Hivos International/Carol Gribnau: We must be very cautious about using Genetically Modified Organisms

Hivos International

We must be very cautious about using Genetically Modified Organisms
Op/Ed | Carol Gribnau | February 12, 2018 |
Sustainable Food

We invest in a world where entrepreneurial local people are developing new solutions for some of the most challenging problems of our time. There are many other options for sustainably increasing food production and improving the livelihoods of smallholder farmers that we should look at first before considering investing in GM technology.

While acknowledging the lack of international consensus on the risks and benefits of using genetic modification (GM) technology, Hivos has strong reasons to be very cautious about the use and promotion of genetically modified crops.

The fact that biotechnology plays a major role in contributing to sustainable development makes the production of genetically modified organisms (GMOs) even more controversial. As we monitor the scientific debate around the application of GM technology, Hivos focusses closely on the socio-economic, cultural and environmental contexts surrounding the sustainable production of food.
Support for smallholder farmers worldwide is crucial

It is crucial that we support the 500 million smallholder farmers worldwide if our global food system is to become more sustainable and deliver healthy and affordable food for a growing population without degrading the environment. Smallholders not only produce over 70 percent of globally available food, they also play a key role in conserving traditional plant and crop varieties, maintaining agrobiodiversity and contributing to resilient food production systems. This is why investments to improve smallholder farming infrastructure, access to finance and access to markets are urgently needed.

The currently dominant global food production system promotes a development model of export-oriented, commodity-driven, large-scale industrial agriculture. Most agricultural research and investments – including related to GMOs - are therefore geared towards medium and large-scale enterprises, and their financial and technology needs, instead of smallholder farmers and their needs. Even though we recognise the benefits this development model brings in terms of productivity gains, we’re extremely worried about its other less beneficial consequences: the decline of agrobiodiversity, soil fertility and smallholder agriculture.

Photo: open source seed bank near Hyderabad, India - by Altaf Qadri
Our best bet is diversity in food and food production

Now that the world and the climate are increasingly more volatile – from weather conditions to markets – we strongly believe that our best bet is to enhance the diversity of the food we produce and how we produce it. This will create greater resilience and sustainability in agricultural production systems. In most cases, technological solutions like genetic modification solely favour and attract large-scale agribusinesses, especially because of their proprietary ownership. A single focus on technological solutions such as GM ignores the broader and much more important problem of chronic underinvestment in and marginalisation of smallholder agriculture.
Priority must be given to proven, non-GM tech options

Before considering investing in GM technology in developing countries, priority must be given to options that have proven to increase the productive capacity of smallholder agriculture, reduce environmental impacts and provide economic opportunities for the many instead of the few. What are some of these options?

    Investment in producing and improving locally adapted seeds and (open pollinated) varieties through community seeds banks
    Use of manure and compost to ecologically fertilise soil (or artificial fertiliser in some contexts)
    Nutrient recycling
    Efficient water management
    Diverse planting strategies and other natural forms of pest and disease control
    Promotion of open source seeds systems that favour local seed production and distribution, guaranteeing open access to genetic material for third party breeders.

Photo: open source seed bank near Hyderabad, India - by Altaf Qadri
Make optimal use of locally available natural and human resources

All these methods provide great alternatives to heavy reliance on costly and environmentally unfriendly inorganic fertilisers and pesticides, and farm machinery or other mechanical processes. Smallholders using the options above make optimal use of locally available natural and human resources - such as soil, water, vegetation, local plants and animals, and human labour, knowledge and skills. They typically produce multiple crop varieties on farms that are ecologically resilient and can cope with drought and climate change, resulting in sustainable livelihoods for the farmers.

These agroecological practices are not only proven ways to improve nutrition and avoid economic losses for smallholder farmers, but are also safe – for farmers, consumers and the planet.
Tags:
Biodiversity
Mono-cropping
Open Source Seeds Systems
Productive Landscapes
Print HTML logo LinkedIn logo Twitter logo Facebook logo
Carol Gribnau
Contact our Green Society Programme Director
Carol Gribnau
Contact by e-mail
+ 31(0)70 376 5500
Related content
No need for GMOs: Uganda’s rich biodiversity already provides solutions to the country’s food problems
Anne Majani
East Africa Programme Officer for Green Foods and Productive Landscape
Anne Majani
Contact by e-mail
+254 725 451 729
Menu

    Home
    What we do
    How we work
    Where we work
    Our Network
    About Hivos

What we do
Sustainable Food
Renewable Energy
Transparency & Accountability
Freedom of Expression
Sexual Rights and Diversity
Women’s Empowerment
Stay connected

    Hivos Global Newsletter
    Facebook
    Twitter
    RSS feed

Global Office
Visiting address

Raamweg 16
2596 HL  The Hague
The Netherlands
T +31 (0)70 376 55 00
F +31 (0)70 362 46 00
E info@hivos.org
Twitter: @hivos
Postal address

P.O. Box 85565
2508 CG  The Hague
The Netherlands
Top

    Alliance2015 Creative Commons

Unless otherwise indicated, the content on this site is available under a
Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License

    Disclaimer