The Week UK: US Who wrote the Donald Trump editorial?

We use cookies as set out in our privacy policy. By using this website, you agree we may
The Week UK



US
Who wrote the Donald Trump editorial?
Sep 7, 2018
With the president on the war path, The Week looks at the most likely culprits              
    
    

Yuri Gripas/AFP/Getty Images

Donald Trump wasted no time labelling the author of an anonymous New York Times editorial detailing chaos in his White House a traitor.
See related
Would Donald Trump ever accept election defeat?
Donald Trump: the most explosive highlights from Bob Woodward’s book
Will Donald Trump be impeached?

The damning op-ed by a “senior administration official” has divided opinion and sparked a Washington guessing game about who the author could be – and what their real motives are.

The Week looks at five of the most likely culprits:
The vice president

The theory that Vice President Mike Pence wrote the article largely stems from its use of the word “lodestar”.

The New York Times piece refers to the late Republican Senator John McCain as a “lodestar for restoring honour to public life and our national dialogue”.

The term, meaning “star that leads or guides”, is a relatively rare word, but “one which the vice-president has frequently used”, says the BBC.

“The vice president is all smiles, nods and quiet, deferential loyalty in public, which of course means that he has the perfect cover to write something like this in The New York Times” says CNN, adding he “is also ambitious - and there's no question he wants to be president”.
The ‘resistance’

Newly-released extracts from veteran journalist Bob Woodward’s explosive tell-all book about life inside the Trump White House paint a portrait of a president effectively kept in check by those around him.

The anonymous author of the op-ed termed this group “the resistance”. It is not known exactly who is part of this not-so-secret cabal keeping the world safe but several senior White House officials have been implicated.

Secretary of State Mike Pompeo has fiercely denied writing the editorial, attacking the writer as a “disgruntled deceptive bad actor”.

Daniel Coats, the director of national intelligence, also issued a denial saying the speculation that he or his deputy wrote the op-ed was “patently false”, reports The Guardian.

The Independent reports that some of Trump's supporters have suggested that the Times op-ed is part of a “trap” and a “soft coup” against the Republican leader.

Andy Smarick, conservative policy expert at R Street, suggests the culprit might be driven by more personal reasons, writing on Twitter: “It is an apologia. Someone is doing his/her best to defend and explain his/her decision to work there.... I suspect that the author — and others in similar situations — recognizes that the chances of the future judging this administration kindly are now infinitesimal.”
The Republicans

This brings us to the president’s own party, the majority of whom have remained remarkably loyal and/or silent over the past two years.

But with numerous scandals brewing and the president’s approval ratings tanking, some believe the letter was a “PR stunt” designed to distance the Republican Party from Trump in the run-up to November's mid-term elections.
The New York Times

The theory that New York Times hacks penned the op-ed themselves, posited by the president himself, has little going for it apart from playing into Trump’s narrative about a coordinated liberal media conspiracy to bring him down, led by the “failing” New York Times.

If it did by any chance turn out to be true, however, it is not unreasonable to think it could be the nail in the coffin for America’s paper of record.
Donald Trump

Admittedly more than a little far-fetched, this theory makes more sense when viewed in the context of the prevalent idea among Trump’s loyal support base that the establishment is conspiring to undermine the president.

To this end, the BBC’s North America editor Jon Sopel suggested the article would play into Trump’s long-standing narrative of a deep state operating behind the scenes to thwart him.
Advertisement

Read more: US
Donald Trump
White House
Republicans
Mike Pence
Advertisement
Advertisement
You are here:

    HomeWho wrote the Donald Trump editorial?

Related Articles

    The White House
    One-Minute Read
    Who wrote the Donald Trump editorial?
    Kevin Spacey in House of Cards
    One-Minute Read
    House of Cards: Frank Underwood killed off
    Roy Moore has sued Sasha Baron Cohen for defamation
    One-Minute Read
    Roy Moore sues Sasha Baron Cohen
    Donald Trump slams anonymous senior aide over New York Times op-ed
    Donald Trump
    Donald Trump thwarted by White House ‘resistance’
    Donald Trump NFL
    NFL
    Trump: Nike’s Kaepernick advert sends ‘terrible message’
    Eric Reid, Colin Kaepernick and Eli Harold kneel for the national anthem
    One-Minute Read
    Nike shares fall as customers burn shoes over Kaepernick
    Donald Trump
    In Depth
    Everything Donald Trump has threatened to quit
    Kate McClure and Johnny Bobbitt in happier times
    One-Minute Read
    Homeless man sues couple who raised $400,000 for him

Advertisement
The Week Magazine
Find out how The Week works
VIEW
Portfolio

The experts' guide to good living

    The best crime dramas 2018
    Four of the best holiday castles in Britain and Ireland
    I-Pace: Jaguar’s answer to Tesla

Read more
Popular

    What is the Momo suicide challenge and is it linked to young players’ deaths?
    World News
    Who are the Illuminati and what do they control?
    Entertainment
    How did Avicii die?
    World News
    Strange conspiracy theories: from Jesus and JFK to Prince Charles and Elvis
    World News
    The best crime dramas 2018
    Culture

Trending Topics

    Donald Trump
    Brexit
    House prices
    Cultural appropriation
    Kensington Palace
    Islamic State

Daily Briefing

Ten things you need to know today
In partnership with Rolex

    Blair doubts Labour can be ‘taken back by moderates’
    GCHQ boss warns threat from Russia is ‘active’
    British Airways investigates huge data leak

Read more
Our Latest Offers, Competitions and Events

    Our latest offers and competitions
    Latest offers and events
    Outstanding wines that won't break the bank

FIND OUT MORE
Back to top

    FacebookTwitter

    NewsSportBusinessTechnologyCars MoneyPortfolioPodcastSubscriptionsOffers

    The Week US
    Email newsletter
    Privacy Policy
    Cookie Policy
    RSS
    Sitemap
    Contact us
    Authors
    About us

© Copyright The Week Ltd which is a subsidiary of Dennis Publishing Limited.
The Week incorporates The First Post. The Week™ and The First Post™ are trademarks of Felix Dennis.

    Felix DennisJobsMedia InformationSubscription EnquiresBooksAppsYour Online Choices

Sign up for our daily newsletter
Newsletter