Inside Climate News/Sabrina Shankman: Premature Birth Rates Drop in California After Coal and Oil Plants Shut Down

Inside Climate News

Premature Birth Rates Drop in California After Coal and Oil Plants Shut Down

Within a year of eight coal- and oil-fired power plant retirements, the rate of preterm births in mothers living close by dropped, finds new study on air pollution.
Sabrina Shankman
By Sabrina Shankman
Follow @shankman
May 22, 2018
Air Pollution From Coal Plants Tied to Premature Births

New study adds fresh evidence to a robust body of research on the harmful effects of exposure to air pollution, especially in young children. Credit: SAUL LOEB/AFP/Getty Images

Shutting down power plants that burn fossil fuels can almost immediately reduce the risk of premature birth in pregnant women living nearby, according to research published Tuesday.

Researchers scrutinized records of more than 57,000 births by mothers who lived close to eight coal- and oil-fired plants across California in the year before the facilities were shut down, and in the year after, when the air was cleaner.

The study, published in the American Journal of Epidemiology, found that the rate of premature births dropped from 7 to 5.1 percent after the plants were shuttered, between 2001 and 2011. The most significant declines came among African American and Asian women. Preterm birth can be associated with lifelong health complications.

The results add fresh evidence to a robust body of research on the harmful effects of exposure to air pollution, especially in young children—even before they're born.

"The ah-ha moment was probably just seeing what a large, estimated effect size we got," said lead author Joan Casey, who is a post-doctoral fellow at UC Berkeley. "We were pretty shocked by it—to the point that we did many, many additional analyses to try to make it go away, and didn't succeed."
California Power Plant Closures Coal Oil Preterm Births

Coal- and oil-fired power plants emit a bevy of air pollutants that have known negative impacts on public health—including fine particulate matter (or PM 2.5), nitrogen oxides, sulfur dioxides, benzene, lead and mercury.

Using birth records from the California Department of Public Health, the researchers found mothers who lived within 5 kilometers, 5-10 kilometers and 10-20 kilometers of the eight power plants. The women living farthest away provided a control group, since the authors assumed their exposure would be minimal.

Sign up for InsideClimate News Weekly

Our stories. Your inbox. Every weekend.

The authors controlled for many socioeconomic, behavioral, health, race and ethnicity factors affecting preterm birth. "That could account for things like Obamacare or the Great Recession or the housing crisis," Casey said.

The study found that the women living within 5 kilometers of the plants, those most exposed to the air pollution, saw a significant drop in preterm births.
Greater Impact on African American Women

In an accompanying commentary in the journal, Pauline Mendola, a senior investigator with the Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health and Human Development, wrote that the methods and creative design of the study add to its importance.

"The authors do an excellent job of testing alternative explanations for the observed associations and examining social factors that might increase vulnerability," she wrote.

Noel Mueller, an epidemiologist at Johns Hopkins University who also studies health impacts of air pollution, said one particularly notable and complicated finding was the greater impact on non-Hispanic African American and Asian women. African American women, in particular, are known to have higher rates of preterm childbirth.

"Studies like this highlight a potential role that environmental exposure might have in driving that disparity," he said. "I think that's really important."
What Happens When Air Pollution Continues

In a separate article published last week in the American Heart Association's journal Hypertension, Mueller examined what can happen when the pollution source is not eliminated.

In a study that looked at 1,293 mothers and their children in the Boston area, Mueller and his coauthors found that babies who were exposed to higher levels of particulate matter during the third trimester were significantly more likely to have high blood pressure in childhood.

Particulate matter can come from cars and the burning of coal, oil and biomass.

Casey, the author of the California study, said the findings from the two studies are related. "We know that preterm birth isn't the end of the outcomes for a child that is born early," she said.

Mueller said the same factors that can cause preterm labor, such as higher intrauterine inflammation, also could be causing higher blood pressure in children who have been exposed.

"It raises serious questions about whether we want to roll back any environmental regulations," Mueller said.

In her commentary on the California study, Mendola made a similar observation.  

"We all breathe. Even small increases in mortality due to ambient air pollution have a large population health impact," she wrote. "Of course, we need electricity and there are costs and benefits to all energy decisions, but at some point we should recognize that our failure to lower air pollution results in the death and disability of American infants and children."
Published Under:
Coal

    Email this page

    Printer-friendly version

About the Author
Sabrina Shankman
Sabrina Shankman

Sabrina Shankman is a reporter for InsideClimate News focusing on the Arctic. She joined ICN in the fall of 2013, after helping produce documentaries and interactives for the PBS show "Frontline" since 2010 with 2over10 Media. She is the author of the ICN book "Meltdown: Terror at the Top of the World," and was named a finalist for the Livingston Awards for Young Journalists for that work. Shankman has a Masters in Journalism from UC Berkeley's Graduate School of Journalism.

Your donation powers our nonprofit newsroom.

Our stories. Your inbox. Every weekend.
Most Popular
An environmental group installed solar panels atop Faith Community Church to sell the church cheap, clean electricity. Credit: NC WARN
How Solar Panels on a Church Rooftop Broke the Law in N.C.

By Dan Gearino
Sea Surface Temperatures. Credit: NOAA
The Most Powerful Evidence Climate Scientists Have of Global Warming

By Sabrina Shankman and Paul Horn
A satellite image captures algae blooms in Lake Erie in 2011. Toledo, Ohio, is at the southwestern tip of the lake. Credit: European Space Agency
Toxic Algae Blooms Occurring More Often, May Be Caught in Climate Change Feedback Loop

By Georgina Gustin
A solar farm is planned for Bent Mountain, a former coal mine in Kentucky's Pike County. Credit: Kenny Stanely/RH Group
Solar Plans for a Mined Kentucky Mountaintop Could Hinge on More Coal Mining

By James Bruggers
Pruitt’s Own Scientist Appointees Condemn EPA ‘Secret Science’ Policy
Pruitt’s Own Scientist Appointees Challenge EPA Science Restrictions

By Marianne Lavelle
InsideClimate News Launches National Environment Reporting Network
InsideClimate News Launches National Environment Reporting Network

By Staff
Key currents of the Atlantic ocean's overturning circulation. Credit: NASA
Scientists Say Ocean Circulation Is Slowing. Here’s Why You Should Care.

By Bob Berwyn
A fishing vessel crew unloads its catch off the coast of Virginia. Credit: Andrew Caballero-Reynolds/AFP/Getty ImagesA fishing vessel crew hauls in a catch off the coast of Virginia. Credit: Andrew Caballero-Reynolds/AFP/Getty Images
Fish Species Forecast to Migrate Hundreds of Miles Northward as U.S. Waters Warm

By Bob Berwyn
Tens of Thousands of Species Could Be Protected By Limiting Warming to 1.5 Degrees
Urgent Climate Action Required to Protect Tens of Thousands of Species Worldwide, New Research Shows

By John H. Cushman Jr., Neela Banerjee
Embattled Atlantic Coast Pipeline Faces Environmental Justice Complaint
Atlantic Coast Pipeline Faces Civil Rights Complaint After Key Permit Is Blocked

By Phil McKenna

Learn more about ICN's environmental journalism institute

Our Sponsors
View all sponsors
Follow

    facebook.com/insideclimatenews
    twitter.com/insideclimate

Related
Hydraulic fracturing site near a home in Pennsylvania. Credit: Anna Belle Peevey
Fracking Study Finds Low Birth Weights Near Natural Gas Drilling Sites

By Sabrina Shankman
‘This Is an Emergency’: 1 Million African Americans Live Near Oil, Gas Facilities

By Phil McKenna, Marianne Lavelle
Refinery in Richmond, California. Credit: Justin Sullivan/Getty Images
Top Oil Industry Group Disputes African-American Health Study, Cites Genetics

By Phil McKenna
EPA Administrator Scott Pruitt meets with coal miners in Pennsylvania. Credit: Justin Merriman/Getty Images
How Pruitt's EPA Is Delaying, Weakening and Repealing Clean Air Rules

By Marianne Lavelle
A coal truck leaves a power plant in Utah. Fossil fuel combustion in power plants and truck engines is a major producer of fine particulate matter linked to lung damage and other health problems. Credit: George Frey/Getty Images
How Pruitt’s New ‘Secret Science’ Policy Could Further Undermine Air Pollution Rules

By Marianne Lavelle

Subscribe to Clean Economy Weekly

Want More Stories Like This One?
Contribute To Our Staff
Donate Now
More Coal
A solar farm is planned for Bent Mountain, a former coal mine in Kentucky's Pike County. Credit: Kenny Stanely/RH Group
Solar Plans for a Mined Kentucky Mountaintop Could Hinge on More Coal Mining

By James Bruggers
In 2008, a coal ash containment area broke at the TVA's Kingston Fossil Plant, and 5.4 million cubic yards of coal ash washed downstream toward the Emory River. Credit: Brian Stansberry/CC-BY-3.0
Don't Gut Coal Ash Rules, Communities Beg EPA at Hearing

By Georgina Gustin
EPA Administrator Scott Pruitt meets with coal miners in Pennsylvania. Credit: Justin Merriman/Getty Images
How Pruitt's EPA Is Delaying, Weakening and Repealing Clean Air Rules

By Marianne Lavelle
More on Coal
Subscribe to InsideClimate News Email Newsletters

    Articles & Investigations
    Today's Climate
    Clean Economy
    Week in Review

Subscribe
More From The Author
Air Pollution From Coal Plants Tied to Premature Births
Premature Birth Rates Drop in California After Coal and Oil Plants Shut Down

By Sabrina Shankman
A map of average temperatures in degrees Celsius on May 8, 2018, show a warm spot near freezing over the Arctic. Credit: Climate Reanalyzer/University of Maine
Arctic Heat Surges Again, and Studies Are Finding Climate Change Connections

By Sabrina Shankman
In coastal Alaska, communities count on winter sea ice to buffer the shore from damaging waves. The ice is disappearing and erosion is getting worse as the Arctic warms twice as fast the global average. Credit: Sabrina Shankman
Kids Challenge Alaska’s Climate Paradox: The State Promotes Oil as Global Warming Wreaks Havoc

By Sabrina Shankman
More by Sabrina Shankman

    Whistleblowers Jobs & Freelance Policies & Legal Our E-Books

Keep Environmental Journalism Alive
Donate Now

    News Investigations Topics Today's Climate Clean Economy Middle Ground Infographics