Energy Manager Today
News and Best Practices for
Commercial & Industrial Energy Managers
INTL FC Stone - Click Here.
NYC Sues Oil Industry, Saying ‘Greed’ Put State at Risk; Oil Giants Say No
January 15, 2018 by Ken Silverstein
New York City is suing BP, Chevron, ConocoPhillips, Exxon Mobil and Royal Dutch Shell, saying that each has contributed to global warming and has cost the city billions of dollars as it has tried to mitigate the harm done from such things as deviant weather patterns. The oil giants, though, are firing back, noting that they are on board with efforts to reduce heat-trapping emissions.
The Associated Press broke the story, all part of a much longer saga in which the city’s pensions have said that they would divest from fossil fuel holdings. The state, meanwhile, has gone after ExxonMobile Corp., saying that the oil giant had purposely mislead investors about what it knew about climate change and when it knew it.
“(W)e’re bringing the fight against climate change straight to the fossil fuel companies that knew about its effects and intentionally misled the public to protect their profits,” Mayor Bill de Blasio said, in a statement. “As climate change continues to worsen, it’s up to the fossil fuel companies whose greed put us in this position to shoulder the cost of making New York safer and more resilient.”
Beyond the allegations that Exxon knew about the risk of climate change four decades ago but didn’t reveal its knowledge, New York State is also alleging that between 2010 and 2014, Exxon used “secret internal figures” that were less than the numbers it had provided to investors: Internally, it applied a cost of $40 per ton of CO2 in 2030 while externally, it said it had been using $60 a ton in 2030. That made the company’s financials look better, the state’s attorney general alleges.
For their part, the environmental activists are exploring all of their options in an effort to lessen the effects of climate change. Their approach is similar to the one taken against the tobacco industry, which knew of the dangers of smoking but which had failed to tell consumers. A key difference, though, is that fossil fuels have long been an essential commodity whereas tobacco is a discretionary product.
However, the Center for International Environmental Law has uncovered evidence that Exxon’s oil executives knew of the coming climate phenomenon: In 1968, the Stanford Research Institute issued a paper to the American Petroleum Institute saying that environmental changes could jeopardize the earth’s future.
“These documents are the tip of an evidentiary iceberg that demands further investigation,” Carroll Muffett, head of the environmental center, has said “Oil companies had an early opportunity to acknowledge climate science and climate risks, and to enable consumers to make informed choices. They chose a different path. The public deserves to know why.”
Ironically, that move comes atop a formal pledge by ConocoPhillips, Gazprom, StatOil, Roy Dutch Shell and Total that they are supporting a global pact to achieve the carbon goals. Those oil companies are already investing in alternative resources.
For Exxon’s part, it says that the information it had nearly four decades ago was not conclusive. But it quickly adds that today a lot more is known — and that climate change is real and that everyone needs to do their part.
“ExxonMobil welcomes any well-meaning and good faith attempt to address the risks of climate change. Reducing greenhouse gas emissions is a global issue and requires global participation and actions,” Exxon said in a statement, following New York’s announcement to divest. “Lawsuits of this kind — filed by trial attorneys against an industry that provides products we all rely upon to power the economy and enable our domestic life – simply do not do that.”
With respect to divestiture, investment fund managers collectively control trillions and money does talk. Hence, the threat of mass withdrawals of cash that provide the fuel to expand their businesses is a powerful weapon. But it is a strategy that should be carefully considered — not one to smear all fossil fuels, which have promoted prosperity and lifted the impoverished throughout the world.
The model is formulated at least in part after the successful anti-Apartheid movement that took place in the 1980s to give blacks equal rights in South Africa. There, 125 major corporations such as General Electric said that they would pull up stakes unless the practice ended. And, it’s a strategy endorsed by this writer to punish gun makers that are ignoring the pubic’s will, which demands universal background checks and other safety measures.
Studies vary on whether shareholder activism is actually a productive way to drive change and to increase returns. One side argues that the goodwill generated by investing in cleaner energies is enduring and that it goes to the bottom line. Others, though, say that fund managers should concentrate exclusively on building shareholder value — that such a tack is the best way to serve society.
Categories Energy Management, Featured, Financial, Industrial, SustainabilityTags ExxonMobil, new york city, oil industry
Post navigation
Low-Hanging LEDs Still the Apple of an Organization’s Eye
Choosing the Correct Emission Control Technology
Sponsored By: Anguil Environmental Systems
Planning for a Sustainable Future
Sponsored By: Dakota Software
10 Tactics of Successful Energy Managers
Sponsored By: EnergyCap, Inc.
The EHS Guidebook: Selecting, Implementing, and Using EHS Software Solutions
Sponsored By: EtQ
Leave a Comment
NEWSLETTER
NEWSLETTER SIGNUP
Join 100,000+ subscribers who gain a competitive advantage with our news and analysis.
Select the newsletters that interest you: Energy Manager Today Newsletter (Mon, Wed, Fri) Environmental Leader Newsletter (Mon, Wed, Fri)
Energy Manager Today - Click Here.
Leaders Leading
Marty Sedler, Director, Global Utilities and Infrastructure, Sr. PE – Intel Corporation
Upcoming Webinars
Negotiating Energy Contracts – 10 Terms You Need...
Best Practices
Beyond Energy Management
Read More Best Practices
Sponsored By Transformative Wave
2:36
Facebook
Twitter
Embed
Wistia video thumbnail - Transformative Wave - Heating Ventilation and Air Conditioning
FEATURED SUPPLIERS
FS-Elliott
Digital Lumens
Call2Recycle, Inc.
EtQ
EnerNOC, Inc.
Anguil Environmental Systems
Progressly
View All Suppliers >
WHITE PAPERS
Achieving Digital Transformation through Operational Excellence
Sponsored By:
Progressly
9 Ways Mobility Enables Companies to Streamline Daily Operations
Sponsored By:
Progressly
Datasheet Track and Manage Field Operations
Sponsored By:
Progressly
Wake Up To The Future of Work Operational Performance Management
Sponsored By:
Progressly
5 Reasons To Make the Switch from Scantron
Sponsored By:
Progressly
6 Things to Consider When Deciding Whether to Build or Buy Software
Sponsored By:
Progressly
How to Unsilo Your EHS Data
Sponsored By:
Progressly
Just the Facts 8 Popular Misconceptions about LEDs Controls
Sponsored By:
Digital Lumens
How TrackingManaging Energy Consumption Drives Real Cost Savings
Sponsored By:
Digital Lumens
Your Guide to the Benefits of Centrifugal Compressors
Sponsored By:
FS-Elliott
View All White Papers >
UPCOMING WEBINARS
ON DEMAND WEBINARS
Negotiating Energy Contracts – 10 Terms You Need to Know
Mexico’s Deregulated Energy Markets: How to Reduce Costs and Protect Budgets
Why Aligning Renewable and Commodity Energy Purchases Makes Strategic Sense
The EHS Manager’s Priorities in 2017: Predict and Prevent
From Isolated to Integrated: How to Eliminate the Redundancies and Inefficiencies of Independent EHS Systems
See More Webinars >
FOLLOW US social-footer-twittersocial-footer-linkedinsocial-footer-facebooksocial-footer-googlesocial-footer-youtubesocial-footer-rss
PRIVACY POLICY | ABOUT US | SEND A STORY | ADVERTISE
© Copyright 2018 Energy Manager Today ® is a registered trademark of Business Sector Media LLC.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
No comments:
Post a Comment