The Week UK: UN to set up global ‘snooper’s league table’

The Week UK
   
World News
UN to set up global ‘snooper’s league table’
Mar 1, 2019
Human rights expert to measure countries’ privacy safeguards                                
     

The United Nations has taken the first step towards creating a league table of global governments that conduct the most surveillance on their own citizens.
See related
Does the UK counter-terrorism bill threaten free speech?
Has Facebook turned a corner after 2018’s privacy scandals?

UN special rapporteur on the right to privacy, Joseph Cannataci, has submitted a draft list of questions that measure countries’ privacy safeguards to the UN Human Rights Council for comment.

The 28-question survey, which covers everything from chatroom monitoring to systematic surveillance, begins with a potential five points if a country’s constitution had a provision to protect privacy.

“Other questions range from parliamentary and judicial oversight of surveillance and intelligence activities, profiling of civilians, and the use of 'bulk powers' — such as downloading an entire set of phone records rather than getting a judge’s permission to listen into one call,” says Reuters.

The final question asks: “Does your country have a police and/or intelligence service which systematically profiles and maintains surveillance on large segments of the population in a manner comparable to that of the Stasi in the 1955-1990 GDR (East Germany)?”

The rankings system is part of Cannataci’s wider brief investigating digital privacy, which was created by the Human Rights Council in 2015 in response to the Edward Snowden revelations about US surveillance.

Reuters reports that “the council’s 47 member states are not be obliged to agree with his findings, but special rapporteurs’ reports are generally influential in a forum where governments are keen to appear to have an unblemished human rights record”.

Earlier this month Cannataci slammed plans by the UK government to make it an offence to view terrorist material online just once.

Under the Counter-Terrorism and Border Security Bill, which was granted Royal Assent in mid-February, a maximum penalty for viewing some types of terrorist information – even once – is 15 years imprisonment.

On a visit to the UK, Cannataci said the new law risked “pushing a bit too much towards thought crime”.

The UN official said “the difference between forming the intention to do something and then actually carrying out the act is still fundamental to criminal law… here you're saying: ‘You've read it three times so you must be doing something wrong.”

The Register says government has argued the law still provides for the existing “reasonable excuse defence”, “which includes circumstances where a person ‘did not know, and had no reason to believe’ the material accessed contained terrorist propaganda”.

Read more: World News
Privacy
Terrorism
You are here:

    HomeUN to set up global ‘snooper’s league table’

Related Articles

    Hamza bin Laden
    In Depth
    Who is Hamza bin Laden?
    Russia Ship South Korea
    One-Minute Read
    Ship with ‘drunk’ captain crashes into motorway bridge
    Indonesia mine collapse
    One-Minute Read
    Indonesia mine collapse: race to rescue dozens
    Former Facebook content moderator is suing the tech giant for causing PTSD
    The Week Unwrapped
    The Week Unwrapped: Horror jobs, 5G and arguing with kids
    Odd News
    Condoms found to clean kitchen taps
    One-Minute Read
    Benjamin Netanyahu indicted for corruption
    One-Minute Read
    UN to set up global ‘snooper’s league table’
    Former Trump lawyer Michael Cohen will testify at the House Oversight and Reform Committee
    In Depth
    How does impeachment work?

The Week Magazine
Take a look at what's inside
VIEW
Portfolio

The experts' guide to good living

    The bumper market for collectable comics
    The best European holiday destinations this spring
    Best restaurants for Shrove Tuesday pancakes across the UK

Read more
Popular

    Momo challenge: what is it and how did the hoax begin?
    World News
    Momo challenge spliced into Peppa Pig and Fortnite videos, warns school
    Technology
    Ferrari F8 Tributo 2019: first images, prices, specs and release date
    Motoring
    Jared Kushner ‘arranging return of Christ’
    World News
    Ferrari F8 Tributo 2019: first images, prices, specs and release date

Trending Topics

    Donald Trump
    Brexit
    House prices
    Cultural appropriation
    Kensington Palace
    Islamic State

Daily Briefing

Ten things you need to know today

    US offers $1m reward for bin Laden son
    Umunna named spokesperson of Independent Group
    North Korea disputes Trump account of talks

Read more
Our Latest Offers, Competitions and Events

    Our latest offers and competitions
    Latest offers and events
    Outstanding wines that won't break the bank

FIND OUT MORE
Back to top

    FacebookTwitter

    News
    Sport
    Business
    Technology
    Cars
    Money
    Portfolio
    Podcast
    Subscriptions
    Offers

    The Week US
    Email newsletter
    Privacy Policy
    Cookie Policy
    RSS
    Sitemap
    Contact us
    Authors
    About us
    Privacy Preferences

© Copyright The Week Ltd which is a subsidiary of Dennis Publishing Limited.
The Week incorporates The First Post. The Week™ and The First Post™ are trademarks of Felix Dennis.

    Felix DennisJobsMedia InformationSubscription EnquiresBooksAppsYour Online Choices