The Conversation/Jennifer Fitchett: Why the Indian Ocean is spawning strong and deadly tropical cyclones

The Conversation

    Edition:

Available editions
Africa

    Job Board

    Become an author
    Sign up as a reader
    Sign in

The Conversation
Academic rigour, journalistic flair

    Arts + Culture
    Business + Economy
    Education
    Environment + Energy
    Health + Medicine
    Politics + Society
    Science + Technology
    In French

Why the Indian Ocean is spawning strong and deadly tropical cyclones
May 8, 2019 3.02pm SAST
Author

    Jennifer Fitchett

    Senior Lecturer in Physical Geography, University of the Witwatersrand

Disclosure statement

Jennifer Fitchett receives funding from the DST-NRF Centre of Excellence for Palaeoscience.
Partners

University of the Witwatersrand

University of the Witwatersrand provides support as a hosting partner of The Conversation AFRICA.

The Conversation is funded by the National Research Foundation, eight universities, including the Cape Peninsula University of Technology, Rhodes University, Stellenbosch University and the Universities of Cape Town, Johannesburg, Kwa-Zulu Natal, Pretoria, and South Africa. It is hosted by the Universities of the Witwatersrand and Western Cape, the African Population and Health Research Centre and the Nigerian Academy of Science. The Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation is a Strategic Partner. more
Republish this article

Republish
Republish our articles for free, online or in print, under Creative Commons licence.
An aerial view of the damage from flood waters after tropical cyclone Idai made landfall in Mozambique’s Sofala province. EPA/ Emidio Jozine

    Email
    Twitter6
    Facebook34
    LinkedIn
    Print

The Indian Ocean has made its mark on the global news cycle this year. In March, tropical cyclone Idai made headlines as one of the most severe storms to have made landfall in Mozambique. Current estimates indicate that more than 1,000 people died. This makes it the most deadly tropical cyclone ever to have made landfall on the southern African subcontinent.

Until Idai, tropical cyclone Eline, which struck in 2000, was the most devastating tropical cyclone to make landfall in Mozambique.

After Idai, Eline was the strongest – though not the deadliest – cyclone to have hit the southern east African cost. This ranking as the strongest was soon after challenged by tropical cyclone Kenneth, a category 4 tropical cyclone that made landfall over the border of Mozambique and Tanzania six weeks after Idai.

Kenneth, in many regards, took the region by surprise. The storm was the northernmost tropical cyclone to make landfall on Mozambique, and the first to make landfall on Tanzania. It occurred very late in the season. Most cyclones in the region occur from January to March. It was also unusual for the Mozambique Channel to experience two severe tropical cyclones that made landfall within one season.

The third major cyclone to emerge out of the Indian Ocean came a few weeks after Kenneth, when cyclone Fani, a tropical cyclone on the border of Category 5 intensity wind speeds, hit the east coast of India. Category 5 tropical cyclones were only first recorded in the North Indian Ocean from 1989 so, again, this storm is unusually severe in the context of the longer historical records.

These high intensity storms have been tied to the very warm sea surface temperatures in the Indian Ocean. Temperatures of 30°C are occurring more often and over longer periods of time. This is a result of gradual warming on a global scale, which has resulted in a net increase in ocean temperatures.

Warmer ocean temperatures allow stronger storms to form. These conditions are exacerbated by global forcing mechanisms including El Niño and the Indian Ocean Dipole, which concentrates warm ocean waters in smaller geographic areas.

High intensity storms have been a frequent feature along the coast of the US throughout recorded history. Their increased frequency in the Indian Ocean should be raising alarm bells because countries like the US are much better equipped to help people prepare ahead of time, and to handle the fallout.
Measuring intensity

Tropical cyclone intensity is classified according to the Saffir Simpson scale. Categories are measured on the basis of the sustained wind speed and the storm’s central pressure. Each category is accompanied by estimates of the likely severity of damage and possible storm surge height.

Tropical cyclones form and intensify due to a combination of seven primary climatological conditions. Among other things, these include warm sea surface temperatures, high humidity levels and atmospheric instability.

For a storm to intensify, these conditions have to be maximised while the storm remains over the ocean.

Tropical cyclones require a sea surface temperature of 26.5°C to form, while the highest intensity storms require much warmer sea surface temperatures of 28-29°C. This is important because it’s one of the reasons why southern Africa is experiencing more intense tropical cyclones.

The South Indian Ocean is warming rapidly. This means that regions that previously experienced the temperatures of 26.5°C that facilitated tropical cyclone formation are now experiencing temperatures as warm as 30-32°C.

Simultaneously, regions further from the equator which didn’t previously have sufficiently warm water for tropical cyclone formation, with sea surface temperatures of 24-26°C are more regularly experiencing the threshold temperature. This increases the range in which these storms occur, making storms like tropical cyclone Dineo, which made landfall in February 2017 in southern Mozambique, more common.

These very warm sea surface temperatures are not a factor of global scale warming alone. They’re further influenced by a range of global and local forcing mechanisms. These include El Niño Southern Oscillation, the Indian Ocean Dipole and the Southern Annular Mode. For this particular cyclone season, scientists are seeing the strongest impact from the [Madden-Julian Oscillation].

This is a band of moisture in the tropical regions which moves eastward over a 30 to 90 day period. The strong Madden-Julian Oscillation is also affecting tropical cyclones in Australia.
Comparing storms

Ranking storms on the basis of their Saffir Simpson classification is not always the most valuable measure. That’s because it can’t take the characteristics of the location of landfall into consideration.

This results in two key shortcomings. First, it doesn’t take the flooding potential into account. This is difficult to identify for a particular storm, because it’s not only a function of how much rain is experienced and over what period – or even the height of storm surge – but also the nature of the region of landfall.

Lower-lying, relatively flat areas are more prone to flooding than higher elevation regions or those with rugged topography. This is part of the reason that Idai caused such severe flooding. Some regions will have better suited storm water infrastructure. And when flooding does occur, some regions are better able to warn and evacuate people to prevent or minimise the loss of life.

Another factor which determines the devastation resulting from a tropical cyclone is the population density of the area of landfall. The higher the population density, the more people who are at threat of losing their life, their homes and livelihoods.

This also means more people who would need to be evacuated in a short period, and more people who need shelter until the storm’s immediate effects have subsided. This is why Idai and Eline resulted in far greater losses and fatalities than the stronger intensity Kenneth, and why the total damage from Fani is projected to be particularly devastating. We need to start measuring storm destructiveness in addition to climatological metrics.

    Flood defences
    Indian Ocean
    Southern Africa
    Mozambique
    Sea temperature
    Global Perspectives
    Tropical cyclone Idai

    Tweet
    Share
    Get newsletter

You might also like
Why NGOs in Africa must respect village headmen and hierarchies
Wildebeest migrations in East Africa face extinction. What must be done
Trump’s one-on-one approach to China has dangerous implications for global trade and world peace
We’re developing the world’s first vaccine suitable for humans and livestock
Sign in to comment
2 Comments
Oldest Newest

    Nicolas Cook

    It would have been interesting to see worked into this discussion some of the weather dynamics discussed in the author’s 2014 article with Stefan W. Grab, “A 66-year tropical cyclone record for south-east Africa: temporal trends in a global context.”

    That article noted that some research from other regions has indicated that increases in cyclone strength linked to warming ocean surface temperatures can be “mitigated by an increase in vertical wind shear associated with sea surface warming.” Elsewhere, it noted that “whilst sea surface temperature determines the maximum potential intensity of a tropical cyclone, a strong vertical shear (difference in magnitude and direction between lower and upper tropospheric winds) prevents the formation of tropical cyclones, as it inhibits the development of strong cyclonic circulation.”  In short, it spoke to the complexity of the interplay in cyclone dynamics of both weather and the climate change factors that many observers believe are affecting the Indian Ocean region.

    Given the frequent references to climate change as a key factor explaining recent Indian Ocean cyclone strength and intensity that have appeared in the press since Cyclone Idai, it would also have been useful to summarize some of the points discussed in the 2014 article regarding how those factors might both spur and moderate cyclone frequency and intensity. It might also have been useful to stress, as did the 2014 piece, how challenging it is likely to be to determine definitively whether and to what extent climate change factors might be at play in the dynamics of cyclones in the region.

    The 2014 article in question is freely available to readers; see below.

    Ref: A 66-year tropical cyclone record for southeast Africa: temporal trends in a global contextINTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF CLIMATOLOGYhttps://doi.org/10.1002/joc.3932
    Read more
    11 hours ago
    Report
        Jennifer Fitchett

        Senior Lecturer in Physical Geography, University of the Witwatersrand
        In reply to Nicolas Cook

        Yes indeed. Unfortunately not possible to get into all dynamics in a short piece, and the focus here is on why these storms were so strong (as opposed to why some potential storms aren’t occurring). Not at all an attempt to underplay the complexity of the impact of a warming climate on storm formation and intensity.

        I do also speak to the role of vertical shear in my most recent academic paper on high intensity storms, which is linked above, but can also be found here: http://www.scielo.org.za/scielo.php?script=sci_arttext&pid=S0038-23532018000600018.

        I do speak a lot to vertical shear more broadly. Eg a recent interview with the BBC: https://www.bbc.co.uk/sounds/play/w3csym1m
        3 hours ago
        Report

Most popular on The Conversation

    Breast ironing: a harmful practice that doesn’t get sufficient attention
    We asked people in Vietnam why they use rhino horn. Here’s what they said
    Why South Africa should seriously consider taxing its wealthy citizens
    Ethical questions around returning Dadaab refugees “home”
    South Africa’s black middle class is battling to find a political home

    Wildebeest migrations in East Africa face extinction. What must be done
    South Africa’s poll is more about battles in the ANC than between political parties
    Race still colours South Africa’s politics 25 years after apartheid’s end
    South Africa’s main parties all have plans for education. What’s missing?
    How we are developing immunotherapies relevant to Africa

Expert Database

    Find experts with knowledge in:*

Want to write?

Write an article and join a growing community of more than 83,700 academics and researchers from 2,838 institutions.

Register now
The Conversation
Community

    Community standards
    Republishing guidelines
    Research and Expert Database
    Analytics
    Job Board
    Our feeds

Company

    Who we are
    Our charter
    Our team
    Partners and funders
    Resource for media
    Contact us

Stay informed and subscribe to our free daily newsletter and get the latest analysis and commentary directly in your inbox.
Email address
Follow us on social media

Privacy policy Terms and conditions Corrections

Copyright © 2010–2019, The Conversation Africa, Inc.