The Guardian/Sarah Marsh: Kim Darroch: Johnson joins defence of press over cables publication

The Guardian

Press freedom
Kim Darroch: Johnson joins defence of press over cables publication

Fellow Tory Michael Fallon had suggested journalists should be subject to Official Secrets Act

Sarah Marsh
@sloumarsh

Sat 13 Jul 2019 12.30 BST
First published on Sat 13 Jul 2019 05.21 BST

Shares
294
Boris Johnson, said punishing the press for publishing the leaked cables would amount to ‘an infringement of press freedom.

Boris Johnson has come out in defence of the right of the press to publish leaked diplomatic dispatches sent by the former British ambassador to the US Sir Kim Darroch, saying it would amount to “an infringement on press freedom and have a chilling effect on public debate”.
Advertisement

Johnson criticised the police over a warning to journalists that they could face prosecution if they publish any further leaked cables. Speaking at a Tory leadership hustings at Wyboston in Bedfordshire, he said that while it was right the perpetrator of the leak was “hunted down and prosecuted” it was wrong for police to target the media.

“It cannot conceivably be right that newspapers or any other media organisation publishing such material face prosecution,” he added.
Advertisement

“In my view there is no threat to national security implied in the release of this material. It is embarrassing, but it is not a threat to national security. It is the duty of media organisations to bring new and interesting facts into the public domain. That is what they are there for.”
Advertisement

His comments came after Hunt, the foreign secretary, who is battling with Johnson to be the next Conservative prime minister, said he would “defend to the hilt” the right of the press to publish the leaks.
Advertisement

Hunt wrote on Twitter: “These leaks damaged UK/US relations and cost a loyal ambassador his job, so the person responsible must be held fully to account. But I defend to the hilt the right of the press to publish those leaks if they receive them and judge them to be in the public interest: that is their job.”
Q&A
What did Sir Kim Darroch write about Trump in the cables?
Advertisement

The Metropolitan police has launched a criminal investigation into the leak of the messages, which were sent to the Mail on Sunday. The UK’s largest police force threatened the media with prosecution for publishing the dispatches.

George Osborne and other editors accused Scotland Yard of encroaching on press freedom. The inquiry by the Met counter-terrorism command, which is responsible for investigating breaches of the Official Secrets Act, was announced in a statement attributed to the assistant commissioner Neil Basu.

His words were echoed by the executive director of the Society of Editors, Ian Murray, who said: “I cannot think of a worse example of a heavy-handed approach by the police to attempt to curtail the role of the media as a defence against the powerful and those in authority.” He said it was the kind of approach that would be expected from a totalitarian regime.

Earlier, former defence secretary Michael Fallon suggested journalists should be subject to the Official Secrets Act. Speaking on BBC Radio 4’s Today programme on Saturday, Fallon welcomed the Met investigation, describing the leak as a “clear breach of the Official Secrets Act” and “damaging to diplomatic efforts”.

He added: “As soon as we find who did it, we should have them investigated and prosecuted.” Fallon said the advice to newspapers about not publishing the material was “quite logical”.
Quick guide
Who could be prosecuted over the leak?

He added: “If they are receiving stolen material then they should give it back to the rightful owner and should be aware of the huge damage done and potential greater damage by further breaches of the Official Secrets Act.”

Fallon was then asked by the presenter, John Humphrys, whether journalists should comply with the act. He responded: “I don’t think anyone can entirely absolve themselves of the need to avoid damage to this country.

“We have press freedom … but we also have laws. We have the Official Secrets Act and it is important that law is upheld.”
Guardian Today: the headlines, the analysis, the debate - sent direct to you
Read more

When news of the Met police inquiry broke, Osborne, the former chancellor and now editor of the Evening Standard, appeared to suggest the statement, which called for any leaked documents to be returned to the government, was written by a junior officer and showed a lack of understanding of press freedom.

The statement said: “The publication of leaked communications, knowing the damage they have caused or are likely to cause, may also be a criminal matter.

“I would advise all owners, editors and publishers of social and mainstream media not to publish leaked government documents that may already be in their possession, or which may be offered to them, and to turn them over to the police or give them back to their rightful owner, Her Majesty’s government.”
Q&A
What did Sir Kim Darroch write about Trump in the cables?

Osborne described the statement as ill-advised, saying: “If I were the Metropolitan police commissioner, and I wanted to maintain my credibility and the credibility of my force, I would quickly distance myself from this very stupid and ill-advised statement from a junior officer who doesn’t appear to understand much about press freedom.”

On Saturday he tweeted:

    George Osborne (@George_Osborne)

    What a mess the Met Police have got themselves into attacking press freedom. No prosecution would have a chance of succeeding anyway. I predict a u-turn today by Commissioner overruling Mr Basu; if they stick with his threats to the media then there will be calls for resignations
    July 13, 2019

Tim Shipman, the Sunday Times political editor, criticised the “sinister, absurd, anti-democratic statement this evening threatening journalists with arrest for printing government leaks”, and asked the Met on Twitter: “Do you have any comprehension of a free society? This isn’t Russia.” The Liberal Democrat MP Norman Lamb said the remarks suggested a “slippery slope to a police state”.

Speaking at the Tory hustings, Johnson said: “In my view there is no threat to national security implied the release of this material. It is embarrassing, but it is not a threat to national security.

“It is the duty of media organisations to bring new and interesting facts into the public domain. That is what they are there for. A prosecution on this basis would amount to an infringement on press freedom and have a chilling effect on public debate. That is my view.”

Darroch announced he was resigning on Wednesday, saying his position had become impossible following the leak of dispatches in which he described Donald Trump’s White House as inept and dysfunctional.

The comments drew a furious response from the US president, who said the White House would no longer deal with Darroch.

In the House of Commons on Thursday, the Foreign Office minister Alan Duncan said an internal Whitehall inquiry had found no evidence the leak was the result of computer hacking. Instead, he told MPs the focus was on finding “someone within the system who has released illicitly these communications”.

The chair of the foreign affairs select committee, Tom Tugendhat, questioned whether journalists who published such material were committing an offence. “I doubt it is a crime to publish. The ability to have a free press is essential,” he said.
Topics

    Press freedom

    Foreign policy
    Jeremy Hunt
    Official Secrets Act
    Michael Fallon
    George Osborne
    Metropolitan police
    news

    Share on LinkedIn
    Share on Pinterest
    Share on WhatsApp
    Share on Messenger

more on this story

    Met police launch investigation into leaked Darroch cables
    2d
    Met police launch investigation into leaked Darroch cables
    Boris Johnson claims he supports Kim Darroch amid Tory criticism
    3d
    Boris Johnson claims he supports Kim Darroch amid Tory criticism
    Johnson has thrown US ambassador under the bus, say top Tories
    4d
    Johnson has thrown US ambassador under the bus, say top Tories
    Our man in the US wins scant support from either party leader
    John Crace
    4d
    1,374
    Our man in the US wins scant support from either party leader

        Kim Darroch: urbane diplomat who knew how to throw a party
        4d
        Kim Darroch: urbane diplomat who knew how to throw a party
        Kim Darroch has resigned. Now Britain risks becoming a vassal of the US
        Martin Kettle
        4d
        742
        Kim Darroch has resigned. Now Britain risks becoming a vassal of the US

promoted linksfrom around the web
Recommended by OutbrainAbout this Content

    Luxury Condos at a Glance: Tour the World's Finest Luxury… Mansion Global
    Everyone In Ghana Is Going Crazy Over This Cheap WiFi Booster Everyone In… mrgadgetpro.com

Most popular

    UK
    UK politics
    Education
    Media
    Society
    Law
    Scotland
    Wales
    Northern Ireland

    News
    Opinion
    Sport
    Culture
    Lifestyle

    Contact us
    Complaints & corrections
    SecureDrop
    Work for us
    Privacy policy
    Cookie policy
    Terms & conditions
    Help

    All topics
    All writers
    Digital newspaper archive
    Facebook
    Twitter

    Advertise with us
    Search UK jobs
    Dating
    Discount Codes

Support The Guardian
Available for everyone, funded by readers
Contribute
Subscribe
Back to top
© 2019 Guardian News & Media Limited or its affiliated companies. All rights reserved.