The Conversation/Alain Naef: Argentina, Turkey, Indonesia – why it’s too early to speak of contagion in emerging markets

The Conversation

Edition:

Available editions
Africa

    Job Board

    Become an author
    Sign up as a reader
    Sign in

The Conversation
Academic rigour, journalistic flair

    Arts + Culture
    Business + Economy
    Education
    Environment + Energy
    Health + Medicine
    Politics + Society
    Science + Technology
    In French

Argentina, Turkey, Indonesia – why it’s too early to speak of contagion in emerging markets
September 11, 2018 2.44pm SAST
Author

    Alain Naef

    PhD Candidate in Financial History and Teaching Fellow in the Economics Faculty, University of Cambridge

Disclosure statement

Alain Naef is funded by the Economic and Social Research Council (ESRC).
Partners

University of Cambridge

University of Cambridge provides funding as a member of The Conversation UK.

The Conversation is funded by the National Research Foundation, eight universities, including the Cape Peninsula University of Technology, Rhodes University, Stellenbosch University and the Universities of Cape Town, Johannesburg, Kwa-Zulu Natal, Pretoria, and South Africa. It is hosted by the Universities of the Witwatersrand and Western Cape, the African Population and Health Research Centre and the Nigerian Academy of Science. The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation is a Strategic Partner. more
Republish this article

Republish
Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under Creative Commons licence.
The value of Argentina’s peso has plummeted in recent months. SC Image / Shutterstock.com

    Email
    Twitter2
    Facebook7
    LinkedIn
    Print

Turkey, Indonesia and Argentina have all seen their currencies experience huge drops in recent months. Similarly, stocks in India, South Africa, Mexico and others have taken a hit.

Emerging markets across the board have been under pressure since the US Federal Reserve raised interest rates in June. Governments and companies had borrowed in dollars when interest rates were low and the dollar was weak. Now the dollar is strong and interest rates are rising. And research by economists Michael Bordo, Chris Meissner and David Stuckler has shown that countries with higher foreign currency debt are more likely to experience currency and debt crises, especially in countries with lower policy credibility.

Some fear a repeat of the 1997 Asian financial crisis when contagion spread from the Thai baht to other South-East Asian currencies, resulting in a large regional economic crisis. But contagion this time round is unlikely.

The 1997 Asian financial crisis has changed the way economists approach currency crises. Before, they mainly believed that a run on a currency would occur only when a country was running a balance of payment deficit and the central bank did not have sufficient reserves to defend the currency. Following the Asian crisis, current IMF chief economist Maurice Obstfeld was among the first economists to show that currency crises can be a self-fulfilling prophecy, as happened in 1997. If investors start to have a pessimistic outlook on emerging markets currencies, it can lead to runs on currencies with no unhealthy economic fundamental or no misguided government policies.

This is not what is happening now. Argentina shows weak fundamentals and the government is struggling to finance its budget for the upcoming years. Turkey’s central bank is under attack from its president, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan, and needs to prove its independence to investors. But these are isolated situations and it is unlikely we will see global contagion.

The Fed recently issued a note explaining that the global crisis risk associated with emerging market currencies. According to the note, the risk of contagion among emerging currencies is low as only a limited number of countries present a risk, and their importance relative to the global economy is small. They based their reasoning on a study by Harvard economist Laura Alfaro and colleagues that demonstrated that emerging markets after the global financial crisis are less at risk than the five Asian crisis countries before 1997.
Markets are wary of Turkish president, Recep Tayyip Erdoğan’s increasing control over the economy. EPA-EFE/STR
Different approaches

The Argentinian case is interesting, however, because the current government has been the poster child of orthodox economic policies. If the economy were to fall further, it would show that even by following most IMF recommendations, growth is not achievable. This would open the door to a more populist backlash or the return of Peronist opposition in the upcoming 2019 general election.

But all is not lost. The US$50 billion that the IMF offered Argentina is a significant amount compared to the size of the currency market in Argentina, which the Bank for International Settlements estimates to be roughly US$1 billion a day. This means that the central bank will have room for manoeuvre as long as Argentina’s president, Mauricio Macri, refrains from any missteps, such as when he announced his desire for help from the IMF via YouTube. The move reflected the president’s willingness to get his country on board to talk again to the IMF, an institution that is closely linked to the bankruptcy of the country in the early 2000s. But markets felt less reassured by his comments.

Turkey, meanwhile, has implemented measures to try to stop the fall in the lira and to make it more difficult for speculators to bet against or “short” the lira. This has had some effect without solving the crisis. The real issue remains whether the central bank will be able to remain independent of Erdoğan, as economist Barry Eichengreen recently argued. The Turkish president’s disdain for central bank independence shows how different Turkey’s situation is from Argentina’s.

It is too easy to lump together all emerging markets. But, although contagion is not yet on the agenda, this does not mean that all is fine. A recession in the US is overdue after over nine years since the last official recession, and this would have a more serious effect on the global economy by putting pressure on exports from emerging markets. This would be likely to lead to more currency crisis. But until then, contagion should be limited.

    US Federal Reserve
    Interest rates
    Emerging markets
    Argentina
    Turkey
    Asian Financial crisis
    Currency crisis
    central banks
    US dollar

    Tweet
    Share
    Get newsletter

You might also like
Turkey’s homemade currency crisis has truly global implications
What low interest rates have done for the world – and the likely effects of a rise
Turkey’s lira crisis: ‘economic war’ sees Erdoğan look east for new allies
Explainer: why some current account imbalances are fine but others are catastrophic
Sign in to comment
1 Comment
Oldest Newest

    Patrick Newman
    Patrick Newman is a Friend of The Conversation

    No surprise that IMF measures have not worked for Argentina and indeed they do not work generally other than pleasing accountants. The loan conditions tend to harm the long term development of emerging economies. These countries in the article are small players in comparison to G7 India and China so for those waiting for the next recession you need to look at the big boys. Things are not the same as 2007/8 but that does not guarantee no recession for the foreseeable future and a major potential trigger is Trump and the developing trade war with a secondary vulnerability in the form of Brexit. One very clear difference is the sovereign debt position which is far worse in relation to GDP than 2007 making difficulties if recession bites and deficits increase. Private debt is also not in a good position and it is not difficult to see how quickly the US and UK (plus some of the EU) would rapidly descend into a recession. Give it no more than two years!
    5 hours ago
    Report

Most popular on The Conversation

    Namibian genocide victims’ remains are home. But Germany still has work to do
    How new Silk Road will cement China as major trading partner for Africa
    Xenophobia in South Africa: why it’s time to unsettle narratives about migrants
    Why Abiy won’t succeed unless he listens to Ethiopia’s majority – its rural people
    South Africa’s in a recession. Here’s what that means

    New technology tells us which animal bones were used to make ancient tools
    How the humanities can deliver for the fourth industrial revolution
    The fate of unique species in Tanzania’s coastal forests hangs in the balance
    Research-intensive universities in Africa? A model of how to build them
    South Africa is paying a heavy price for dysfunctional local government

Expert Database

    Find experts with knowledge in:*

Want to write?

Write an article and join a growing community of more than 72,400 academics and researchers from 2,511 institutions.

Register now
The Conversation
Community

    Community standards
    Republishing guidelines
    Research and Expert Database
    Analytics
    Job Board
    Our feeds

Company

    Who we are
    Our charter
    Our team
    Partners and funders
    Contributing institutions
    Resource for media
    Contact us

Stay informed and subscribe to our free daily newsletter and get the latest analysis and commentary directly in your inbox.
Email address
Follow us on social media

Privacy policy Terms and conditions Corrections

Copyright © 2010–2018, The Conversation Africa, Inc.