORIES
    Germany
    World
    Business
    Science
    Environment
    Culture
    Sports
    
    A - Z Index

    MEDIA CENTER
    Live TV
    All media content
    Latest Programs
    Podcasts

    TV
    Schedule and Reception
    TV Programs
    
    RADIO

    LEARN GERMAN
    German Courses
    German XXL
    Community D
    Teaching German

    ABOUT DW
    Who we are
    Press
    Business & Sales
    Advertising
    Travel

    SERVICE
    Reception
    Mobile
    Smart TV
    Newsletters & Co.
    FAQ
    Contact
    
    DW AKADEMIE
    About us
    Media Development
    Master's Degree
    Traineeship
    Training

© 2017 Deutsche Welle | Privacy Policy | Legal notice | Contact | Mobile version
×
DW
Deutsche WelleFREE - In Google Play
VIEW