MIT Technology Review/Will Knight: China may overtake the US with the best AI research in just two years

MIT Technology Review
Intelligent Machines

China may overtake the US with the best AI research in just two years

The number of influential AI research papers coming from China is increasing rapidly, a data analysis shows.

    by Will Knight March 13, 2019

White House plans to cut funding for science couldn’t come at a worse time for the country’s ambitions to lead the world in artificial intelligence.

The most detailed analysis of Chinese AI research papers yet suggests that China is gaining on the US more quickly than previously thought.

China’s vibrant tech scene has come up with a number of  recent breakthroughs, and the government has recently launched a major initiative to dominate the development of the technology within a matter of years (see “China’s AI awakening”).
Sign up for the The Algorithm
Artificial intelligence, demystified
Stay updated on MIT Technology Review initiatives and events?

    YesNo

Still, it isn’t easy to measure progress in a broad and complex area of technology like artificial intelligence. Previous studies have shown that China already produces a larger number of research papers mentioning AI terms like “deep learning.” But it has always been difficult to ascertain the quality of that research.

The new study aims to solve that problem. It comes from the Allen Institute for Artificial Intelligence (Ai2), a nonprofit in Seattle created by Microsoft cofounder Paul Allen that is focused on fundamental AI research. The institute previously created a tool, called Semantic Scholar, that uses artificial intelligence to make it easier to search and analyze scientific research papers published online.

Using this tool, Ai2’s researchers examined not just the number of AI research papers coming from China but the quality of those papers—as judged by the number of citations they receive in other work. The study suggests that China will overtake the US in the most-cited 50% of research papers this year, the top 10% of research papers in 2020, and the top 1% by 2025.
The top 50% of AI research papers, by citations.
How Chin and the US share the top 50% of AI research papers, by citations, over time.
Allen INstitute for Artificial Intelligence

“Our economy and security has benefited greatly from the cutting-edge research being home grown in our universities and research institutes,” says Oren Etzioni, CTO of Ai2 and a leading AI researcher.“We need to urgently increase AI research funding, and commit to visas for AI students and experts.”

But there are reasons to be cautious about this research, too.

Kai-Fu Lee, a prominent Chinese AI investor who previously established both Microsoft’s and Google’s outposts in China, says the study may overstate things a bit. “There’s definitely momentum,” he said by phone from Beijing, “but the time horizon is farther out.”

Lee, who is the author of a recent book on AI in China,  AI Superpowers: China, Silicon Valley, and the New World Order, says the US still boasts the vast majority of the world’s most influential scientific thinkers, according to measures of an individual’s citations (the US is also still far ahead of China in terms of “best paper awards” at major conferences). “Had there not been a Geoff Hinton or a Yann LeCun,” he says, referring to two AI researchers based in Canada and the US, respectively, “would there have been deep learning?”

Lee is also hopeful that people don’t lose sight of overall scientific progress when talking about the “AI race” between the US and China.

Etzioni agrees that openly published scientific research can benefit everyone, regardless of its country of origin, but he believes the study should  serve as a wake-up call to the US government. “If we move to second place, will the next Google be founded here or in China?” he says. “It’s not a zero-sum game, but it isn’t a picnic either.”

Keep up with the latest in artificial intelligence at EmTech Digital.

The Countdown has begun.
March 25-26, 2019
San Francisco, CA
Register now
The top 50% of AI research papers, by citations.
Share

Will Knight

Will Knight Senior Editor, AI

Will Knight is MIT Technology Review’s Senior Editor for Artificial Intelligence. He covers the latest advances in AI and related fields, including machine learning, automated driving, and robotics. Will joined MIT Technology Review in… More
Related Video

More videos

Intelligent Machines
Next-Generation Robots Need Your Help 27:36

Intelligent Machines
AI's Economic Impact 35:20

Intelligent Machines
Autonomous Vehicles and Urban Transportation 28:38
More from Intelligent Machines

Artificial intelligence and robots are transforming how we work and live.

    No, IBM didn’t just “reverse time” with a quantum computer

    Amazing headlines about time machines are a long way off the mark, sadly.

    by Konstantin Kakaes
    Quantum computing should supercharge this machine-learning technique

    Certain machine-learning tasks could be revolutionized by more powerful quantum computers.

    by Will Knight
    Drones that perch like birds could go on much longer flights

    A simple gripping mechanism allows unmanned aerial vehicles to save energy by resting on ledges and poles.

    by Erin Winick

More from Intelligent Machines
From Our Advertisers

    In association with VMware
    Digital transformation sparks innovation in networking

    In association with Google
    For data-savvy marketers, there’s a new keyword: Intent

    In association with Google
    Machine learning teaches marketers to cultivate a growth mindset

    In association with Oracle and Intel
    Machine learning - driven analytics: Key to digital transformation

Want more award-winning journalism? Subscribe to MIT Technology Review.

    Print + All Access Digital $79.95/year* Best Value

    The best of MIT Technology Review in print and online, plus unlimited access to our online archive, an ad-free web experience, discounts to MIT Technology Review events, and The Download delivered to your email in-box each weekday.
    Subscribe

      
    See details+
    All Access Digital $35.95/year

    The digital magazine, plus unlimited site access, our online archive, and The Download delivered to your email in-box each weekday.
    Subscribe

      
    See details+
    Print Subscription $55.95/year*

    Six print issues per year plus The Download delivered to your email in-box each weekday.
    Subscribe

      
    See details+

* Prices are for U.S. residents only

See international prices
The Algorithm Artificial intelligence, demystified
Stay updated on MIT Technology Review initiatives and events?

    YesNo

Follow us
Twitter Facebook RSS
MIT Technology Review

The mission of MIT Technology Review is to bring about better-informed and more conscious decisions about technology through authoritative, influential, and trustworthy journalism.

Browse
International
Editions

    Company
    Your Account
    Customer Support
    More
    Policies

MIT Technology Review © 2019 v.|eiπ|
1/3
You've read one of three free articles this month. Log in for more, or subscribe now for unlimited online access.